I have a XDS 45 since before the recall, accurate, easy to pocket carry, limited capacity. I have a Rock Island 1911 Officers Model with a 3.5" barrel, 7+1, Very Accurate, needs IWB or OWB.
XD 45 SC Mod 2, Accurate, 9+1, 13 round reloads, accurate, IWB or OWB. S&W M&P Shield (bigger than a 9 MM Shield) too big for pocket carry, I haven't shot it yet.
EDIT: I have shot the Shield, it shoots well. I like shooting it a little better than the XDS and the S&W has one more round standard (both XDS and S&W have seven round extended magazines), but the XDS has better sights for me, and is pocketable, so the XDS a little more versatile.