One in the chamber? Or not!!

One in the Chamber

Always! In regards to the safety on or off....depends on whether or not the gun actually has a "safety". As others have posted, many guns; ie Glocks, have an inherent saftey, like a Safe Trigger. Now a gun like a 1911 in condition one, Cocked and Locked, gives some the HeeBeeJeeBees. No need to fret if you carry this way as long as you keep the thumb safety in the up (on) position. The gun is designed to fit the hand in such a way that when you draw the weapon, your thumb is in a natural position near the safety to tick it down into the fire position. It's a great gun!

Surfcc
 
It's kind of amazing this thread goes on so long. The bottom line is that a gun with an empty chamber is pretty much useless for self defense. It's not a matter of opinion, it's a fact that isn't really debatable. If you carry with an empty chamber then you are just making yourself more likely to become a victim who looks foolish after being shot because you had to try to cycle a round into the chamber before you're gun was ready to fire.
If you're going to carry then you need to just sack up and carry more than a paper weight.

That's true only if you can't quickly chamber a round. I don't carry with an empty chamber, but for those who do, I won't say that it's useless they can't chamber one very quickly.
 
I actually like my decocker ( allthough i am not too closed minded to see the advantages of other setups and feel it is a personal preferance, but please take the time to get to know your firearm.) I usually use mine as a safer way to release the hammer and drop it with my thumb, better than pulling the trigger if the thumb slips off without the other thumb underneath. and allways point it in a safe direction applys to decocking at least 10 times over.
 
It's kind of amazing this thread goes on so long. The bottom line is that a gun with an empty chamber is pretty much useless for self defense. It's not a matter of opinion, it's a fact that isn't really debatable. If you carry with an empty chamber then you are just making yourself more likely to become a victim who looks foolish after being shot because you had to try to cycle a round into the chamber before you're gun was ready to fire.
If you're going to carry then you need to just sack up and carry more than a paper weight.


I want go as far as to say that if you do not have a round chambered it is useless but it is for sure slower than having a round in the chamber. That extra split second may be the difference between life and death.
 
I want go as far as to say that if you do not have a round chambered it is useless but it is for sure slower than having a round in the chamber. That extra split second may be the difference between life and death.

Which is why it pays to be aware of your surroundings at all times, round chambered or not.
 
One in the chamber

When I was a sergeant for a security service in Indianapolis, I pulled an inspection on my men one day. One of them had a Ruger Security Six, and he had five rounds in the cylinder, and I asked him why. He said he always heard you had to carry an empty chamber under the hammer for safety. I told him that was true of the old, old, old Colt Single Action Army, as it had no safety device to prevent the hammer from striking the firing pin if bumped. Modern Double Action revolvers were safe to carry fully loaded,and you could pound the hammer on the sidewalk until it broke off and it would not fire. I told him to carry six rounds, as someday he might just need it to save his life.

When the sheriff's department in Arizona allowed us to carry autopistols, I carried the 1911. After many many hours of practice, drawing holstering and firing, I carried it cocked and locked, which I was informed by our dept armorer that was the way John Browning meant the .45 to be carried. Now that I am a civilian again, I carry a compact .45ACP on the 1911 model. After much carry and practice, I am not comfortable witht he ambi safety as it walks off, so I carry it hammer down on a loaded chamber. Thumbing the hammer back is second nature to me now. This gives me 6 in the mag and one in the tube, and the thumb-cocking has replaced the safety sweep for me. It is all in how you train. In police work, you constantly hear that under stress, you revert to your training.

The statistic of 21 seconds for a knife attack, comes from the Calibre Press film 'Surviving Edged Weapons,' which we were required to view and it was noted in our jacket. An average person, not even an athlete, can run uphill 21 feet and stab or siice you before you can draw and fire. Most of the film was demonstrating how to overcome this. Sorry, kwo, but they showed the fallacy of backpedaling and drawing. They used a number of security and police officers in scenarios against Tino Insana, and every one of them was 'killed.' After proper training, they were able to defend themselves.

Great discussion.
 
Last edited:
When I was a sergeant for a security service in Indianapolis, I pulled an inspection on my men one day. One of them had a Ruger Security Six, and he had five rounds in the cylinder, and I asked him why. He said he always heard you had to carry an empty chamber under the hammer for safety. I told him that was true of the old, old, old Colt Single Action Army, as it had no safety device to prevent the hammer from striking the firing pin if bumped. Modern Double Action revolvers were safe to carry fully loaded,and you could pound the hammer on the sidewalk until it broke off and it would not fire. I told him to carry six rounds, as someday he might just need it to save his life.

When the sheriff's department in Arizona allowed us to carry autopistols, I carried the 1911. After many many hours of practice, drawing holstering and firing, I carried it cocked and locked, which I was informed by our dept armorer that was the way John Browning meant the .45 to be carried. Now that I am a civilian again, I carry a compact .45ACP on the 1911 model. After much carry and practice, I am not comfortable witht he ambi safety as it walks off, so I carry it hammer down on a loaded chamber. Thumbing the hammer back is second nature to me now. This gives me 6 in the mag and one in the tube, and the thumb-cocking has replaced the safety sweep for me. It is all in how you train. In police work, you constantly hear that under stress, you revert to your training.

The statistic of 21 seconds for a knife attack, comes from the Calibre Press film 'Surviving Edged Weapons,' which we were required to view and it was noted in our jacket. An average person, not even an athlete, can run uphill 21 feet and stab or siice you before you can draw and fire. Most of the film was demonstrating how to overcome this. Sorry, kwo, but they showed the fallacy of backpedaling and drawing. They used a number of security and police officers in scenarios against Tino Insana, and every one of them was 'killed.' After proper training, they were able to defend themselves.

Great discussion.

Where can I get this video? Is it available on YouTube?
 
Great set of responses. Generally I carry one in the pipe, rarely a safety on. I have several DAO's, several DA/SA, many wheel guns as well. Practicing is the key as many have said. What you are comfortable with plays into it as well. If you have a fear of carrying your pistol cocked and locked and fear drawing may cause an unintentional discharge, the best I can offer is to suggest you practice _ safely _ empty mag, empty chamber draw and target acquisition. When you are comfortable with that, take it to the range and practice some more. Then load up the mag, chamber one, practice again and this time when you get to target acquisition, announce "stop, I'll shoot" "get back" whatever you say, and fire "if you decide the perp is still coming" or hold up if the perp is not.

Practicing is the way to get confidence, practicing develops muscle memory, practicing will ease the fears, practicing is what will help you survive...

:nhl_checking:
 
I don't think there's any disagreement on that. What we're trying to debate is whether someone can be alright carrying without a round in the pipe.


Sure, they could be ok, as long as the situation allows extra time to chamber a round. If the choice is between not carrying at all or carrying with an empty chamber, the choice is obvious. I would still recommend more training to get comfortable enough with a firearm to carry a round chambered. If someone is scared of carrying a round in the chamber, they should get a weapon that doesn't scare them.
 
One in the chamber? or not

Walk into a store with an armed robbery in progress, and decide if you want one in the chamber.
 
I carry one on the chamber while on my person.....but not at home when it is in or on the nightstand....I feel at home, I have time to rack one in if I have to.
 
I carry one on the chamber while on my person.....but not at home when it is in or on the nightstand....I feel at home, I have time to rack one in if I have to.


Good idea. Worse case scenario if you're on the street is that you'll lose a round thinking you'll have to rack the slide.

Important thing is that watever way you carry, that you train and train frequently.



gf
 
One in the chamber

I have one in the chamber of EVERY ONE of my handguns. I have one 9mm that is single action, so I would still have to cock the hammer to fire it, but then that is not what I carry all the time. It is usually a .357 or a DA/SA 9mm with the safety off so all I need to do is pull the trigger. As others have said, I am not concerned about either one going off accidentally because it does take a fair amount of pressure to pull the trigger back enough to fire one in DA mode.
 
I carry one on the chamber while on my person.....but not at home when it is in or on the nightstand....I feel at home, I have time to rack one in if I have to.

Me too. I live in a one bedroom apartment (on the fourth floor), so it's small enough that no matter where I am, sleeping or awake, I'll hear if someone is trying to break in.
 
One in the chamber of my gun, one in the chamber of my wife's gun, one in the chamber of my shotgun. I can't promise the dog won't bite, either.
 

New Threads

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
49,533
Messages
610,704
Members
75,032
Latest member
BLACKROCK6
Back
Top