One in the chamber.... or not

In MHO I think a gun shouldn't be "ready to fire." I use a semi-automatic and figure I'll have time to pull the slide. If I don't, I'm not sure it would really matter in the situation I'm in at that time. It's too easy to have your gun go off unexpectedly and just as easy to ready it.
Not too long ago, a guy pumping gas in a Dayton gas station was jumped by a couple of room temperature IQ druggies. They hit him from front and rear simultaneously.

By his own admission, if he hadn't had a round chambered, they probably would have prevailed over him. Instead, one got shot twice in the abdomen and the other headed for the hills.

No self-defense plan I will ever have will involve assuming that an assailant (or multiple assailants) will LET me chamber a round.

The only way your gun can go off "unexpectedly" is if you don't expect it to fire when the trigger gets pulled.
 
To each his own, but for me, I either carry a DAO with a long pull (Sig P250), or something with an external safety (Shield), my normal carry - but always with one in the pipe
 
If you have to have debate about this then you need a traing class...no bullet.....No gun..how fast can that turn into a bigger problem!!!! Learn correct use and ccw way and you'll find 1 is better than none, because none may have been to slow....Is it worth a loved ones life? You make that call...Everyone of us can tell you whatever we think, but until your prepared to then you could be making a mistake!!!
 
I used to carry empty chamber for fear of accidental discharge. Someone on this forum mentioned to me that not only is time of the essence, but more importantly, you could easily find yourself in a situation where you've only got one hand available. I tested my gun at the range to see just how sensitive the trigger pull was and discovered that hammer down gave me a really long trigger pull. After that I felt totally comfortable with a round chambered.

If your gun has a hair trigger, or if you just don't feel comfortable, do what feels right.
 
PP - Personal Protection

Speed Rock - Used to get the first 1-2 shots off quicker when the goblin is moving in fast at close range.

Draw stroke steps while retreating or moving to cover (shooting hand / support hand). Remember, speed doesn't come from fast hands. It comes from economy of movement... by eliminating unnecessary movement. Some of the fastest, most accurate shooters I've seen were in their 50's & 60's.

  1. Access / chest
  2. Grip / chest
  3. Pull / chest
  4. Rotate / chest
  5. Slightly rock hip upward during rotate / Chest
  6. Fire / chest or blocking attacker (don't shoot your support hand)
  7. Join hands
  8. Extend
  9. Fire

Note the slight upward rock of the hip as he rotates the gun



Thanks, I thought this was very good. I have changed some things, keeping one in the chamber, but because of what I learned starting 45 years ago I find myself not comfortable without the thumb safety.
Oh well 1911's and old dogs I guess. Side note: I did stare at the gun for a while on the night stand to make sure it didn't go off the first night chambered. :yes4: Yeah I know...for real...it never did.
 
First and foremost, it is your firearm and you need to be comfortable with how you carry it.

With that said, here are my thoughts and why I carry the way I do. Inform yourself about the Tueller drill. It is a drill that states through empirical data that if someone is 21 feet (7yards) from you with a knife, it will take them 2 seconds to reach you. With a level 2 tactical holster I can get a off a shot in 1.7 seconds. With a Serpa CQC holster, I can get the shot off in 1.3 seconds. However, for kicks and giggles, I decided to try doing this drill without a round in the chamber, but having to rack the slide first. With both types of holsters, I was over 2 seconds. I, therefore, always carry with one round in the chamber at all times. Even if it gives you a 0.5 second advantage, it is worth your life to practice, practice perfectly, and practice safely that way. I have carried and practiced for many years with one in the chamber and have never had an "accidental fire". Every time I want the gun to go bang it does and when I don't want it to go bang it doesn't.

Best wishes on your decision.

While there are many good responses. (NavyLCDR and others) I have tried this drill myself. You should try this drill with an IWB holster and some type of cover such as a t-shirt. Good luck on making under 2 seconds. Even with an open shirt you have the sweep, draw and getting one solid shot on target. It is a challenge in 1.7 seconds. Not to mention if your shirt gets hung up.
You do what you want, but I will ALWAYS carry one in the pipe. Even with a Glock the only thing I have had an issue with is reholstering after a drill. One has to watch that their shirt doesn't get hung up in the trigger guard. Just sayin.
 
right always reholster slowly and mindfully esp of the shirt.......it's drawing that needs be done quick i can do it well with an iwb and under 2 seconds never timed it on a watch but i think i can present it and fire in less than 1.5 i'd like to time it someday
 
In MHO I think a gun shouldn't be "ready to fire." I use a semi-automatic and figure I'll have time to pull the slide. If I don't, I'm not sure it would really matter in the situation I'm in at that time. It's too easy to have your gun go off unexpectedly and just as easy to ready it.

You really need to practice more and get more familiar with your weapon will go off unexpectedly on its own. Also look into proper holsters.
If you think you will have time to ready your gun when it really counts look at the posting with the clip from the dash cam tape of the South Carolina sheriff that was attacked while conducting a traffic stop (was posted yesterday) and decide if he would have had the time.
 
Not too long ago, a guy pumping gas in a Dayton gas station was jumped by a couple of room temperature IQ druggies. They hit him from front and rear simultaneously.

By his own admission, if he hadn't had a round chambered, they probably would have prevailed over him. Instead, one got shot twice in the abdomen and the other headed for the hills.

No self-defense plan I will ever have will involve assuming that an assailant (or multiple assailants) will LET me chamber a round.

The only way your gun can go off "unexpectedly" is if you don't expect it to fire when the trigger gets pulled.

Here's the video-


This guy is a member of a forum I'm on and honestly thinks he would be dead if he had to "chamber".

-
 
The truth is, whether you have one in the pipe or not you may not have enough time to even react draw quick enough either way in many situations because the attacker ALWAYS has the element of surprise against you.

You may have time to rack the slide you may not then again you may not even have time to draw at all.

The unchambered carry method may still save you in some situations and one in the pipe may in several more, but either way there is no garantee so go with which way you feel more comfortable. I understand the ups & downs of both

I have to disagree with your statement that the BG will ALWAYS have the element of surprise. You need to have better situational awareness. If you always keep an eye on your surroundings it eventually becomes routine and it should be very hard for someone to get close enough to surprise you.
 
ALWAYS carry one in the chamber... you need every second on your side. Watch some videos on robberies and gunfights and see how many people would have had time to rack a slide. A good gunbelt, a good holster, and one in the pipe.

:dirol:
 
It is my understanding from reading my state\'s law (TN) on carrying.. It is unlawful to carry with one in the chamber. Are there other states that allow this?
 
Wow, never thought I'd have to defend my position on this forum, but after all the backlash for making a simple reply, I feel compelled to do so. Here's why I don't keep one in the chamber ALL the time: 1st, I've been carrying for a long time and have never been in a situation where I had to draw my firearm. So, did I need to keep one chambered for years, no. 2nd, whenever I felt uneasy about the situation I've been in, I've chambered a round just in case. So, I was prepared if anything happened. 3rd, see references above on numerous accidental discharges. You can't convince me that they can't happen, whether you're highly trained or not. 4th, the only scenario where I would be in a pinch is when I'm jumped by people I never saw coming. I'm not saying that this couldn't happen to me, but I am always aware of my surroundings and the people around me. So, let's say this happens to me. If I have a chance to draw my gun, there's also a chance for the bad guy to get it from me, since I was surprised. I hope he does, because when he tries to fire it at me, it won't go off and that will give me a chance to take him down or get away. At least I won't be dead. Should cops always have one chambered, YES. Why? Because their job puts them in possible danger every single day. Do I need to? No. I have nothing against anyone choosing to keep one in the chamber. That's your choice. I choose not to. Should you call me an idiot for doing so? I'm not calling you one.
 
I always carry with one in the chamber. With modern gun technology and a proper holster and training their shouldn't be a safety concern when you carry a gun chambered. If it's a training situation and you don't feel that you are able to safely carry with a round chambered then I would suggest that more training is needed from an expert firearms instructor. It comes back to the old addage of: "Train like you fight and fight like you train." If not properly trained and you don't go out and practice regularly you probably shouldn't be carrying a firearm.
 
2nd, whenever I felt uneasy about the situation I've been in, I've chambered a round just in case. So, I was prepared if anything happened.

You have your own reasons and that's cool, but this reason is backwards. Why would you go into a situation you were uneasy about in the first place? Why wouldn't you instead go somewhere else instead of chambering a round?

Also, how do you go about chambering a round in a public place once you felt uneasy about the situation?
 
In MHO I think a gun shouldn't be "ready to fire." I use a semi-automatic and figure I'll have time to pull the slide. If I don't, I'm not sure it would really matter in the situation I'm in at that time. It's too easy to have your gun go off unexpectedly and just as easy to ready it.

BULL FRITTERS!! Wishful thinking. Hope is not a plan.
 
I guess the simple reason why I carry with one in the chamber is that just simply there is no reason not to. The chances of something bad happening BECAUSE of the round in the chamber are less than the chances of getting struck by lightening. If there is a lightening storm - sure, I will stay inside, or if I go outside I won't stand on top of a hill holding a golf club in the air. But 364.8 days out of the year, I don't even think about getting struck by lightning. It's the same way with having a round in the chamber. If I am storing my gun for extended lengths of time, or my daughter is having friends over or some special reason like that exists, I will unload the gun. Otherwise everyone in my house knows that my carry gun is fully loaded 99.8% of the time.

I have a paddle holster, so when I undress, I don't even have to remove the gun from the holster, proper manipulation of the retaining features and the holster comes off the belt easily with the gun still in the holster.

For me, the benefits of keeping a round in the chamber far, far, far outweigh any danger so it is an easy choice for me.
 

New Threads

Members online

No members online now.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
49,533
Messages
610,704
Members
75,032
Latest member
BLACKROCK6
Back
Top