Live round in the chamber

Given the reaction time necessary to respond to such an issue (life-threatening assault), the presumption that you'll have that half-second to cycle the slide, let alone two free hands to do so, is faulty.

Exactly! My fear is that I would be using my left hand to keep somebody at a distance while drawing with my right...if I had to cycle the slide both hands come in towards my body leaving the opportunity for a BG to close the distance.

I hope I never have to find out but I keep one in the chamber in case I do.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 
If you're debating this you really need to go to a few defensive handgun classes. From a good qualified instructor!

First thing I learned was retention drills. To do this you MUST be loaded! You cannot draw and tell the threat to wait for you to load before anchoring your gun to your hip to begin shooting. That defeats the purpose of retaining control of your weapon.

Your gun simply can not go bang if it's in a holster. Even more so if it's a Springfield XD or XDM variant. Or even a cocked and locked 1911. The backstrap safety must be engaged along with the trigger safety before you'll get a bang.

It's no different than big game or bird hunting with a round chambered. Load one in put it in safe and keep your muzzle in a safe direction.

Trying to think oh ill have time to rack the slide is pure ignorance.
 
I'm a supporter of CCW and an Australian who cannot carry.

What I don't understand is why people carry with a round in the chamber. It only takes a second to rack the slide, a lot less time to aim and draw, I just don't understand why people feel the need to do that.

I'd rather not risk the chance of accidental discharge. My thoughts only. Happy to be proven wrong. :)

If you can't carry, why are you even thinking about this? Accidental discharge isn't even a remote possibility for you!
 
...without somebody hanging onto one or both of their arms.
... or without trying to stop somebody from stabbing, beating or choking them to death.

Carrying with an empty chamber is essentially trying to create a "fair fight" for somebody unlawfully trying to maim or murder you.

I learned in the U.S. Army (and from fifty years of reading history) that if you find yourself in a "fair fight", your planning skills have failed you BADLY, probably FATALLY.

Great answer to Guns, who has made up his mind---period/end of story. Even his answer on "competent" shooters and "within a half a second" is assuming a lot for most forum members. I'll take any "half a second" I can find if, G-d forbid, I was in a "situation"--even if I was a "competent shooter".
 
The first post really should take care of any doubt. Those officers in the video have had more training than 'most' of us around here, and they didn't stand a chance. Imagine if they had needed to rack the slide as well....

What I haven't seen mentioned here is that our best friend is 'situational awareness'.... with the right mindset and being aware of your surroundings it is less likely someone can get THAT close to you without you being on alert. Not saying someone couldn't act normal until the last second and then pull a knife at close range and attack you -- but it is more likely that they will be looking like they are up to something long before that.

That extra time/effort to rack a slide can definitely mean the difference between winning and losing... I pick the tactic that gives me the best chance of survival, and that is having a round chambered.
 
I agree with WingRider. The main reason I started studying unarmed combat techniques was to be able to defend myself in a close encounter attack and be able to get enough distance to draw my firearm.
 
When Guns finds he neither "competent" or in need of that extra "half a second", I hope he is still alive.

Yeah, when situations turn nasty they turn nasty in a big hurry. When a person gets older their reflexes slow down. I want all the time I can get, barrow or steal!
 
Yeah, when situations turn nasty they turn nasty in a big hurry. When a person gets older their reflexes slow down. I want all the time I can get, barrow or steal!
Lets face it gejoslin, forums and words are easy--when it is time to crap in your pants I also want all the time I can get and any advantage I can get--I am not a highly trained tactical super Navy Seal--I am just a 71 year old in good health retired guy who has his firearms, practices within the limits of my lifestyle, and is watching the disintegration of something I was once proud of--the USA. What I see now scares the hell out of me and I will do whatever it takes to survive. Situational awareness is my best friend--I can choose where I go and when I go and avoid anything that even smells of a problem; it also means that I am as prepared as I can be and any edge, which includes that "half second" Gun talks about, is something that I will gladly take.
 
Lets face it gejoslin, forums and words are easy--when it is time to crap in your pants I also want all the time I can get and any advantage I can get--I am not a highly trained tactical super Navy Seal--I am just a 71 year old in good health retired guy who has his firearms, practices within the limits of my lifestyle, and is watching the disintegration of something I was once proud of--the USA. What I see now scares the hell out of me and I will do whatever it takes to survive. Situational awareness is my best friend--I can choose where I go and when I go and avoid anything that even smells of a problem; it also means that I am as prepared as I can be and any edge, which includes that "half second" Gun talks about, is something that I will gladly take.

I agree most heartily! Well said.
 
I'm over 70 years old, retired Army, and began carrying just because I got too old to fight. When I began carrying concealed I couldn't even think about having a round chambered, and I carried IWB. After much practice and firing, and after reading posts on this and a couple of other forums, Ive changed my practice somewhat.
I now carry OWB in a leather holster that I made and boned. I also carry with a round in the chamber, with the weapon on 'safe'. I practice drawing and flipping the safety to 'fire' at the same time, and am getting quite good at it. I'm like kelkarry, I am taking advantage of all the time I can get.
(I also believe that the fellow who shot himself in the butt because of the worn holster, wouldn't have shot himself in the butt if he had a safety on his weapon. I know, I know, he should have inspected his holster, too... safety is between the ears... blah... blah... Just sayin'.) :o)
 
I'm a supporter of CCW and an Australian who cannot carry.

What I don't understand is why people carry with a round in the chamber. It only takes a second to rack the slide, a lot less time to aim and draw, I just don't understand why people feel the need to do that.

I'd rather not risk the chance of accidental discharge. My thoughts only. Happy to be proven wrong. :)

I'm not even going to bother to read the other responses.

UNLESS you have been in the situation you cannot possibly appreciate the need to carry "hot" (e.g. with one in the chamber, cocked and locked). I was the subject of an attempted carjacking just a few short years ago. I was NOT carrying, but this gave me food for thought indeed.

I was bumped from behind and the driver of the other car in the "accident" came up to talk to me and the next thing I knew I was starting down the barrel (wrong end) of what looked like at least a .50 cal revolver (sic). The fellow was teetering about and had obviously liquored up for his task at hand. I had to make a snap decision. I did. I waited for the light to turn green and floored it, burning rubber, leaving him standing in the roadway. Fortunately for me he did not get his expected response and did not open fire on us. VERY fortunate indeed. I NEVER travel anywhere in the USA these days without carrying.

At first I would never carry with one in the chamber but as time went along it occurred to me more and more that if I had to defend my family with a right handed draw in THAT situation, I would never have been able to rack my slide without having a hole drilled through the left side of my head. Never. My only chance would have been action beating reaction with a "hot" handgun.

I am a great Glock fan and they have nothing... no grip safety.... no thumb safety. Just a trigger, like a revolver. You pull the trigger and they ALWAYS go bang. A great advantage when under stress. Love 'em.

So I started competing IPSC/IDPA/PPC using a 1911 gun with both a grip safety and a thumb safety as well as with my Glocks. No question, it takes thinking under stress to operate a 1911 even with reflexive action. And it takes a fraction of a second on the draw to ensure that you have a solid grip and have flipped the thumb safety off. TOO MUCH. I went back to my Glocks and that is what I compete with.

Having said that, I also went out and bought some very high quality holsters for my Glocks that protect that trigger and I will NEVER reholster a Glock with one hand. Always two hands and total concentration to ensure that the trigger doesn't snag somehow. That is when most Glock ND's happen. On reholstering as you are placing nearby objects moving in the same direction as the trigger. And that's bad news. And opportunity for trouble.

Carrying hot is not for everyone. It took me TWO years to start carrying my Glocks "hot". And I am still playing with other carry guns of all makes and sizes. I particularly like my HK P7M8, which holds 8 rounds plus one in the chamber. It is a squeeze cocker and I have no hesitation carrying it in my pocket without a holster. It is simply the safest handgun I have ever held or seen, super accurate, super reliable.

This debate is one that will go on forever as there is NO correct answer. Put ten folks around a table and you will get eleven opinions on the subject. Much depends on what you are comfy with and that can take lots of time. I want small, fast, easy, reliable, etc. Round in chamber becomes part of that equation.... if for no other reason than it ensures the first round being racked is already in place and not going to jam on its way up the ramp.

NOW, I will read the other responses.
 
i don't see any problem carrying fully loaded and ready to fire with safety off.....if you have to use it in a hurry... clear leather, point and shoot //no time for worry about is safety on or off? or is there one in chamber? that should already be done before you holster it imo...if u have good holster there is no danger of it going off
 
There should not even be any debate about this in my opinion. Always carry with round in chamber and have a good holster.

Criminals always carry with round in chamber so why give them an advantage over you?

:dirol:
 
Criminals may or may not carry with a round in the chamber; but for those of us that have taken live fire lethal force training there is a pretty 'standard' distance at which one needs to be wary of EVERYTHING going on and from which it is possible for a healthy person to disarm you.... even if you are aware that you are going to be disarmed!! How do I know? Lethal force training. I was indeed disarmed from 21 feet after being told it was going to happen. Not only ME, but everyone in the class was unable to clear leather and get off a "round" before being disarmed and 'figuratively' having their trigger finger torn off in the doins'. Amazing? I was jaw to knee for a week I can assure you. I was absolutely certainly that from 21 feet there would be no issue in clearing leather and getting off a good shot. The fact is that from 21 feet IF YOU CAN CLEAR LEATHER AND GET OFF A ROUND it is likely to be so rushed that you have no opportunity to take aim and VERY likely that any round that you do get off will miss the target by a mile.

Understanding this, one begins to understand the importance of carrying hot in addition to practice, practice, practice. I compete regularly in IPSC/IDPA/PPC, etc., to try and maintain somthing of an edge... a reflex if you will.

I have no misconceptions that the fraction of a second saved by carrying hot may save my life one day.
 

New Threads

Members online

No members online now.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
49,533
Messages
610,704
Members
75,032
Latest member
BLACKROCK6
Back
Top