One in the chamber.... or not

It's perfectly reasonable to TEST a single action gun the first time it's carried by having it cocked and locked on an empty chamber. I did that with my Norinco M1911 and Browning Hi Power. After a few hours of the safeties NOT being accidentally disengaged, I carry both with loaded chambers and never would any OTHER way.

There's a world of difference between prudence and paranoia fueled by ignorant rationalizations.

I have to agree with this as well, i spent a lot of time doing just that, trying to dry fire my SA with the manual safety off, without depressing the grip safety, still do it periodically as the pistol is a 70 series MK IV. It's 31years old with everything still original except recoil springs and grips. Never had it drop the hammer. With the exception of ammo testing, initial break in, and using a worn out mag or defective mag. which was my negligence way back when... the only FTF was during manually chambering a round. Those are three absolutes I can offer up, no what "ifs." That was enough to convince me, after my first and only ND; and it took some convincing after that idiotic manuver. that's me though, and what I learned from real life experience between me, my 1911, and my old '63 Chevy. So far no BG's have gotten too close, I prefer avoidance, asi have always consdered myself a pacifist, armed. I may someday be left without any other choice, but to defend my family or myself. Hope not. Peace guys.
 
Yikes! You guys are scaring me again. (No, that's not a compliment.) First of all, I didn't start anything, unless just by posting 1 initial opinion you think I did. I'm only defending my position after so many told me I was wrong. You are proving nothing to me, except that maybe you don't have an open mind and are over confident. If you are over confident, you scare me more than the criminals. I do agree that this crowd is totally against me and many may have more experience than me, but that's not a reason for me to change my mind. I even stated that my instructors carry a round in the chamber. Just because they have more experience than me doesn't mean I should blindly follow their choice. I'm not here to prove anything to you, except the fact that I'm willing to listen and change my mind IF you can give me an overwhelming reason to. I'm also proving to you I won't just sit back and take your posts as closed and not debatable. So far you've convinced me of little. I didn't bring up the "time" issue, someone else did and I stood by my decision, despite the fact that it will take me a second longer to rack my slide. If seconds are a factor, I would rather try and use both hands to defend myself than only one. And I certainly don't want to give my attacker a chance to take my gun and use it against me. So, are two hands better than one? I think so. Is giving the attacker a chance to get your gun worth the risk? I don't think so. If I only have one arm and the attacker has my gun and is shooting me with it, am I better off? I don't think so. Here's an analogy that I wish I'll never hear again and I wish I never had to use, but it fits the situation perfectly. Please bear with me, I know you're going to roll your eyes, but it really makes sense in the situation we're in. Your older and more experienced friend is going to jump off a cliff and says you should too. Should you? (I know, it's ridiculous, but please keep reading.) You have an open mind and want to know why he thinks it's a good idea. He tells you he's been offered 1 million dollars if he jumps. You think, hmmmm, there may be a point here. However, you're still not convinced, because if you do and you die, you won't get the 1 million dollars. So you tell him you think it's a bad idea, but he continually tries to convince you otherwise. So, you say, if he can give you a perfect reason why you should, then you'll change your mind and jump. That's exactly what's going on in this thread.
Then go get yourself killed kid. that's the end. I concede. You know better. I can't help someone who won't help themself. BC1 out...
 
One more thing: why does this post even exist if there wasn't an argument or a debate to be made? If all of you are absolutely correct, the question would never have been asked. Therefore, even though I seem to be the only one here that chooses not to chamber a round, there must be others out there and I doubt they're all wrong.

No offense intended but we have an old saying in Germany: "Eat more ****! Trillions of flies can not be wrong!"

I really mean no offense it simply serves to illustrate the point that lots of people can indeed be totally wrong together. Being German I say we certainly were at some point.
 
Yikes! You guys are scaring me again. (No, that's not a compliment.) First of all, I didn't start anything, unless just by posting 1 initial opinion you think I did. I'm only defending my position after so many told me I was wrong. You are proving nothing to me, except that maybe you don't have an open mind and are over confident. If you are over confident, you scare me more than the criminals. I do agree that this crowd is totally against me and many may have more experience than me, but that's not a reason for me to change my mind. I even stated that my instructors carry a round in the chamber. Just because they have more experience than me doesn't mean I should blindly follow their choice. I'm not here to prove anything to you, except the fact that I'm willing to listen and change my mind IF you can give me an overwhelming reason to. I'm also proving to you I won't just sit back and take your posts as closed and not debatable. So far you've convinced me of little. I didn't bring up the "time" issue, someone else did and I stood by my decision, despite the fact that it will take me a second longer to rack my slide. If seconds are a factor, I would rather try and use both hands to defend myself than only one. And I certainly don't want to give my attacker a chance to take my gun and use it against me. So, are two hands better than one? I think so. Is giving the attacker a chance to get your gun worth the risk? I don't think so. If I only have one arm and the attacker has my gun and is shooting me with it, am I better off? I don't think so. Here's an analogy that I wish I'll never hear again and I wish I never had to use, but it fits the situation perfectly. Please bear with me, I know you're going to roll your eyes, but it really makes sense in the situation we're in. Your older and more experienced friend is going to jump off a cliff and says you should too. Should you? (I know, it's ridiculous, but please keep reading.) You have an open mind and want to know why he thinks it's a good idea. He tells you he's been offered 1 million dollars if he jumps. You think, hmmmm, there may be a point here. However, you're still not convinced, because if you do and you die, you won't get the 1 million dollars. So you tell him you think it's a bad idea, but he continually tries to convince you otherwise. So, you say, if he can give you a perfect reason why you should, then you'll change your mind and jump. That's exactly what's going on in this thread.

I had stopped posting to this inane thread because I was tired of someone who wasn't listening to decades of research on the topic. As firearms owners and bearers we have a duty to ourselves and those we are protecting to be able to be as SAFE but ALSO as EFFICIENT as we can be with our weapons. That means learn as much as we can and train with perfect practice as much as we can. ONE of things many posters have learned and will learn if they take a decent firearms course is the Tueller drill. Please read this site: Tueller Drill - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Everyone who has learned about this knows with confidence and without debate that an attacker 21 feet away can get to you in under two seconds. An attacker. Someone who means to do you harm. Therefore, we train, we train often and we train with perfect practice to be as good as we can be so that way we can get off a round accurately and safely in under two seconds. My original post showed you that I after much training and much practice I can not do that if I must rack the slide, but I'm definitely under that two seconds with one in the chamber. You make assertions that it will only take an extra second to rack the slide.... SECONDS count. You will be dead if you cannot fully implement what is necessary under the Tueller drill. If you have practiced and have been timed and can draw, rack your slide and get off a center of mass shot in under two seconds, kudos to you. You are the fastest shot I know.

Your analogy about jumping off a cliff is stupid...I didn't call you stupid, just the straw-man argument you came up with. The laws of physics have been known since the late 1600's and mankind has known well before that someone jumping off a cliff will get hurt. And so will you sir if you do not train like I just mentioned in the above paragraph. No one will stop you from carrying the way you feel most comfortable. But with the facts that I have learned, including the FACT about the Tueller drill, I cannot conceive of not wanting to be prepared to be able to draw my firearm in less than two seconds. Time yourself and see. I will no longer respond to you until you have done that and I suggest the rest of the forum should not respond to croute either until he has been timed.
 
I don't know if this has been brought up, but I've seen semis occasionally having trouble manually feeding the first round (no problems during firing). Good luck clearing that when someone's coming at you.
 
There is a time and a place for everything. I think I understand his reasons for empty chamber carry.
I had an encounter when I lived in New Hampshire that follows his ideal.
Let me explain.....

This happened about twenty years ago when I was coming home from work. I lived I'm a two story apartment tenement. The first floor was at the sub basement level and the second story was, well, up one level.
It was fairly late, I was the assistant manager and had to close that night so I got to my building late, around 12:30 at night.
I parked my car and as I made my way to the lobby, one of the residents yelled down that he needed a ride to the store. I did not "know" this clown other than that he lived down the hall from me.
I ignored him and entered the building. As I made my way to the second floor landing, he came out of his place and demanded a ride to the store to get more beer.
Now, in N.H. the stores closed by nine that sold brew. There was no store open to take him to but he would not listen. By now, his girl and a few of his drinking buddies where all in the hall with him, goading him on to not take no for an answer!
Now this assclown goes back into his apartment and comes out with a huge kitchen knife!
He's standing on the top of the stairs telling me if I don't take him, he is going to stab my azz!
He approaches the stairs and slowly starts down towards me, I don't have much time to do anything and I am faced with a choice. I carried a .45 cal 1911 pistol, cocked and locked on my hip. I knew that I would be justified if I pulled the trigger but I didn't feel that was my only option.
Just as he had reached the halfway point to me, I said OK, go get your coat and I'll meet you outside. He got this big smile on his face and bolted up the stairs to his apartment, I turned and went down the stairs just like I was going to go out to my car ( in his mind I'm sure) and instead, I went ALL the way down to the lower apartments.
I simply walked down the long corridor and came up the stairs on the other end of my building and walked cautiously to my apartment and went in.
When my "ruse" was found out, he was pissed! He was yelling like a jerk about how he got screwed out of a ride to the store until someone called the cops on his loud mouth!

When I recounted this to my LEO friends, they wanted to know why I didn't shoot him once he presented the knife and approach me!! I said what I did was better. I got home safe and I didn't have to kill anyone. Isn't that what a successful self defense scenario should be?
I went to bed and he got himself not dead.... A win win in my book!
 
There is a time and a place for everything. I think I understand his reasons for empty chamber carry.
They're completely different.

You avoided the use of deadly force by practicing deception.

To hear him talk, he would have engaged the knife wielding moron with his bare hands, even when attacked.
 
There is a time and a place for everything. I think I understand his reasons for empty chamber carry.
I had an encounter when I lived in New Hampshire that follows his ideal.
Let me explain.....

This happened about twenty years ago when I was coming home from work. I lived I'm a two story apartment tenement. The first floor was at the sub basement level and the second story was, well, up one level.
It was fairly late, I was the assistant manager and had to close that night so I got to my building late, around 12:30 at night.
I parked my car and as I made my way to the lobby, one of the residents yelled down that he needed a ride to the store. I did not "know" this clown other than that he lived down the hall from me.
I ignored him and entered the building. As I made my way to the second floor landing, he came out of his place and demanded a ride to the store to get more beer.
Now, in N.H. the stores closed by nine that sold brew. There was no store open to take him to but he would not listen. By now, his girl and a few of his drinking buddies where all in the hall with him, goading him on to not take no for an answer!
Now this assclown goes back into his apartment and comes out with a huge kitchen knife!
He's standing on the top of the stairs telling me if I don't take him, he is going to stab my azz!
He approaches the stairs and slowly starts down towards me, I don't have much time to do anything and I am faced with a choice. I carried a .45 cal 1911 pistol, cocked and locked on my hip. I knew that I would be justified if I pulled the trigger but I didn't feel that was my only option.
Just as he had reached the halfway point to me, I said OK, go get your coat and I'll meet you outside. He got this big smile on his face and bolted up the stairs to his apartment, I turned and went down the stairs just like I was going to go out to my car ( in his mind I'm sure) and instead, I went ALL the way down to the lower apartments.
I simply walked down the long corridor and came up the stairs on the other end of my building and walked cautiously to my apartment and went in.
When my "ruse" was found out, he was pissed! He was yelling like a jerk about how he got screwed out of a ride to the store until someone called the cops on his loud mouth!

When I recounted this to my LEO friends, they wanted to know why I didn't shoot him once he presented the knife and approach me!! I said what I did was better. I got home safe and I didn't have to kill anyone. Isn't that what a successful self defense scenario should be?
I went to bed and he got himself not dead.... A win win in my book!

Excellent, Excellent!!!

Way to think on your feet!

-
 
OK guys. Lets let this thing alone. No matter how good a response to his question, he will not carry one in the pipe. This is a dead horse. Lets just hope that the blurb in the news paper announcing his death is for natural causes. Now, lets do something useful on this site.
 
So, if you still think I'm wrong, you'll have to provide more compelling evidence that I'm better off with one in the chamber.

I understand your stated reasons /situations for not carrying with in in the chamber and they are valid and very possible, however the only way to avoid those specific situations is to not carry at all.

With that being said, carrying a gun for self defense on a daily basis is you acknowleging the possible need for deadly force without notice whenever or wherever you may be.

you may not have time to draw the gun, you may have time to draw but not rack the slide, stress has a weird way of making usually easy tasks hard to accomplish as quick as practiced though

tough call
 
risk. n
risk?


There has been a lot ot talk about which option carries the most risk. There is always a risk when carring. The question should be, how often and how seriosly do you train. I carry a 1911 8+1 and two extra mags. I also train seriously every week. How you carry is not the biggest issue. How yoy train is.
 
croute, I have a Ruger SR9c. Let's forget for a moment that it has a manual safety. It also has a trigger safety which has to be depressed before it will fire. I also have to take up the slack in the trigger. Then, the trigger has to be depressed all the way for the weapon to fire. I have two holsters, both of which do a good job of covering the trigger guard when the gun is holstered. Please explain to me how, if I practice not putting my finer inside the trigger guard before I extend the gun and make the decision to shoot, I am going to get a AD/ND? Also, I don't remember in any of your posts you describing what gun/holster combination you have and what makes you think you would possibly have a AD/ND. If you've answered that already, I'm sorry, I don't remember and I'm not going back through all your posts to look. I'd really like answers to these questions. Please give me these explanations.
 
If you wish to not carry with a round in the chamber, that's your choice. Just never say you weren't warned when the SHTF and you don't have the time to load.
 
Survival of the fittest in the jungle, when an animal makes a stupid mistake they do not breed because they were lunch.
And that practice would not be passed on.
Looks like we have that example in the making.
 
As one who carries a .357 Magnum revolver in a fanny pack, it's kind of a moot question, as I have all seven cylinders loaded, so all I have to do is pull the trigger. I know I need to concentrate on my accuracy in a critical situation, and am probably toast if it comes down to an OK Corral quick draw situation, but then I may be the one to make a good shot versus a spray and pray artist who misses by keeping my head and acting rapidly but deliberately. You never know what will happen, but I do know my odds are better by the fact that I carry, and I practice. I know that given my weapon getting into my hand, I have a tool that's ready when I need it that will give me a very good chance of surviving.
 
Survival of the fittest in the jungle, when an animal makes a stupid mistake they do not breed because they were lunch.
And that practice would not be passed on.
Looks like we have that example in the making.

Yep, it is known as the process of Darwinian self-elimination. :hang3:
 
This happened about twenty years ago when I was coming home from work. I lived I'm a two story apartment tenement. The first floor was at the sub basement level and the second story was, well, up one level.
It was fairly late, I was the assistant manager and had to close that night so I got to my building late, around 12:30 at night.
I parked my car and as I made my way to the lobby, one of the residents yelled down that he needed a ride to the store. I did not "know" this clown other than that he lived down the hall from me.
I ignored him and entered the building. As I made my way to the second floor landing, he came out of his place and demanded a ride to the store to get more beer.
Now, in N.H. the stores closed by nine that sold brew. There was no store open to take him to but he would not listen. By now, his girl and a few of his drinking buddies where all in the hall with him, goading him on to not take no for an answer!
Now this assclown goes back into his apartment and comes out with a huge kitchen knife!
He's standing on the top of the stairs telling me if I don't take him, he is going to stab my azz!
He approaches the stairs and slowly starts down towards me, I don't have much time to do anything and I am faced with a choice. I carried a .45 cal 1911 pistol, cocked and locked on my hip. I knew that I would be justified if I pulled the trigger but I didn't feel that was my only option.
Just as he had reached the halfway point to me, I said OK, go get your coat and I'll meet you outside. He got this big smile on his face and bolted up the stairs to his apartment, I turned and went down the stairs just like I was going to go out to my car ( in his mind I'm sure) and instead, I went ALL the way down to the lower apartments.
I simply walked down the long corridor and came up the stairs on the other end of my building and walked cautiously to my apartment and went in.
When my "ruse" was found out, he was pissed! He was yelling like a jerk about how he got screwed out of a ride to the store until someone called the cops on his loud mouth!

When I recounted this to my LEO friends, they wanted to know why I didn't shoot him once he presented the knife and approach me!! I said what I did was better. I got home safe and I didn't have to kill anyone. Isn't that what a successful self defense scenario should be?
I went to bed and he got himself not dead.... A win win in my book!

Excellent way to think quickly on your feet sir! =-)
 
It's time for me to say this. I didn't before because I can guess what your reaction to it will be, but here goes: I have seen video and heard about many, many, many accidental discharges of guns. (Negligent discharges, whatever it is). And, quite a few of them were by people that had training, IE cops. (I heard your feelings about cops, just using them as an example I can think of where they did receive training.) Now, listen very carefully to this next part. I bet you every single one of them heard the same things I did and thought, "that will never happen to me, it can't." I've thought the exact same thing. However, I'm smart enough and open minded enough to realize that if it can happen to them, it probably can happen to me. So, if it's imposssible for this to happen, why does it? And if it's impossible for it to happen to someone like you, why does it? So, my point is, why take the risk? I'm erring on the side of safety. Why am I still in this discussion? Still defending my opinion and hoping at least some of you will take away something I'm saying. I've already had a few people say I've had some good points. I also think a few are at least agreeing with me that they should have an open mind. Should you all come with me on the dark side? No, you shouldn't, because you should take away what you want from this and so should I. You also should think for yourself, which is what I do and will continue to do until someone convinces me otherwise.
Well there ar 9 folks in NY that woudl say Cops are not well trained. I for one agree. Shooting is way down on the list of high priority things for most le's. I have had far more training them most Le's. There is no such thing as a accidental discharge only those who do not follow the four basic rules.
 

New Threads

Members online

No members online now.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
49,533
Messages
610,704
Members
75,032
Latest member
BLACKROCK6
Back
Top