One in the chamber.... or not

My thoughts are to always be prepared... if there is a situation that requires the use of my firearm IMMEDIATELY, I do not want to take the extra step in order to defend myself or my loved ones. Seconds count in an emergency situation. I am cocked and locked at all times.
 
I understand all about the risks and the time it takes to pull the slide to get ready to fire but i still don't like to carry one in the chamber idea. I guess i am old fashion when it comes to this. I carry a Tarus Millineum Pro 9mm and i feel that i can be ready when the time comes. I also have a Ruger LCR 357 and now it is always ready. My choice is my Tarus and i feel very comfortable with it. I guess when the time (if ever) comes then maybe i will learn the right way.
 
Can't believe this thread isn't locked yet. Should just change the thread title to "If you decide to carry unchambered then everyone will bash you and call you incompetent and tell you to sell your guns" haha :rolleyes:

Sent from my Verizon Galaxy S III using Tapatalk 2

That's about the size of it ;-)
 
Lies? Please tell us how it is possible to harm yourself or anyone else if you are following the four rules?

I only meant that it requires dedication and repetitive thought to stay safe. As humans, sometimes we "slip" and forget a step so to speak, and with guns, that can be a dangerous situation.
 
"Owning a handgun doesn't make you armed any more than owning a guitar makes you a musician" - Jeff Cooper

While I support every ones right to bear arms I realize that many who do so are incompetent to do so effectively, they feel that it's far more important that they believe they are competent than to actually become competent. More people survive out of pure dumb luck than skill.
 
When I was new to carrying, I never kept one in the chamber either. Over the years as I practiced drawing and shooting, I became aware of just how foolish an idea Mexican carry with an empty gun really was. As long as you properly maintain your gun and carry it in a well-fitting holster, there is virtually nothing to worry about. Heck, I barely even unload mine when I take it off my hip at the end of the end of the day. The ONLY time it's ever unloaded any more is when there are kids in my home.
 
A long time ago in a galaxy far, far away...

Firearms used to have a small chance of discharging if dropped. Now, in this day and age, firearms are made of high quality materials and safety devices and do not "accidentally" discharge. Every discharge is a pull of the trigger an the shooter i in control of his trigger finger. This is called a "negligent" discharge. If you practice not touching the trigger until you are ready to send a round downrange (as all professional trainers teach) then you have no reason to fear a round in the chamber and your weapon is ready to use.

It's the 21st century. It's time to quit blaming the gun for poor training.
 
"Owning a handgun doesn't make you armed any more than owning a guitar makes you a musician" - Jeff Cooper

While I support every ones right to bear arms I realize that many who do so are incompetent to do so effectively, they feel that it's far more important that they believe they are competent than to actually become competent. More people survive out of pure dumb luck than skill.


People overcomplicate owning and utilizing handguns for self defense and that is one reason certain groups of the public shy away from them and remain scared of guns .

People do not need to be professional shooters or gun enthusiasts to utilize a handgun effectively for self defense no more than a person needs to be a professional driver nascar etc to operate a vehicle to get them from point a to point b safely


A person needs to choose a gun, learn how that specific gun operates loading unloading safely familiarity with the trigger a holster that keeps fingers away from the trigger area treat it like it's loaded at all times don't point it at anybody unless they are an immediate threat (should be common sense)

A handgun packing frail 81 year old grandma can defend herself against a 21 year old hoodlum because her pistol equalizes the situation giving her iron mike tyson punching power at the pull of a trigger or atleast in theory that's the point of citizens carrying for self defense
 
When I was new to carrying, I never kept one in the chamber either. Over the years as I practiced drawing and shooting, I became aware of just how foolish an idea Mexican carry with an empty gun really was. As long as you properly maintain your gun and carry it in a well-fitting holster, there is virtually nothing to worry about. Heck, I barely even unload mine when I take it off my hip at the end of the end of the day. The ONLY time it's ever unloaded any more is when there are kids in my home.
I should have put that i have just recently got my cc permit and i guess i am still a little hesitant to carry fully loaded. I know some people feel that i am "Incompentent" but it's like other things you have to get more confidence and practice. I know that some people are just "Born" with the natural abiity to feel relaxed with carrying one in the chamber. To me it takes time to feel comfortable with carrying a firearm, i started carrying because the way the world is becoming. You hear of so many people killing others and so much crime and so on. So thank you for your understanding and your info.
 
I should have put that i have just recently got my cc permit and i guess i am still a little hesitant to carry fully loaded. I know some people feel that i am "Incompentent" but it's like other things you have to get more confidence and practice. I know that some people are just "Born" with the natural abiity to feel relaxed with carrying one in the chamber. To me it takes time to feel comfortable with carrying a firearm, i started carrying because the way the world is becoming. You hear of so many people killing others and so much crime and so on. So thank you for your understanding and your info.

No, your not incompentant, in fact when I first straped on my gun after getting my permit, i did not chamber one, then after thinking about it, on the way to Walley World, we got out of the car and I racked one in, been carry cocked&locked since, maybe 10 years now, it really is the best way to carry, you will when your ready
 
Request for safety recommendations when carring a SA (only) that doesn't have a decocking safety (safety leaves hammer back). Just purchased Sig P938.
 
I should have put that i have just recently got my cc permit and i guess i am still a little hesitant to carry fully loaded. I know some people feel that i am "Incompentent" but it's like other things you have to get more confidence and practice. I know that some people are just "Born" with the natural abiity to feel relaxed with carrying one in the chamber. To me it takes time to feel comfortable with carrying a firearm, i started carrying because the way the world is becoming. You hear of so many people killing others and so much crime and so on. So thank you for your understanding and your info.

I really don't know anyone that would call a newbie "incompetent" just because they haven't had enough training & experience to feel comfortable with plus 1 carry. I personally would say a person like you in not necessarily incompetent.

You just lack "confidence"
.

True "incompetence" comes into play when a person allows an "irrational" fear to overcome their abilities to train & gain the experience to overcome the phobia that they may have been brainwashed into believing.

Conversely, a lack of confidence can be overcome through training, practice & experience.

To me, a person that allows irrational FEAR to control their actions is the real definition of "incompetent". These are the people that really do need to re-access their life; and if they CC a firearm, the may need to re-think their decision.

-
 
I should have put that i have just recently got my cc permit and i guess i am still a little hesitant to carry fully loaded. I know some people feel that i am "Incompentent" but it's like other things you have to get more confidence and practice.
I feel that you're new, unsure and trying to do the right thing.

That's a FAR cry from asking questions to which you don't want honest answers, and justifying an irrational position by puffing yourself up like some sort of testosterone poisoned Beverly Hills Ninja.

I doubt that anybody here considers you "incompetent".
 
When revolvers were first created, there was a real danger of the chambered round going off if dropped or if the hammer was struck.
Modern revolvers and semi's have safety block's and such to prevent this.
So my answer is, it depends on your firearm.
Since I don't have an old antique revolver I have always carried 6 in my six shot S&W and 5 in my Model 60 and in my semi's I carry the full mag load plus 1 in battery. (Also why I like SA/DA semi's)
 
To WVRaybird

I should have put that i have just recently got my cc permit and i guess i am still a little hesitant to carry fully loaded. I know some people feel that i am "Incompentent" but it's like other things you have to get more confidence and practice. I know that some people are just "Born" with the natural abiity to feel relaxed with carrying one in the chamber. To me it takes time to feel comfortable with carrying a firearm, i started carrying because the way the world is becoming. You hear of so many people killing others and so much crime and so on. So thank you for your understanding and your info.

Something to think about: the VAST majority of negligent discharges of a firearm (probably at least 90%) happen when a person is handling the firearm during loading, unloading or when the firearm is thought to be unloaded. So, especially for an inexperienced shooter, would it not stand to reason that the safest environment to load, unload and handle the firearm is one that is free from distraction and pressure so that the full attention of the operator can be devoted to handling the firearm? Thus, would it not stand to reason that a person and bystanders would be safer if the firearm were loaded before leaving the house and then carefully placed in the holster and left there, rather than performing the loading operation on the street under the pressure of a self-defense situation?

In addition, under which conditions is it likely that a mistake will be made during loading, at the house or on the street under pressure? At the house you can make a determined and deliberate effort to fully pull the slide back and let it fly forward. You can then verify the round is properly chambered by checking a chamber indicator and/or pulling the slide back just enough to observe a round in the chamber and proper extraction, then returning the slide to fully closed (known as in battery). In the self-defense situation the adrenaline is flowing, the sweat is pouring, you increase your chances of short cycling the slide and you are not afforded the time to double check the loading of the round before having to fire.

It's just plain safer to load the gun under controlled circumstances and leave it alone during the day, regardless of what feelings your lack of experience is causing.
 
Request for safety recommendations when carring a SA (only) that doesn't have a decocking safety (safety leaves hammer back). Just purchased Sig P938.

Single action semi autos only fire if the hammer's back. That leaves you 3 options if you are going to carry it.

Option 1- what we are talking about here- carrying the gun hammer down on an empty chamber.
Personally (please, take note of the previous word), I consider this to be unloaded. In my opinion, carrying a gun like that is just being a gun bearer for a mugger and I'd personally prefer that you NOT do that because after he takes your gun from you, he may decide to use it on ME next. Please note all of the previous posts about how doubtful it will be in a real world confrontation that you will have time to draw, chamber, acquire the target and fire effectively. They will do a pretty effective job of explaining why I feel this way.

Option 2- Hammer down on a loaded round (AKA 'condition 2').
Personally (there's that word, again), I see this as a negligent discharge waiting for a place to happen.

To lower the hammer on a live round, you have to disengage ALL manual and automatic safeties designed and built into the gun and lower the hammer. To fire you, have to thumb the hammer back- under stress in a self defense situation. Knowing that fine motor control is one of the first things that goes under a surge of adrenaline, I see an unacceptably high (for me, at least) possibility of a negligent discharge happening. Since your thumb will be in the way of the slide's travel when it occurs, most likely you will also jam the gun (probably cause a FTE) That means, you are under attack, stressed out of your mind, slightly injured from the slide contact, probably holding an inoperable pistol AND responsible for that round you just ND'd if you survive the attack.

Option 3- Carrying it with the hammer back, safeties on, with a round chambered (AKA 'Condition 1 carry')

This is the way I carry a single action semi auto. When combined with a good holster- and assuming the gun is in good operating condition- it seems to me personally (please note that word one last time) to be the safest and fastest way to carry a loaded single action semi auto for self defense purposes. All of the safeties designed into the gun- both manual and automatic- are engaged, the holster is designed so not to interfere with them staying engaged and I can still draw, thumb the safety off as I present and fire quickly and efficiently.

There's a last option if you aren't comfortable with carrying it Condition 1- don't carry that gun for self defense at all. I didn't use a SA semi auto for self defense carry for several years because I wasn't comfortable with it either.
 

New Threads

Members online

No members online now.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
49,533
Messages
610,704
Members
75,032
Latest member
BLACKROCK6
Back
Top