Request for safety recommendations when carring a SA (only) that doesn't have a decocking safety (safety leaves hammer back). Just purchased Sig P938.
Single action semi autos only fire if the hammer's back. That leaves you 3 options if you are going to carry it.
Option 1- what we are talking about here- carrying the gun hammer down on an empty chamber.
Personally (please, take note of the previous word), I consider this to be unloaded. In my opinion, carrying a gun like that is just being a gun bearer for a mugger and I'd personally prefer that you NOT do that because after he takes your gun from you, he may decide to use it on ME next. Please note all of the previous posts about how doubtful it will be in a real world confrontation that you will have time to draw, chamber, acquire the target and fire effectively. They will do a pretty effective job of explaining why I feel this way.
Option 2- Hammer down on a loaded round (AKA 'condition 2').
Personally (there's that word, again), I see this as a negligent discharge waiting for a place to happen.
To lower the hammer on a live round, you have to disengage ALL manual and automatic safeties designed and built into the gun and lower the hammer. To fire you, have to thumb the hammer back- under stress in a self defense situation. Knowing that fine motor control is one of the first things that goes under a surge of adrenaline, I see an unacceptably high (for me, at least) possibility of a negligent discharge happening. Since your thumb will be in the way of the slide's travel when it occurs, most likely you will also jam the gun (probably cause a FTE) That means, you are under attack, stressed out of your mind, slightly injured from the slide contact, probably holding an inoperable pistol AND responsible for that round you just ND'd if you survive the attack.
Option 3- Carrying it with the hammer back, safeties on, with a round chambered (AKA 'Condition 1 carry')
This is the way I carry a single action semi auto. When combined with a good holster- and assuming the gun is in good operating condition- it seems to me personally (please note that word one last time) to be the safest and fastest way to carry a loaded single action semi auto for self defense purposes. All of the safeties designed into the gun- both manual and automatic- are engaged, the holster is designed so not to interfere with them staying engaged and I can still draw, thumb the safety off as I present and fire quickly and efficiently.
There's a last option if you aren't comfortable with carrying it Condition 1- don't carry that gun for self defense at all. I didn't use a SA semi auto for self defense carry for several years because I wasn't comfortable with it either.