One in the chamber.... or not

I honestly decided not to contribute to this post anymore, but I'm writing one last time because I can't hold my tongue. I came to this forum hoping to learn some new things and help others with their questions. I'm now close to regretting my decision. I thought this would be an excellent discussion and I stated my opinion. Now I'm an idiot for not having a round chambered, I'm a troll because I don't have a round chambered, I should leave my gun at home because I don't have a round chambered, I don't have training because I don't have a round chambered... Obviously I came to the wrong place and most of you have nothing to offer me. To those who engaged me and provided me with compelling points- thank you. For those that didn't- if you don't have anything to offer, please don't post.
Croute, don't get discouraged. Many of the posters give each other a little smack. Just get proper training. The topic is quite complicated and no one can really consider all on this forum. A good personal protection class takes a couple of days for a reason. It covers the law, prevention, awareness, avoidance, deterrence, de-escalation, strategies for in-home and away from home, proper handling, shooting techniques, proper draw stroke from a number of holsters, etc. It should also touch on behavioral science. A quick study of the habits of perps and how they attack. Live fire drills such as the Teuller drill show how fast the attack unfolds and how little time there is to react. We teach you the psychological and physiological changes that will happen to you when attacked and how you might respond. It should teach you what to do and say in the aftermath of a violent encounter; dealing with police, etc. It gets complicated. Our job is to teach you to survive. To instill a skill set and knowledge in you. We can't tell you how an attack will unfold or exactly what to do. Precisley why "what-if" scenarios are a joke.

Many of the posters are pretty well versed in this topic. Many are instructors. Some, including myself, make flippant comments. The best advice is to take a class with a good, experienced instructor. If you're anywhere near southern NY contact me and we'll get you in with our best instructor (former FBI / SWAT trainer). I'll even discount the class for you. Just don't get discouraged.
 
Croute, don't get discouraged. Many of the posters give each other a little smack. Just get proper training... ...Many of the posters are pretty well versed in this topic. Many are instructors...
Concur, Croute - cheer up. Take the replies in balance. I really WAS scared the first time someone tossed me explosives. As I got used to the gear discomfort gave way to knowledge and practical, safe practices.

Carrying a loaded firearm entails significant risk and responsibility. In my lifetime I have been proximate to four accidental discharges, three military and one civilian; two were scary, one cost a man a toe and the fourth killed a 19-year old bystander. The common thread in these incidents was careless handling, not a failure of a firearm to operate properly. Carelessness implies knowledge absent training.

A search of this thread produced the word "training" 23 times. If you dislike the tone in some of the replies here (I did), I still think you provoked some good answers. The word "training" did arise 23 times, even from some who need more training in common courtesy. :D This is in fact one of the more courteous firearms forums around.
 
I for one have provided two excellent training videos that prove without a doubt the utter importance of having a round chambered in your firearm 'while carrying' for self defense.
Even more to the point, AT LEAST two videos of actual SHOOTINGS have been posted, in which the victim probably would have succumbed without having a fully ready firearm to hand.
 
I honestly decided not to contribute to this post anymore, but I'm writing one last time because I can't hold my tongue. I came to this forum hoping to learn some new things and help others with their questions. I'm now close to regretting my decision. I thought this would be an excellent discussion and I stated my opinion. Now I'm an idiot for not having a round chambered, I'm a troll because I don't have a round chambered, I should leave my gun at home because I don't have a round chambered, I don't have training because I don't have a round chambered... Obviously I came to the wrong place and most of you have nothing to offer me. To those who engaged me and provided me with compelling points- thank you. For those that didn't- if you don't have anything to offer, please don't post.


Stick around & keep reading & you will learn something; I promise.

There are a lot of excellent people here to help. The reason "Outlaw" and a few others have gotten on your case a little is you seem to be unwilling to accept anyone's advice. The TRUTH is carrying a firearm with an empty chamber creates more risks than it prevents; PERIOD!

That being said; you still seem to listen & want to argue the point. But, there is no legitimate argument to the TRUTH.

Nobody is trying to force you to do something you do not feel comfortable doing. What we want you to do is get the TRAINING" you need to help you overcome the reservations you have about carrying plus 1.

The people here really do care about your safety!

Nobody has any other motive but to offer you some good advice that could save your life one day. Do what you want. But, I want to also leave you with these words:

Proverbs 18:1-2 (NKJV)
[SUP]1 [/SUP]A man who isolates himself seeks his own desire; He rages against all wise judgment.
[SUP]2 [/SUP]A fool has no delight in understanding, But in expressing his own heart.


PS; I'm not calling you anything; I'm just quoting another wise man.
-
 
I honestly decided not to contribute to this post anymore, but I'm writing one last time because I can't hold my tongue. I came to this forum hoping to learn some new things and help others with their questions. I'm now close to regretting my decision. I thought this would be an excellent discussion and I stated my opinion. Now I'm an idiot for not having a round chambered, I'm a troll because I don't have a round chambered, I should leave my gun at home because I don't have a round chambered, I don't have training because I don't have a round chambered... Obviously I came to the wrong place and most of you have nothing to offer me. To those who engaged me and provided me with compelling points- thank you. For those that didn't- if you don't have anything to offer, please don't post.
You seem determined to keep asking the question until you get the answer you want to hear. This being the case, giving up would seem to be a good way to save bandwidth...
 
Not to keep on, you did state, " majority rules." correct? I've kept my 1911's cocked and locked since the day I bought my first one. The sidearm is designed just for that carry condition. It's as safe as it's handler. It is a little unsettling at first, but try to make it discharge( dry fire) without gripping it, with or without the manual safety on. It can get knocked into the fire position accidentally.
 
But what if somebody takes it away from you?

What if you accidentally drop it on your foot?

Wrap it up in bubble wrap until you think you're going to need it...

I'll take that chance....Carried two for 30+ years and never had it jump out and shoot me or anyone else....
 
I have been having this discussion lately, and am out of ideas. So, majority rules, does it really make a difference, is it worth the "risk", I need opinions to further my argument.

Thanks,
Dennis

Not sure what "risk" your referring too. If you mean the risk of carrying a gun loaded (the way it was intended to be). I don't see any. No round chambered = unloaded gun. You can't defend yourself with an unloaded gun. Period.
 
If a suspect is 7 yards away will cut you before you can draw and shoot...Now add to that you would have to chamber a round I'd say if he was within 15 yards, he would still cut you....( it may well be within 20 yards...I don't have data to back up the distance if you have an empty chamber)




Carrying a weapon without one in the chamber is giving the criminal the advantage...




I like so many others carry a 1911 cocked and locked.


Good article for you to read


http://www.theppsc.org/Staff_Views/Tueller/How.Close.htm
 
I honestly decided not to contribute to this post anymore, but I'm writing one last time because I can't hold my tongue. I came to this forum hoping to learn some new things and help others with their questions. I'm now close to regretting my decision. I thought this would be an excellent discussion and I stated my opinion. Now I'm an idiot for not having a round chambered, I'm a troll because I don't have a round chambered, I should leave my gun at home because I don't have a round chambered, I don't have training because I don't have a round chambered... Obviously I came to the wrong place and most of you have nothing to offer me. To those who engaged me and provided me with compelling points- thank you. For those that didn't- if you don't have anything to offer, please don't post.

It's your gun and your life so be it but I have something to offer. Carry a revolver with the hammer on the empty chamber and you're good to go.
 
There are no places that are completely safe. Only places that are safer than others.

Therefore always carry when legal to do so, and always condition 1.
 
It's your gun and your life so be it but I have something to offer. Carry a revolver with the hammer on the empty chamber and you're good to go.

That still does not solve croute's concern about a bad guy being one trigger pull away of shooting the victim with their own gun after they grab it.
 
I always carry loaded and one in the tube. My carry guns have no manual safeties. I carry my semis the same as my wheel guns. Every gun is loaded, whether it is or not.
 
Maybe we should set up a set like the robbery. There are some here that think they could get a round in the chamber and live to tell about it.
I bet this guy was thinking the same thing.
 
I honestly decided not to contribute to this post anymore, but I'm writing one last time because I can't hold my tongue. I came to this forum hoping to learn some new things and help others with their questions. I'm now close to regretting my decision. I thought this would be an excellent discussion and I stated my opinion. Now I'm an idiot for not having a round chambered, I'm a troll because I don't have a round chambered, I should leave my gun at home because I don't have a round chambered, I don't have training because I don't have a round chambered... Obviously I came to the wrong place and most of you have nothing to offer me. To those who engaged me and provided me with compelling points- thank you. For those that didn't- if you don't have anything to offer, please don't post.

It is risky to offer a controversial opinion for debate, you will inevitably get some very heated responses. Try to ignore any insults and just take away any useful information you can find. It's not easy but it will get you more out of it. ;-)
 
I have strong opinions on this subject. I found that the more I became used to carrying and the more I practiced the more comfortable I became with my gun. It was years before I moved on to a gun with no external safety. I'm an amature that tried to progress the best I could. I think other more experienced people making me question what I was doing helped me become a more competent armed citizen. I learned by what I saw went wrong while training under the pressure of timed practice. If you can see what goes wrong and know it will be worse in real life you will learn what you need to become and do to be the best you can be for yourself. It will not be the same for all of us. The range won't do it. Get someone good to push you through everything that may go wrong. When you carry and practice long enough you'll know what's right for you.
 
I honestly decided not to contribute to this post anymore, but I'm writing one last time because I can't hold my tongue. I came to this forum hoping to learn some new things and help others with their questions. I'm now close to regretting my decision. I thought this would be an excellent discussion and I stated my opinion. Now I'm an idiot for not having a round chambered, I'm a troll because I don't have a round chambered, I should leave my gun at home because I don't have a round chambered, I don't have training because I don't have a round chambered... Obviously I came to the wrong place and most of you have nothing to offer me. To those who engaged me and provided me with compelling points- thank you. For those that didn't- if you don't have anything to offer, please don't post.

I'm sorry you feel that way, the choice to carry chambered or not is yours and yours alone, I'm sure you will find some to agree with you, but you should have seen from the first few post's that your opinion is in the very small minority, if you feel confident enough in your ability to react in time vs haveing a rd chambered. great, I hope for your sake you are never tested, because much research, not opinion, has proven you wrong
 
Simple answer is carry however you wish, but while you are racking the slide, my slide will have already returned to battery to go again.
 

New Threads

Members online

No members online now.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
49,533
Messages
610,704
Members
75,032
Latest member
BLACKROCK6
Back
Top