One in the chamber.... or not

In MHO I think a gun shouldn't be "ready to fire." I use a semi-automatic and figure I'll have time to pull the slide. If I don't, I'm not sure it would really matter in the situation I'm in at that time. It's too easy to have your gun go off unexpectedly and just as easy to ready it.

Maybe at home.... but on the street?

GG
 
I'm not BSing anyone here. I'm telling you the truth. Not sure why so many cannot understand my position. Do I think I would be at a disadvantage in some instances without a round chambered, yes. Do I think I would be at a disadvantage in some instances with a round chambered, yes. That's my entire point. You may not be wrong and I may not be wrong. To each his own until I'm convinced otherwise. Good to see some others with martial arts training. That may be my biggest problem. Although karate is one of the most offensive styles in martial arts, most of the training is to diffuse the situation and get out of it. Defense, not offense. I would always choose defense before offense until I don't have a choice. I guess I'll move on and let you be. Thanks for the interesting conversation.

I would kindly suggest probability for your consideration. The chances of not having a round chambered benefitting you for some reason are simply far less than the other way round. It sounds a bit like some people that are arguing they won't wear a seat belt because they MIGHT get tangled in it and drown in a lake. It is far more likely that they will simply crash into something where the seat belt will save them. Besides, they could just carry a rescue knife.

Also kindly consider this: Aside of some Mossad agents no professional I ever heard of carries a gun without a round in the chamber. And as some say this method may be good enough for the Mossad but most of us are not good enough to get into the Mossad ;-).
 
1 in the pipe, always. Been around firearms my entire life, never once had a discharge from one that I was in control of that I didn't make happen myself.

Thank you. I said much the same some time ago and some of these "expert gunners" acted as if an "accidental discharge" (misnomer) was commonplace!!

GG
 
You guys are getting much better at presenting your case. Still not quite there yet. The only thing I'm still stuck on is the situation. Here's the scenario: if there's a knife-wielding thug 20 feet from me, I will have time to draw and rack, and shoot him. If he's much closer, again, I'm not sure I'd want to draw, even with a bullet chambered. I'd rather fend off the attack without a gun. You all seem to be siding with drawing your gun, even when you probably don't have enough time to get off a good shot. Not only that, but let's say you draw it and the thug gets it from you. Now you're probably defensless and have a bullet in you. Convince me that I'm wrong and I'll swallow my pride and chamber a round from now on. By the way, for all of you saying I should just leave my gun at home, that's the most rediculous argument I've ever heard. Obviously not having a round chambered is completely different than not having a gun. Give it a rest.

This entire post smells of 'trollism' imvho. :unsure:

~SMFH~ :butcher:
 
ONE IN THE CHAMBER! If you don't feel safe that way, then you have not trained enough and are not comfortable enough with your firearm. Train and learn. Jim....out.
 
So far I'm not convinced. I'm still not sure you're getting my point of situations where I believe you shouldn't draw your gun. Those are the only cases where I believe it's better not to have one in the pipe.
Ok here is the simple drill I do with EVERY class. This is to show how far away a bg ccan be and still get to you BEFORE you can draw and fire. Stand back to back with another person you face the target when the instructor says go or beep when using a shot timer the person at your back runs at the SAME time you draw and fire as fast as you can. When your shot goes off the runner STOPS. Re-holster turn and see how far away they are. Now in your case try the same drill only this time leave the chamber empty and now you draw rack the slide then fire. See how much further the person is. Remember this is how far a person can be FROM you and get to you BEFORE you can draw and fire ( and in your case rack the slide ) do you really think that time is worth your life? If you are going to carry do so with the mental picture that IF needed your going to kill someone. If you want to SCARE a person or frighten them then carry mace. A firearm is not a toy you either train to use it or you really on someone else to protect you. This is your choice and your right to choose. The problem is carrying a firearm with the chamber empty is like buying a car without a windshield. It may be neat but in the end your going to get hit by allot bugs every one making you wish you had bought a car with a windshield. Of course if we equate this with a firearm chances are your not going to get the chance to contemplate your bad choice. When you NEED it it must be there ready and you must be trained to react with it. If your not willing to do that then what is really the point of having it?
 
Always chambered.

My Kahr CW9 does not have a safety which at first drew concern. But after learning how to carry correctly I am at ease and carry as much as legally possible.
 
You guys are getting much better at presenting your case. Still not quite there yet. The only thing I'm still stuck on is the situation. Here's the scenario: if there's a knife-wielding thug 20 feet from me, I will have time to draw and rack, and shoot him. If he's much closer, again, I'm not sure I'd want to draw, even with a bullet chambered. I'd rather fend off the attack without a gun. You all seem to be siding with drawing your gun, even when you probably don't have enough time to get off a good shot. Not only that, but let's say you draw it and the thug gets it from you. Now you're probably defensless and have a bullet in you. Convince me that I'm wrong and I'll swallow my pride and chamber a round from now on. By the way, for all of you saying I should just leave my gun at home, that's the most rediculous argument I've ever heard. Obviously not having a round chambered is completely different than not having a gun. Give it a rest.
Croute, you need to get some training; quickly. You're so wrong that as an instructor I can't even begin to explain it on this forum. One sure way to know? Take a walk through the hood alone at, say... 1:30 AM, with a gold watch and a few chains. Experience can be the best teacher.
 
Aside of some Mossad agents no professional I ever heard of carries a gun without a round in the chamber. And as some say this method may be good enough for the Mossad but most of us are not good enough to get into the Mossad ;-).

I would think the Mossad is much more into offense than defense.
 
Obviously you guys are in a daily life-threatening situation that I don't experience. To answer your questions: I'm perfectly comfortable with carrying my gun. I'm not afraid to have a round chambered at all times, I just choose not to because I don't think it's necessary. I've had training from an officer. I'm an excellent shot and can probably draw my gun while racking the slide, shoot a target and be just as or more accurate as many of you, within a second of your actual time. That's what we're talking about here, 1 second of time, if that. I really don't think that's going to matter if you and I are in the exact situation. I'm also a second-degree blue belt in Tae Kwon Do. I'll use that training in situations where I'm jumped and actually don't want my gun to be a part of the equation. I have racked my slide in public places without anyone knowing. There are ways to do this if you are aware of your surroundings. And no, I didn't walk into a situation that I could have avoided in the first place. I found myself in situations where I became uncomfortable and worked my way out of it as quickly as I could. Last, and most important, I emphasize my position on the situation where I'm taken by surprise. Really think about this one. If I'm taken by surprise, have a gun to my head, a knife in my back, etc. Two things are going to happen: I won't have the opportunity to draw my gun or I won't want to draw my gun. So, it won't matter if a round is chambered in that situation, unless the bad guy gets my gun from me, and in that case I'll be glad I didn't have one in the pipe. If I don't have one second of time to chamber a round, I shouldn't be drawing my gun in the first place. I choose not to chamber a round, you do. To each his own. If you ever see me in a "caught on tape" video and I get killed, only because I didn't have a round chambered, feel free to laugh at me and use me as an example. Until then, let's just stick to a decent conversation with pros and cons without the potshots.

I really do not care to be rude, but, your opinion demonstrates a very poor understanding of the real world. The fact that you have gotten away with very poor SD practice doesn't make it good practice.
I have been CCW'ing for 39 years, day in, day out. During that time, I have needed to draw my gun once and have not needed to fire. That one day, had I not had my gun available and instantly ready, I probably would not be here talking about it. When you discover that you are in trouble, or that you don't have both hands free, your poor tactical decision, could easily be fatal. If you die because you were stupid, that's ok, but how would you deal with having your wife or child die for your mistakes?
 
During that time, I have needed to draw my gun once and have not needed to fire. That one day, had I not had my gun available and instantly ready, I probably would not be here talking about it.

While I certainly do not agree with carrying an unloaded gun...I must ask.... If you drew your gun, but did not need to fire it......ummmmm......what difference did it make that one time whether the gun was loaded or not? Could the bad guy see down the barrel and see a bullet peeking at him and that is what scared them off?
 
The sound just may stop an aggressor in his tracks.

However, I carry with one in the chamber. LCP or LC9 are carry guns here. LCP doesn't have a safety, I leave the LC9's safety off to be consistent with how I practice with the LCP. Both guns are in a holster that covers the trigger.

Finally we're having a better discussion with some good points, without the potshots. I now appreciate the feedback. I'm also open to changing my ways if someone gives me a clear reason why I should have a round chambered. So far I'm not convinced. I'm still not sure you're getting my point of situations where I believe you shouldn't draw your gun. Those are the only cases where I believe it's better not to have one in the pipe. And since I don't know when that situation may happen, I don't keep the gun ready to fire. Again, if I'm jumped or cornered unexpectedly, the last thing I'd be thinking about is trying to draw my gun. I'd be focused on how to either take down the opponent or get away. At least until an opportunity presents itself where I would have a chance to draw it. In that case, I don't think racking the slide while drawing is going to make a huge difference- a total of 1 second.

While I certainly do not agree with carrying an unloaded gun...I must ask.... If you drew your gun, but did not need to fire it......ummmmm......what difference did it make that one time whether the gun was loaded or not? Could the bad guy see down the barrel and see a bullet peeking at him and that is what scared them off?
With an unloaded gun, you're bluffing. What if he feels lucky???
 
You guys are getting much better at presenting your case. Still not quite there yet. The only thing I'm still stuck on is the situation. Here's the scenario: if there's a knife-wielding thug 20 feet from me, I will have time to draw and rack, and shoot him. If he's much closer, again, I'm not sure I'd want to draw, even with a bullet chambered. I'd rather fend off the attack without a gun. You all seem to be siding with drawing your gun, even when you probably don't have enough time to get off a good shot. Not only that, but let's say you draw it and the thug gets it from you. Now you're probably defensless and have a bullet in you. Convince me that I'm wrong and I'll swallow my pride and chamber a round from now on. By the way, for all of you saying I should just leave my gun at home, that's the most rediculous argument I've ever heard. Obviously not having a round chambered is completely different than not having a gun. Give it a rest.
All the statistics I've seen show that if a bg is 20 feet away from you with a knife in his hand and your gun is in its holster, you're gonna get cut, even WITH a round in the chamber. So, in this scenerio maybe you're right - it probably wouldn't make any difference if you had a round in the chamber. Or, for that matter, if you'd left your gun at home.

Having said that, I'll choose to try not to let the bg with a knife in his hand get that close to me - AND I'll have a round chambered. But, that's just me...
 
All the statistics I've seen show that if a bg is 20 feet away from you with a knife in his hand and your gun is in its holster, you're gonna get cut, even WITH a round in the chamber. So, in this scenerio maybe you're right - it probably wouldn't make any difference if you had a round in the chamber. Or, for that matter, if you'd left your gun at home.

Having said that, I'll choose to try not to let the bg with a knife in his hand get that close to me - AND I'll have a round chambered. But, that's just me...

The main issue is that the knife at 20 ft scenario is just ONE scenario of many. The original post focussed far too much on just that one.
 
All the statistics I've seen show that if a bg is 20 feet away from you with a knife in his hand and your gun is in its holster, you're gonna get cut, even WITH a round in the chamber. So, in this scenerio maybe you're right - it probably wouldn't make any difference if you had a round in the chamber. Or, for that matter, if you'd left your gun at home.
The difference is that by NOT having a loaded round... or a firearm at all, you go from the POSSIBILITY of a particular outcome to the CERTAINTY of it.

This underlies all of the anti-gun claims that ONLY the killer in an active shooter situation should be armed because a LAC might ACCIDENTALLY hit an innocent person instead of the wouldbe mass murderer. They prefer the CERTAINTY of DEATH by EXECUTION to the POSSIBILITY of WOUNDING by ACCIDENT.

Some chance is always better than no chance.
 
I honestly decided not to contribute to this post anymore, but I'm writing one last time because I can't hold my tongue. I came to this forum hoping to learn some new things and help others with their questions. I'm now close to regretting my decision. I thought this would be an excellent discussion and I stated my opinion. Now I'm an idiot for not having a round chambered, I'm a troll because I don't have a round chambered, I should leave my gun at home because I don't have a round chambered, I don't have training because I don't have a round chambered... Obviously I came to the wrong place and most of you have nothing to offer me. To those who engaged me and provided me with compelling points- thank you. For those that didn't- if you don't have anything to offer, please don't post.
 
One common thread in every self defense disscussion is, a gun fight will never happen the way you imagine. I feel it's best to prepare for the worst, and pray for the best. Most such altercations begin with you using your weak hand to get you attacker away and off balance, while drawing and firing one handed as your weapon clears the holster. Most gunfights are one handed, and point shooting at bad breath distance. It's a good topic, name calling sent it off track.
 
I honestly decided not to contribute to this post anymore, but I'm writing one last time because I can't hold my tongue. I came to this forum hoping to learn some new things and help others with their questions. I'm now close to regretting my decision. I thought this would be an excellent discussion and I stated my opinion. Now I'm an idiot for not having a round chambered, I'm a troll because I don't have a round chambered, I should leave my gun at home because I don't have a round chambered, I don't have training because I don't have a round chambered... Obviously I came to the wrong place and most of you have nothing to offer me. To those who engaged me and provided me with compelling points- thank you. For those that didn't- if you don't have anything to offer, please don't post.

I for one have provided two excellent training videos that prove without a doubt the utter importance of having a round chambered in your firearm 'while carrying' for self defense.

You have repeatedly responded; "I'm not convinced"..."Convince Me"...Yada, yada, yada...Blah, blah, blah. :rolleyes:

It is clear (to me at least) that you do not want to learn from our collective years of combined experienced opinions...
I now believe that you merely want to 'bloviate' your misguided thoughts on why you think carrying a firearm without a round in the chamber is 'perfectly acceptable', when in fact it is 'not' perfectly acceptable.

It is utter folly sir!
 

New Threads

Members online

No members online now.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
49,533
Messages
610,704
Members
75,032
Latest member
BLACKROCK6
Back
Top