One in the chamber.... or not

It is an old argument, what can I say, you can train for carrying without a round in the chamber but nobody can convince me it's actually gonna be FASTER to draw and rack the slide. Maybe not much SLOWER but it's a physical impossiblity for that way of carry to be FASTER.

Modern gun designs are meant to be carried locked and loaded and I see no reason to deviate from that.
 
It is an old argument, what can I say, you can train for carrying without a round in the chamber but nobody can convince me it's actually gonna be FASTER to draw and rack the slide.
I think it's much more important that rather than slower, it might be IMPOSSIBLE.

The entire thing is premised on a violent assailant LETTING you draw AND chamber a round. In the Dayton case, the victim had to fight for all he was worth to draw and fire a LOADED firearm, and he had to do so ONE handed.

Any plan premised on somebody doing things that make it necessary to shoot him, STOPPING those actions long enough for you to chamber a round, is a BAD plan.
 
croute;346136[/quote said:
I've been carrying for a long time and have never been in a situation where I had to draw my firearm. So, did I need to keep one chambered for years, no. .

Then I guess by that same logic, you really didn't need to carry at all for all those years.
 
I've been carrying for a long time and have never been in a situation where I had to draw my firearm. So, did I need to keep one chambered for years, no.

Then I guess by that same logic, you really didn't need to carry at all for all those years.
The truth is that many of the arguments in favor of carrying with an empty chamber are conceptually identical to the arguments for not CARRYING, AT ALL.

They're generally based on a greater fear of theoretical dangers than of IMMEDIATE danger.

Carrying with an empty chamber because you believe a violent assailant will LET you chamber a round is as irrational as not carrying at all because you believe the police will "protect" you.
 
So far I'm not convinced. I'm still not sure you're getting my point of situations where I believe you shouldn't draw your gun. Those are the only cases where I believe it's better not to have one in the pipe. And since I don't know when that situation may happen, I don't keep the gun ready to fire. Again, if I'm jumped or cornered unexpectedly, the last thing I'd be thinking about is trying to draw my gun. I'd be focused on how to either take down the opponent or get away. At least until an opportunity presents itself where I would have a chance to draw it. In that case, I don't think racking the slide while drawing is going to make a huge difference- a total of 1 second.

~SMFH~ :no:
I give up......have a nice day. :hang3:
 
I think it's much more important that rather than slower, it might be IMPOSSIBLE.

The entire thing is premised on a violent assailant LETTING you draw AND chamber a round. In the Dayton case, the victim had to fight for all he was worth to draw and fire a LOADED firearm, and he had to do so ONE handed.

Any plan premised on somebody doing things that make it necessary to shoot him, STOPPING those actions long enough for you to chamber a round, is a BAD plan.

And that is another good argument against carrying without one in the chamber.
 
Finally we're having a better discussion with some good points, without the potshots. I now appreciate the feedback. I'm also open to changing my ways if someone gives me a clear reason why I should have a round chambered. So far I'm not convinced.

The exact same arguments you use to justify not carrying a loaded gun are the arguments that the Brady Campaign and other groups use to justify not carrying a gun at all. The fact is, none of us can predict when we will need or not need a gun, and none of us can predict when we will be required to successfully chamber a round in enough time to save our life or the lives of our loved ones and none of us can predict when we might fail to do so. We carry a gun for that remote possibility that we will have to use it to defend ourselves or our family. The Brady Campaign says that possibility is too remote to carry a gun for. I carry a round in the chamber for the remote possibility that I will need to draw my gun and shoot at a somebody in the worst possible circumstances. If I have to do that only once in my entire lifetime...that one time will be a life or death situation that I would rather prepare fully for in the comfort of my home than in the circumstances of a criminal attacking me or my family.

You won't bet your life on what the Brady Campaign tells you - that you won't ever need the gun to save your life or protect your family. Why bet your life on being able to sucessfully chamber the round when it is needed the most.
 
Please, correct me if I am wrong here.
Didn't the OP ask for opinions about if he should carry with one in the chamber or not? Seems to me, his mind is made up. No +1 no matter what we advise. He seems to think he will be just fine with an empty chamber so why are we trying to change his mindset?
Let it go and wish him God speed! It's his life to win or lose as he chooses.

Just sayin...... Ya know?
 
He seems to think he will be just fine with an empty chamber so why are we trying to change his mindset?
I'm not. He's made his choice and will live or die by it.

I'm concerned with the uninformed who might read what he posts and similarly risk their lives and those of their families by being unprepared to meet the MOST likely threat they'll face, a violent opponent not inclined to give them time to fool around with an unloaded firearm, rather than the sort of cartoon gremlins faced by Bugs Bunny, who might be tempted to pull the trigger on a safely holstered firearm with a loaded chamber.

I don't try to change committed anti-gunners either, just ensure that their misinformation and disinformation doesn't go unchallenged.
 
I think the act of chambering a round is the one most prone to failure, at least from my personal experience; then add the stress of a life threatening situation? Can't end well. Good holster, and awareness are the key, in my opinion. Guns do not fire themselves, Always one in the chamber for me, 1911 cocked and locked. Gotta know where the muzzle is at all times.
 
You guys are getting much better at presenting your case. Still not quite there yet. The only thing I'm still stuck on is the situation. Here's the scenario: if there's a knife-wielding thug 20 feet from me, I will have time to draw and rack, and shoot him. If he's much closer, again, I'm not sure I'd want to draw, even with a bullet chambered. I'd rather fend off the attack without a gun. You all seem to be siding with drawing your gun, even when you probably don't have enough time to get off a good shot. Not only that, but let's say you draw it and the thug gets it from you. Now you're probably defensless and have a bullet in you. Convince me that I'm wrong and I'll swallow my pride and chamber a round from now on. By the way, for all of you saying I should just leave my gun at home, that's the most rediculous argument I've ever heard. Obviously not having a round chambered is completely different than not having a gun. Give it a rest.
 
Finally we're having a better discussion with some good points, without the potshots. I now appreciate the feedback. I'm also open to changing my ways if someone gives me a clear reason why I should have a round chambered. So far I'm not convinced. I'm still not sure you're getting my point of situations where I believe you shouldn't draw your gun. Those are the only cases where I believe it's better not to have one in the pipe. And since I don't know when that situation may happen, I don't keep the gun ready to fire. Again, if I'm jumped or cornered unexpectedly, the last thing I'd be thinking about is trying to draw my gun. I'd be focused on how to either take down the opponent or get away. At least until an opportunity presents itself where I would have a chance to draw it. In that case, I don't think racking the slide while drawing is going to make a huge difference- a total of 1 second.
So, it sounds like you're saying that the only time you need a round chambered is when you have to use your weapon. <scratching head>
 
I'm also gonna call BS (💩) on this whole thread. The OP yanking our collective chain. I doubt he even owns a gun to begin with.
Let him "carry" any way he wants but once again, I call BS here.

Link Removed
 
You guys are getting much better at presenting your case. Still not quite there yet. The only thing I'm still stuck on is the situation. Here's the scenario: if there's a knife-wielding thug 20 feet from me, I will have time to draw and rack, and shoot him. If he's much closer, again, I'm not sure I'd want to draw, even with a bullet chambered. I'd rather fend off the attack without a gun. You all seem to be siding with drawing your gun, even when you probably don't have enough time to get off a good shot. Not only that, but let's say you draw it and the thug gets it from you. Now you're probably defensless and have a bullet in you. Convince me that I'm wrong and I'll swallow my pride and chamber a round from now on. By the way, for all of you saying I should just leave my gun at home, that's the most rediculous argument I've ever heard. Obviously not having a round chambered is completely different than not having a gun. Give it a rest.
I have martial arts training, but my name's not Bruce Lee OR Sonny Chiba.

The idea that it's going to be EASIER for me to defend myself barehanded against a knife wielding opponent, than to evade him just long enough to draw and fire my loaded firearm is simply risible.

You'd rather "fend off an attack without a gun"? What you're ACTUALLY saying is that you'd rather get CUT.

Get my gun away from me HOW? My policy is that if you try to forcibly and unlawfully take the gun, you get the bullets, center of mass.

A tenchiken, followed by a draw and bullet to the back of my assailant's head or kidney beats wrestling with a probably younger, bigger, and stronger knife wielding opponent EVERY time. But then I'm one of those eccentrics who'd rather RISK getting cut to shoot his assailant, than to GUARANTEE he gets cut WITHOUT shooting his assailant.

My goal in life is to avoid harm to myself, not star in a low budget remake of "The Street Fighter".
 
i know some self defense and practice disarming someone pointing a gun at my head or back... and would do so if i could however there are scenarios that are best making a quick draw point and fire which may not give time to rack your slide ..... one in the chamber just makes sense to me as things usually happen fast and need quick response time as well
 
Finally we're having a better discussion with some good points, without the potshots. I now appreciate the feedback. I'm also open to changing my ways if someone gives me a clear reason why I should have a round chambered. So far I'm not convinced. I'm still not sure you're getting my point of situations where I believe you shouldn't draw your gun. Those are the only cases where I believe it's better not to have one in the pipe. And since I don't know when that situation may happen, I don't keep the gun ready to fire. Again, if I'm jumped or cornered unexpectedly, the last thing I'd be thinking about is trying to draw my gun. I'd be focused on how to either take down the opponent or get away. At least until an opportunity presents itself where I would have a chance to draw it. In that case, I don't think racking the slide while drawing is going to make a huge difference- a total of 1 second.

I'm sure if you train to pull rack and fire you can get good, but there is no way you can get three mechanical actions take the time of only two, we all know the chances of a situation like that happening, where a split second may count, while carrying is about like hitting the lottery, except that we would all like to hit the lottery, LOL, but a hyped up BG could possably get off 3 or 4 shots in a second, and I for one would hate to be racking the slide, or cocking the hammer while he is doing this, I understand wanting to be safe, in fact when my wife and I first started carrying we went chamber empty, then thinking about it, this lasted two or three days, then it was cocked and locked, then we started carrying Glocks, and it was just cocked and watch where your trigger finger was, while carrying our weapons with safetys I do not use them, its just something else to deal with when split seconds may count, except with the 1911s, where flipping the thumb safety off while unholstering will not slow down a responce
 
I am also proficient with martial arts. In certain circumstances, it very well may be the only option available in a close quarters combat situation.
My Sansei did not allow weapons training until brown belt status. I think this should also be part of the arsenal along with guns.
There is ALWAYS a chance that you may have to rely on something other than your gun.
Just sayin..... Ya know?
 
I'm not BSing anyone here. I'm telling you the truth. Not sure why so many cannot understand my position. Do I think I would be at a disadvantage in some instances without a round chambered, yes. Do I think I would be at a disadvantage in some instances with a round chambered, yes. That's my entire point. You may not be wrong and I may not be wrong. To each his own until I'm convinced otherwise. Good to see some others with martial arts training. That may be my biggest problem. Although karate is one of the most offensive styles in martial arts, most of the training is to diffuse the situation and get out of it. Defense, not offense. I would always choose defense before offense until I don't have a choice. I guess I'll move on and let you be. Thanks for the interesting conversation.
 

New Threads

Members online

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
49,533
Messages
610,704
Members
75,032
Latest member
BLACKROCK6
Back
Top