One in the chamber.... or not

Wow, never thought I'd have to defend my position on this forum, but after all the backlash for making a simple reply, I feel compelled to do so. Here's why I don't keep one in the chamber ALL the time: 1st, I've been carrying for a long time and have never been in a situation where I had to draw my firearm. So, did I need to keep one chambered for years, no. 2nd, whenever I felt uneasy about the situation I've been in, I've chambered a round just in case. So, I was prepared if anything happened. 3rd, see references above on numerous accidental discharges. You can't convince me that they can't happen, whether you're highly trained or not. 4th, the only scenario where I would be in a pinch is when I'm jumped by people I never saw coming. I'm not saying that this couldn't happen to me, but I am always aware of my surroundings and the people around me. So, let's say this happens to me. If I have a chance to draw my gun, there's also a chance for the bad guy to get it from me, since I was surprised. I hope he does, because when he tries to fire it at me, it won't go off and that will give me a chance to take him down or get away. At least I won't be dead. Should cops always have one chambered, YES. Why? Because their job puts them in possible danger every single day. Do I need to? No. I have nothing against anyone choosing to keep one in the chamber. That's your choice. I choose not to. Should you call me an idiot for doing so? I'm not calling you one.

I for one am not trying to attack you nor am I calling you any names sir, I am merely trying to show you the true importance of having a round allready in the chamber when carrying your sidearm on your person for 'self-defense'.

Please watch this brief training video as another case in point;

If you think that you will have the time to 'actually chamber a round' within the mere seconds that it takes for someone to physically attack you, you will probably be seriously hurt or maybe even killed.

~Stay Safe~
 
You have your own reasons and that's cool, but this reason is backwards. Why would you go into a situation you were uneasy about in the first place? Why wouldn't you instead go somewhere else instead of chambering a round?

Also, how do you go about chambering a round in a public place once you felt uneasy about the situation?
And the guy in the gas station video didn't feel uneasy. He felt like he needed gas.

There was literally NO way to predict that two straight-up ignoramuses would decide on the spur of the moment to jump him.

If he hadn't had a round chambered, they probably would have gotten his gun. A gun with an empty chamber, in the hands of two assailants wouldn't have helped. I bet the chamber wouldn't have stayed empty for long.

Try to forcibly take my gun and I shoot you with it. I consider that a MUCH better strategy than making it SAFER for you to take it.
 
There is no offence intended, but if you are afraid for whatever reason to carry with a rd in the chamber, with ANY style gun, then it would be best if you didn't carry at all,
 
P226, always loaded with a round in the chamber. There's no mechanical safety, because that's what my brain is for. IWB holster and there's no way the gun will discharge unless I intentionally draw and fire. I'm not going to draw unless I'm ready to fire. I can't conceive of an instance where I'd draw, chamber a round, and then not fire.
 
I have to disagree with your statement that the BG will ALWAYS have the element of surprise. You need to have better situational awareness. If you always keep an eye on your surroundings it eventually becomes routine and it should be very hard for someone to get close enough to surprise you.
Yup. First rules of self-defense are awareness, avoidance, deterrence, de-escalation.
 
Interesting concept... "Gun going off by "accident."" Really? I have never seen a video of a gun going off by accident. I have seen a lot of people doing really stupid things and having a gun go off. NOT by accident, but by STUPIDITY. aka - lack of concentration; judgement; too much familiarity with "the drill"; etc.
Guns going off by accident are the famous words of the anti-gun crowd. They go off because some stuck their booger hook in the trigger guard and pulled the trigger. Maybe a shirt tail gets in there, but that is "lack of concentration" not accident.

If you want to carry with out one in the chamber, I would not call you a name either. This is strictly a personal choice and is up to you. I would encourage you to practice and rethink your position.

But, a man ought to do what he thinks is right.
 
Wow, never thought I'd have to defend my position on this forum, but after all the backlash for making a simple reply, I feel compelled to do so. Here's why I don't keep one in the chamber ALL the time: 1st, I've been carrying for a long time and have never been in a situation where I had to draw my firearm. So, did I need to keep one chambered for years, no. 2nd, whenever I felt uneasy about the situation I've been in, I've chambered a round just in case. So, I was prepared if anything happened. 3rd, see references above on numerous accidental discharges. You can't convince me that they can't happen, whether you're highly trained or not. 4th, the only scenario where I would be in a pinch is when I'm jumped by people I never saw coming. I'm not saying that this couldn't happen to me, but I am always aware of my surroundings and the people around me. So, let's say this happens to me. If I have a chance to draw my gun, there's also a chance for the bad guy to get it from me, since I was surprised. I hope he does, because when he tries to fire it at me, it won't go off and that will give me a chance to take him down or get away. At least I won't be dead. Should cops always have one chambered, YES. Why? Because their job puts them in possible danger every single day. Do I need to? No. I have nothing against anyone choosing to keep one in the chamber. That's your choice. I choose not to. Should you call me an idiot for doing so? I'm not calling you one.
This line ofr thinking assumes a lot. Criminal encounters are generally a surprise even for those with good situational awareness. You don't see Flaco and his two friends creeping around cars on three sides of you. Behavioral science suggests you'll still likely be caught behind the reactionary curve. Wolves hunt in packs. Encounters are extremely violent, occur at close range and re over quickly. And there is no such thing as an accidental discharge, only negligence. He isn't taking your gun. He's stabbing or shooting you with his own. Perhaps a good PP class would bring this home for you.
 
You are absolutely correct. I went back and read that a permit holder can have a pistol chambered, however they cannot have a rifle or shotgun chambered unless they are in danger. I didn't copy/paste the statute but this website has TN's carry info on it.
 
How are you going to clear leather and get a round off in a reasonable time if you do not have one in the chamber???
 
It is my understanding from reading my state\'s law (TN) on carrying.. It is unlawful to carry with one in the chamber. Are there other states that allow this?

I've reviewed your state's laws regarding carrying. I have found one place where they mention a round in the chamber and that is to define a gun being loaded. They actually state that the gun is considered unloaded if there is not a round in the chamber and consider it loaded if there is.
 
Can you post the statue?

I think you have a mis-understanding of your state's CC laws.

Also don't forget that a TN carry permit is just that, it does not specify concealed, so the rule is open or concealed, whatever your comfortable with......but most of the instructors advise concealed
 
I've reviewed your state's laws regarding carrying. I have found one place where they mention a round in the chamber and that is to define a gun being loaded. They actually state that the gun is considered unloaded if there is not a round in the chamber and consider it loaded if there is.

Respectfully, you might want to review Tennessee laws again, my friend. You have posted incorrect information.

Tennessee statute 39-17-1301:

39-17-1301. Part definitions.

As used in this part, unless the context otherwise requires:

(18) "Unloaded" means the rifle, shotgun or handgun does not have ammunition in the chamber, cylinder, clip or magazine, and no clip or magazine is in the immediate vicinity of the weapon.

And Tennessee statute 39-17-1308:

39-17-1308. Defenses to unlawful possession or carrying of a weapon.

(a) It is a defense to the application of § 39-17-1307 if the possession or carrying was:

(1) Of an unloaded rifle, shotgun or handgun not concealed on or about the person and the ammunition for the weapon was not in the immediate vicinity of the person or weapon;

There is just a bit more to unloaded in Tennessee than no round in the chamber.
 
Obviously you guys are in a daily life-threatening situation that I don't experience. To answer your questions: I'm perfectly comfortable with carrying my gun. I'm not afraid to have a round chambered at all times, I just choose not to because I don't think it's necessary. I've had training from an officer. I'm an excellent shot and can probably draw my gun while racking the slide, shoot a target and be just as or more accurate as many of you, within a second of your actual time. That's what we're talking about here, 1 second of time, if that. I really don't think that's going to matter if you and I are in the exact situation. I'm also a second-degree blue belt in Tae Kwon Do. I'll use that training in situations where I'm jumped and actually don't want my gun to be a part of the equation. I have racked my slide in public places without anyone knowing. There are ways to do this if you are aware of your surroundings. And no, I didn't walk into a situation that I could have avoided in the first place. I found myself in situations where I became uncomfortable and worked my way out of it as quickly as I could. Last, and most important, I emphasize my position on the situation where I'm taken by surprise. Really think about this one. If I'm taken by surprise, have a gun to my head, a knife in my back, etc. Two things are going to happen: I won't have the opportunity to draw my gun or I won't want to draw my gun. So, it won't matter if a round is chambered in that situation, unless the bad guy gets my gun from me, and in that case I'll be glad I didn't have one in the pipe. If I don't have one second of time to chamber a round, I shouldn't be drawing my gun in the first place. I choose not to chamber a round, you do. To each his own. If you ever see me in a "caught on tape" video and I get killed, only because I didn't have a round chambered, feel free to laugh at me and use me as an example. Until then, let's just stick to a decent conversation with pros and cons without the potshots.
 
Bill

No risk if carried right with one in the chamber. Big risk if you need to defend and your gun isn't loaded.

Still not sure. It seems common sense would dictate one in the chamber,but I'm a little nervous about it.However,with my SP-101 its not an issue.
 
I've had training from an officer.
Other than the one SWAT sniper with whom I used to shoot service rifle matches, I've rarely been impressed with the firearms knowledge of cops, either technical or legal. In general, I've found them to be a bottomless source of INCORRECT information.
I'm an excellent shot and can probably draw my gun while racking the slide, shoot a target and be just as or more accurate as many of you, within a second of your actual time.
"Probably"... unless somebody physically restrains you... you know, the way it happened to the guy in the Dayton gas station? But hey, maybe that's the ONLY time that's EVER happened in the last two hundred years...

Carry any legal way you want. Just don't wrap it up in sophistry. "Because I don't want to." is a factually unassailable reason... unlike what you've put forth so far.
 
With my carry pistol I can thumb back the hammer to a spot where it it off the firing pin and it will stay there. Since my pistol is a double action the hammer stays off the pin and I can still draw and shoot. You would think that most manufactures would realize that so many people are goin CC that the pistols they make with a hammer should have that nice spot where its not quite down and not quite back, the safety of not having a spring loaded piece of metal stiitin on the firing pin keeping pressure ok the percussion cap and still just having to pull the trigger to get the hammer to come all the way back to drop down.
 
With my carry pistol I can thumb back the hammer to a spot where it it off the firing pin and it will stay there.
I don't know what kind of gun you're carrying, but most modern DA semi-auto handguns don't require (or recommend) carry at half-cock.

Most modern guns of the type have inertia firing pins AND firing pin blocks which prevent the firing pin from touching the primer unless the trigger is intentionally pulled.

I can't name a current, modern semi-auto handgun in which the tip of the firing pin touches the primer when the hammer is forward at rest. There may be one, but I can't name it.

If there was one, I wouldn't carry it.
 
With my carry pistol I can thumb back the hammer to a spot where it it off the firing pin and it will stay there. Since my pistol is a double action the hammer stays off the pin and I can still draw and shoot. You would think that most manufactures would realize that so many people are goin CC that the pistols they make with a hammer should have that nice spot where its not quite down and not quite back, the safety of not having a spring loaded piece of metal stiitin on the firing pin keeping pressure ok the percussion cap and still just having to pull the trigger to get the hammer to come all the way back to drop down.

Read the manufacturer's manual for your gun and I'll bet you find a warning to NOT carry the gun at half-cock. The half-cock notch is an additional safety, not a normal place for the hammer to be resting at.
 

New Threads

Members online

No members online now.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
49,533
Messages
610,704
Members
75,032
Latest member
BLACKROCK6
Back
Top