Live round in the chamber

Call me crazy but I had to try it!
I have a Ruger SR40, removed the mag and confirmed an empty chamber.
After trying this "trick" for about ten minutes, unsuccessfully, I now need to go and ice my shoulder!
Ouch!!

I'll stick to carrying with a round chambered, thank you very much!
 
I'm a supporter of CCW and an Australian who cannot carry.

What I don't understand is why people carry with a round in the chamber. It only takes a second to rack the slide, a lot less time to aim and draw, I just don't understand why people feel the need to do that.

I'd rather not risk the chance of accidental discharge. My thoughts only. Happy to be proven wrong. :)

You never know when you are going to need to pull your gun out in self defense, and if a guy walks up to you pulls a knife out and cuts you that extra second of pulling that slide back could be life or death. Plus, it is one more step you are adding to increase risk of failure. If you are in a high stress situation your mind goes blank and your body takes over. Your skin fills with blood and you get a feeling of anxiety and your legs get weak. It is your body preparing to flea. It is the way we are designed. So if this happens and you pull your gun quickly to shoot and you pull the trigger and nothing happens you will wish you had that round in the chamber. It only takes a second to put a round in the chamber, but it only takes a fraction of a second for someone to assault and/or kill you... Or one of your hands could be unattainable and you can't get the slide back to get a round in the chamber. You have to be prepared for every situation possible. You will not always know when someone is going to attack you until they have already done so....
 
for a long time i did not carry with a round in the chamber due to the fact that the Taurus TCP .380 does not have a safety on it and I figured that if I were to be attacked that I would have enough time to draw chamber and fire but after a lot of serious thought I decided that was not the case if someone were to come right at me when I walked out the door so now I carry with a round chambered at all times. I feel a little uneasy about it but I know with time it will become second nature to me just like when I started carrying in the first place. I have no fear of AD at all and I never really touch the gun anyway when it is in my pocket because that is a dead giveaway that it is there. Now that I am married I have an even stronger desire to protect not only my wife and I but anyone else who may be in danger. It all boils down to whether you actually want to be able to protect yourself or if you truly think that either you are fast enough to draw chamber and shoot or foolish enough to believe that the idiot attacking you will stop and give you time to chamber before he kills you. As always I would rather be judged by 12 than carried out by 6.
 
There are 2 formulas that are constant and unchanging:
Round in Chamber = Bang
No Round in Chamber = No Bang
 
Rifles, particularly AR/M16 platforms have a much different safety mechanism than your standard pistol. most semi-automatic pistols have a positive safety mechanism, meaning that there is not only a lock on the trigger mechanism, but also a block on the firing pin as well. dropping a modern semi auto pistol with a chambered round will not result in a discharge. semi-auto rifles (as well as pump action shotguns, any long gun for that matter), however, have a non-positive safety - meaning the safety only prevents the trigger from being pulled, but does nothing to prevent the internal mechanisms from letting loose. this is why most AD situations are typically from long guns. Most LE agencies always carry pistol with round chambered and long-guns with a full mag and an empty chamber.

ultimately, the best "safety" for your weapon is your brain and your training.

I through we had already debunked this. Modern firearms in good repair do not go off when dropped, even without a firing pin block. Long guns are not ADs waiting to happen. Ar15s even with their free floating firing pin are will not just "let loose".

Sent from my SPH-L710 using Tapatalk 2
 
Call me crazy but I had to try it!
I have a Ruger SR40, removed the mag and confirmed an empty chamber.
After trying this "trick" for about ten minutes, unsuccessfully, I now need to go and ice my shoulder!
Ouch!!

I'll stick to carrying with a round chambered, thank you very much!

LOL. I can't do it either. My SIG P220 needs two men and a boy to rack the slide.
 
This is something I had to really consider and thought about for the longest time. After debating the idea I came to a conclusion after asking myself, do I handle/treat my firearm any differently when there isnt a round in the chamber? NO, which should be everyones response to that. I now carry with one in the pipe and don't think twice about it. As long as you abide by the #1 rule and treat every firearm as if it were loaded then there wont be a problem. With that said, I would take extra precaution when holstering the firearm and make sure to use a holster with a full trigger gaurd.
 
IMO this is pretty simple stuff.
As "JSDinTexas" pointed out quite simply-
Round in Chamber = Bang
No Round in Chamber = No Bang
 
I carry with a round chambered. The seconds lost on racking a round could mean the difference of living or dying. It also reduces the chance of a malfunction when loading a round.
 
I carry with a round chambered. The seconds lost on racking a round could mean the difference of living or dying. It also reduces the chance of a malfunction when loading a round.

I agree 100% To me if someone isn't sure enough of his gun handling ability to have one in the chamber he has no business packing a gun. He needs way more training
 
Honestly, I am much more concerned facing an edged weapon than a firearm in an attack. No matter if I'm armed or not. They are much more unpredictable than a firearm. Just something I've thought about and would encourage everyone else to consider also. It never hurts to train in empty hand defense even if you carry. In fact, it is probably more important to. I also keep one in the chamber.
 
I carry with a round chambered. The seconds lost on racking a round could mean the difference of living or dying. It also reduces the chance of a malfunction when loading a round.

If it takes you seconds to rack, you are doing something wrong. Most competent shooters can rack within half a second with ease.
 
The time used for racking a round could be used for shooting your assailant. Always keep a round racked, bad guys do.

:triniti:
 
Regarding:

"As a civilian, if someone was trying to mug me at knife point, i'd give him my wallet, let him walk away, then shoot the fucker!!!"

If you were ever to get a CCW, you would be taught in your training the ONLY reason you shoot someone is to "stop" them from taking your life and limb which you believe will "imminently" happen. When someone just robbed you and they walked away and are no longer threatening you, you let them walk away and don't antagonize them, you calmly call 911 for help and "be a good witness" and describe him/her accurately. This is what I learned in CCW classes. I have 13 ccw's. It is also the ability to be mature and not let your emotions of fear, anger, vengeance overcome you so that you give in to shooting someone as s/he "walks away." Being a CCW holder requires a mature frame of mind. IN one of my tactical training classes it was drilled in my head "Is it worth dying over?" Not many things are, I can think of my life and the lives of my loved ones, not much else. That parking space, my wallet, my car, that spot in line...take it. I will be passive and humble and say "I don't want any trouble" -- knowing full well I have a CCW and pistol and can confidently take it out and be firm in 0-60 just like that. In your scenario, I'd let him walk away, thank God I was not hurt, and get a good description of him and if he is only "walking" away and not running perhaps the police will get here while he is walking across the street.
 
If it takes you seconds to rack, you are doing something wrong. Most competent shooters can rack within half a second with ease.

Given the reaction time necessary to respond to such an issue (life-threatening assault), the presumption that you'll have that half-second to cycle the slide, let alone two free hands to do so, is faulty.
 
If it takes you seconds to rack, you are doing something wrong. Most competent shooters can rack within half a second with ease.
...without somebody hanging onto one or both of their arms.
... or without trying to stop somebody from stabbing, beating or choking them to death.

Carrying with an empty chamber is essentially trying to create a "fair fight" for somebody unlawfully trying to maim or murder you.

I learned in the U.S. Army (and from fifty years of reading history) that if you find yourself in a "fair fight", your planning skills have failed you BADLY, probably FATALLY.
 
what if you get injured or pinned by ruble etc? being able to operate the weapon with only one hand is a very valuable skill.

If I was carrying a bag/baby/valuable item and needed to draw, I could and function the gun very well. with out a round in the chamber, not so much. I used to be a huge fan of Israeli draw but as of late, not so much.

A better option is click safety off and acquire target.
 

New Threads

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
49,533
Messages
610,704
Members
75,032
Latest member
BLACKROCK6
Back
Top