Live round in the chamber

Its all in the wording but you are fight its negligence that causes most dilscharges that are unintended. Just as its negligence on someones part that causes most traffic accidents.
 
I'm a supporter of CCW and an Australian who cannot carry.

What I don't understand is why people carry with a round in the chamber. It only takes a second to rack the slide, a lot less time to aim and draw, I just don't understand why people feel the need to do that.

I'd rather not risk the chance of accidental discharge. My thoughts only. Happy to be proven wrong. :)

My LC9's magazine only carries 7 rounds so I carry 7+1. Why? In case I'm confronted by 8 BG's instead of 7.
 
it might take a few days or even a couple weeks to get used to but after reading dozens of stories where people had to use a firearm in self defense, i personally view it as the way to go. not to mention, any modern firearm wont accidentally discharge. most accidental discharges happen when the main safety (located between the ears) malfunctions and puts a finger on the trigger when it shouldn't be.
 
A 1911 in condition one is the same condition as any Tupperware gun with a round in the chamber. Locked cocked and ready to go boom.


How do you carry a revolver that does not have a round in the chamber.


A gun with no round in the chamber is an unloaded brick.
 
Mots tupperware guns (glock, I had two of them)
when you rack a round the firing pin (striker) is held back. when the trigger is pulled it releases the striker.
so it is "cocked" if a round is in the chamber.


No the striker is not pulled back with the trigger pull. its not on a glock or an XD ( had one of them too)
 
So, OP, if you are afraid of an accidental discharge, is it possibly because you have not trained sufficiently to develop trigger finger discipline? If that is the case, then you are nowhere near well trained enough to carry a firearm in public. Or is that you simply do not understand firearms enough to realize that the ultimate safety is the one between ones ears, not any mechanism on the gun? If so, then you are not well trained enough to carry a firearm in public.

Get more training, if you can in Australia, and come back to tell us what you think then.

Thanks everyone for taking the time to respond to my question. And thanks for the welcome!!!

As an Australian, my ignorance of this is quite common in my country. Pistol owners in Australia cannot store their firearms loaded. In the event of a home invasion, we would have an incredibly hard time justifying in court that we had time to open our safe, unlock our separately stored ammo, load and shoot the intruder, all after we decided our life was in danger.

We cannot carry pistols loaded or unloaded on our person, in our car glove box or anywhere else in our vehicle during normal travels. In fact they need to be transported in a locked container, unloaded with ammo locked seperately and can only be transported in a vehicle when directly heading to a range.

Hence why the question because we have no experience in carrying a pistol loaded and holstered each and every hour of every day!

I shoot IPSC and our firearms are only loaded with a round in the chamber when we're told to load and make ready by a range officer on the firing line.

I compete in National and International competitions and will be at the world IPSC shoot, hosted every 3 years, which coincidentally happens to be in America in 2014. Last shoot was in Greece in 2011 and in Indonesia 2008. There hasn't been a world shoot in the US since 1986.

I think i'll forego the firearms safety training...as I like to live on the edge. Oh but please explain what a sear is to me because I forgot. My undestanding is it's a seal with a bent fin.

It is very clear to me that the OP has no Idea of how a firearm works or how fast an attack can happen. He is one of those better off without a gun

I tell you what. When I get to the US, how about we have a little competition. I'll bet you $1000 I can draw, rack and get a single shot on a target quicker and more accurately than you can aim and fire. Exception clause... you fire relatively the same time I do and you're not a competition IPSC shooter. :dirol:

A 1911 in condition one is the same condition as any Tupperware gun with a round in the chamber. Locked cocked and ready to go boom.
How do you carry a revolver that does not have a round in the chamber.
A gun with no round in the chamber is an unloaded brick.

My question was specific to a single action semi auto with a round in the chamber and the hammer back. A 5lb hammer pull on a double action semi-auto or revolver has never crossed my mind as unsafe. I should have been more specific that my concern was about a single action auto with the hammer back with only a small amount of metal (the sear) preventing the hammer from dropping.

Obviously you haven't handled a semi-auto pistol before. That one second "could" be the difference. If your pistol jams when trying to rack the slide, "it will be the difference". While not having any actual statistics, I would guess that the odds are several hundred to one in favor of a jam during the racking process compared to a light strike or other malfunction of an already chambered live round. So actually, I cannot understand why anyone WOULD NOT have a round chambered.

The risk of accidental discharge is even less of a possibility. Consider yourself proven wrong. :laugh:

Obviously you haven't handled a semi-auto pistol before. Pistols tend to jam during / after extraction of a case, not when racking the slide. I fire 10,000+ rounds a year. The only stoppage i've had in the last 3 years was with a round of factory ammo, during extraction of the previous fired case.

I doubt that would be very advisable, not even in down under ;-)

And you're assuming or hoping that just by giving the perp your stuff the confrontation is over. That's very optimistic and might end up with you getting stabbed to Death anyway.

You obviously have a sense of humor. :) I was kidding about shooting them after the fact, but you seem to be one of the few that picked up on that.

Watching that video, it still seems to take 21 feet of distance to stop an imminent knife attack. I still believe negotiation is your best form of first line defence. Nobody can stop someone coming at them with a knife in a surprise attack! But then again, the motivation of such an attack is improbable.

When I get to the US, I will most certainly carry with a live round in the chamber though. Considering a glock because of the advanced safety features, reliability and compact style. Perhaps a glock 26.

Thanks for the comment.

geez- all these blistering replies telling our Aussie friend he's gonna rot in jail,he's a murderer.....I guess nobody that replies to this post noticed that it was DRIPPING in sarcasm...sure-we'de all like to "shoot the fucker" but we all know better in real life....lighten up....

I was very surprised with the responses too! Good on you for having a personality. :)

I'm very pro gun and the right to defend yourself. I envy the laws you have in the US of A. What a great country. Don't ever let those democrats or gun control fanatics take your rights away. I reckon when you do away with 'gun free zones', your firearms laws will be perfect.
 
The Glock 26 (9mm) & the Glock 27 (.40) are two very excellent choices! =-)
Check this video out....


9mm is enough to stop any mofo. :) Great video too.

Now I just need to work out how I can get my CCW permit as a legal alien (travelling on a visa), as opposed to an illegal alien that cannot carry.
 
9mm is enough to stop any mofo. :) Great video too.

Now I just need to work out how I can get my CCW permit as a legal alien (travelling on a visa), as opposed to an illegal alien that cannot carry.

You must not be from Southern California eh?
Many illegal aliens are carrying concealed handguns on a daily basis over there and they don't have permits for them!
 
I am a legal alien and I have a CCW permit ... kind of a story behind that, though, had to jump thu some hoops ...
 
Excellent! How did you jump through the hoops. What is your situation?

I don't know about Australia but here in the US each State does his own thing about gun laws, at least to some degree. My home State does not issue permits to non-citizens so I had to get a Utah non-resident permit which my State does acknowledge as valid. So I am a German with a greencard living in NC and carrying with a UT permit, gun is an XD so it was made in Croatia. Go figure ;-)
 

New Threads

Members online

No members online now.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
49,533
Messages
610,704
Members
75,032
Latest member
BLACKROCK6
Back
Top