Live round in the chamber

The only AD that I have ever heard of occurred when someone was playing with their weapon, or when they had modified their weapon themself improperly, or when they had become distracted while cleaning their weapon. I have seen rounds hang time at the range but that is different.

I disagree. These are are "negligent discharges" because they would not have happen without human negligence, except for the hang fire.
 
I disagree. These are are "negligent discharges" because they would not have happen without human negligence, except for the hang fire.
  1. Accidental Discharge: The gun does something it shouldn't.
  2. Negligent Discharge: The person does something they shouldn't.
Conservatively speaking, 2 happens at least 100 times more often than 1.
 
That's a great video, but how many confrontations involve someone holding a knife threatening to attack you from over 21 feet away? !!!!

As a civilian, if someone was trying to mug me at knife point, i'd give him my wallet, let him walk away, then shoot the fucker!!!

If you were to let them walk away then shoot them that would most likely be a murder charge against you since at that point the threat is over.
 
This horse has been beat to death, while you are pulling your weapon racking a round into the chamber, I will be slapping my second magazine into my pistol, but carry how you feel is best for you, Israel defense/police do not carry a round in the chamber of their pistols, that is a directive not a personal choice of some of the folks I happen to know.
 
If you don't have a round chambered and someone grabs one of your arms you probably won't be able to chamber a round even if your other arm can draw. It's difficult to work the slide single-handed.

If you insist that a chambered round is unsafe then maybe you should carry a double-action revolver with no round under the hammer. Then if you can draw you can fire.
 
If you don't have a round chambered and someone grabs one of your arms you probably won't be able to chamber a round even if your other arm can draw. It's difficult to work the slide single-handed.
There are ways to chamber a round one handed. They all involve either pointing your firearm at YOURSELF, or someone conveniently leaving a table or bench at the RANDOM spot where somebody has chosen to try to rob, rape or murder you.

I was amused by a poster in a previous thread on this subject who was MORE afraid of carrying a securely holstered firearm with a loaded chamber, than of trying to chamber a round, one handed, by hooking the slide on his belt or pocket, while somebody was trying to beat, choke or stab him to death.

If you insist that a chambered round is unsafe then maybe you should carry a double-action revolver with no round under the hammer. Then if you can draw you can fire.
Or, as one 19th century governor of the State of New York suggested for the State Militia, you could just carry a club...
 
You say you are an aussie well if you live in the USA legally you can well you can in GA im English and i have a carry permit
 
I carry my gun without any bullets,my taser with out batteries,and pepper spray without pressure..You know just to be safe.
 
Lots of good reasons have been cited here already. But let me sum up the two main reasons I think a gun that's not chambered, (or a single-action that's not cocked) is much less useful in a potential "critical incident" than one that's essentially ready to fire with a trigger press (and maybe a quick safety off flick):
1. There's a very good chance that if I need to draw and use my gun, that I won't have full use of both hands. I'll likely need at least one of them to be fighting off the attacker. Try racking a slide with when you have to have one hand otherwise occupied next time you go to the range, and let's see how effective that gun is for you now?
2. Reaction time, vs. distance. I couldn't possibly describe this any better than the video in the first response did, so I won't even try. Let's just say it's very valid and has been supported by many tests over and over.

HOWEVER, trumping all of this, I personally believe that no one should carry if they don't feel safe and comfortable doing so. So if you can't bring yourself to feel like you're able to carry comfortably or with a reasonable degree of safety with a chambered round, then by all means don't. Just think about the issue, weigh the options, and make your decisions based on what is best for you. For some people, this is to not carry at all. No one should be forced to carry. (sounds like you've already done that. So good job!)
 
If you don't have a round chambered and someone grabs one of your arms you probably won't be able to chamber a round even if your other arm can draw. It's difficult to work the slide single-handed.
There are ways to chamber a round one handed. They all involve either pointing your firearm at YOURSELF, or someone conveniently leaving a table or bench at the RANDOM spot where somebody has chosen to try to rob, rape or murder you.

I was amused by a poster in a previous thread on this subject who was MORE afraid of carrying a securely holstered firearm with a loaded chamber, than of trying to chamber a round, one handed, by hooking the slide on his belt or pocket, while somebody was trying to beat, choke or stab him to death.

If you insist that a chambered round is unsafe then maybe you should carry a double-action revolver with no round under the hammer. Then if you can draw you can fire.
Or, as one 19th century governor of the State of New York suggested for the State Militia, you could just carry a club...

One of the parts of the handgun I have now which I will have on every firearm from now on, are what is considered "combat sights," with other various names. Very tall block shape sights, I can hook those on my belt, holster, heel, curb, pretty much anything and rack my slide without pointing it at myself.

But, I reserve that for worse case scenario that I have lost an arm, and I have a malfunction. Until then I feel being prepared is better than having to prepare at the last moment. So I keep a round chambered.

I don't wait till I get in an accident to buckle up. An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure. No one prepares to fail, they just fail to prepare. (although these "one in the chamber" discussions do seem to be people preparing to fail...)
 
That's a great video, but how many confrontations involve someone holding a knife threatening to attack you from over 21 feet away? !!!!

As a civilian, if someone was trying to mug me at knife point, i'd give him my wallet, let him walk away, then shoot the fucker!!!

That's what we in America call murder.
 
I'm a supporter of CCW and an Australian who cannot carry.

What I don't understand is why people carry with a round in the chamber. It only takes a second to rack the slide, a lot less time to aim and draw, I just don't understand why people feel the need to do that.

I'd rather not risk the chance of accidental discharge. My thoughts only. Happy to be proven wrong. :)



The attacker's gun, knife, bat, sword, tire iron, brick, brass knuckles, are always already in their hand ready to go. Since we the good guys have to have our weapon holstered rather than already in our hand, being able to skip the extra slide rack step will atleast give us a fighting chance to defend
 
Have been practicing from 15 feet a lot, maybe need to go out to 25 and shoot more?

Also makes me believe a backup in the pocket is worthwhile.

Bersa Thunder .32
Bersa Thunder .380
Ruger SR9c 9mm

All for carry in IWB

Kel-Tec P-32 ---- pocket gun

:triniti:
 
That's a great video, but how many confrontations involve someone holding a knife threatening to attack you from over 21 feet away? !!!!

As a civilian, if someone was trying to mug me at knife point, i'd give him my wallet, let him walk away, then shoot the fucker!!!

Don't know about the laws in Australia but here in the states if you did that you would be likely be charged with assault with a deadly weapon, armed criminal action, murder if you killed him or attempted murder if you didn't kill him and who knows what else. Why? Because the threat would be seen as being over when he turned and walked away.
 
One of the parts of the handgun I have now which I will have on every firearm from now on, are what is considered "combat sights," with other various names. Very tall block shape sights, I can hook those on my belt, holster, heel, curb, pretty much anything and rack my slide without pointing it at myself.
The question is, can you do that while WRESTLING with somebody trying to choke, beat or stab you to death without pointing it at yourself? Not likely.

But as you said, that's for when you don't have a CHOICE. We both recognize that we have the CHOICE to chamber BEFORE any of that becomes necessary.
 

New Threads

Members online

No members online now.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
49,533
Messages
610,704
Members
75,032
Latest member
BLACKROCK6
Back
Top