Let me enlighten you on NYS politics and voters. State population 19 million. NYC population 8 million. Suffolk County population 1.5 million. Westchester and Rockland County population combined 1.2 million. That's nearly 11 million of the state's 19 million people. That's about 56% of the state population living in less than 3% of the state land in and around NYC, controlling the vote. Most common party affiliation is democrat. Strong liberal base. Large population of foreigners and minorities... strong anti-gun stronghold.
.
Now move upstate and have a look. About 8 million people spread across 53,000 square miles. That's about 44% of the state population living in more than 97% of the state land. Primarily republican voters who's vote is disenfranchised. By the way... nearly 1 million CCW permits in that population of 8 million. NYC and it's surrounding area controls the state. Controls the capital and controls the presidential electoral vote from NYS.
.
Upstate is farmland, mountains, deer and bear hunting, trout fishing, skiing and wilderness. Mostly regular folks. Now why, other than complete ignorance about the facts, would you punish the owner of a hunting lodge or some other pro-gun business because they don't have the voting power to control the largest city in America? remeber some things about upstate NY. For one, they will require permit renewal for the first time... something most other states already do. And they still have no restrictions on things like sitting in a bar armed. Try that in your state. While I don't agree with what happened I have a hard time placing blame on people who were completely blindsided by this.
.
Counties immediately adjacent to NYC are culpable as they're populated by NYC transplants who can't afford $1.2 million for a two-bedroom condo. But not true for those as close as 50 miles away. These counties offer unrestricted CCW permits within 40-50 miles of NYC. I don't expect you to understand but the people of upstate are the ones who took it in the rear, courtesy of NYC and surrounding populace. You want to blame them? Well, their not the problem. Most of us wish NYC would secede from the state and form their own state.