One in the pipe

In a hot situation you won't get a round chambered fast enough. An unchambered gun is a club.
I wouldn't say you absolutely "WON'T", but I wouldn't bet money on it, nevermind my life and limb.

A deadly force encounter is fraught with enough simultaneous, split second life and death choices; why add MORE?

SMART people strive to REDUCE the number of potential points of failure in life threatening situations.
 
I wouldn't say you absolutely "WON'T", but I wouldn't bet money on it, nevermind my life and limb.

A deadly force encounter is fraught with enough simultaneous, split second life and death choices; why add MORE?

SMART people strive to REDUCE the number of potential points of failure in life threatening situations.

This goes along with my argument. During the discussion with my brother-in-law I brought up the possibility of short stroking the slide and the firearm failing to go into battery or producing a failure to feed. All he could really say is that I should know how my "weapon" works.

I do agree that everyone who carries should be aware of basic firearms manipulation. I think many others with his argument fail to realize how the human body responds in a fight or flight scenario. Losing control of fine motor skills during a situation like this could cost people their lives. I guess it's impossible to reason with some folks. I'll continue to carry with one in the pipe and he'll continue to carry his way and the world will continue to turn. Thanks for the input.
 
Losing control of fine motor skills during a situation like this could cost people their lives.
I don't even see this as a matter of fine motor skills.

As the example I gave points out, I'm not willing to bet that I can fight off two people physically assaulting me from front and rear, SIMULTANEOUSLY, while at the same time chambering a round with ONE hand. I'm guessing that if I tell my assailants, "Go stand over there while I pull my gun and chamber a round so that I can shoot both of you.", I'm not going to get a favorable reaction, much less compliance.
 
I don't even see this as a matter of fine motor skills.
Agree. We always teach PP techniques that use only gross motor skills. Racking the slide should be second nature as a gross motor skill. The example I use for fine motor skills is putting six bullets in your revolver while under fire. You'll drop em. Thus I recommend revolver fans use speed-loaders.
 
I don't even see this as a matter of fine motor skills.

As the example I gave points out, I'm not willing to bet that I can fight off two people physically assaulting me from front and rear, SIMULTANEOUSLY, while at the same time chambering a round with ONE hand. I'm guessing that if I tell my assailants, "Go stand over there while I pull my gun and chamber a round so that I can shoot both of you.", I'm not going to get a favorable reaction, much less compliance.

Agree. We always teach PP techniques that use only gross motor skills. Racking the slide should be second nature as a gross motor skill. The example I use for fine motor skills is putting six bullets in your revolver while under fire. You'll drop em. Thus I recommend revolver fans use speed-loaders.

Point taken. My reason for saying fine motor skills was more geared toward clearing a potential malfunction if the slide is not racked properly during a high stress situation.
 
Point taken. My reason for saying fine motor skills was more geared toward clearing a potential malfunction if the slide is not racked properly during a high stress situation.
The odds are very good that if you find yourself in the same situation as the guy in the Dayton gas station that you won't even get a chance to short stroke the slide. You'll probably never get the chance to retract the slide at all before they overwhelm and disarm you. Then the REAL "fun" starts...
 
It is NOTHING like carrying a cell phone without a battery. It's like turning off your cell phone while you carry it. Except the firearm is a LOT faster into action from empty chamber than a cell phone is from off to on.

Stupid analogy used to overstate a good point. Keep it real and drop the hyperbole.
Lighten up brother. I would suggest getting more ruffage in your diet. You seem to be experiencing a lot of pain. Even impressed you were able to use "hyperbole" with all that pain going on.
-
I would add that not having a round chambered and ready to go is like going and you find out you don't have any toilet paper.
Cooking a turkey without having a turkey in the oven?
Putting socks on without putting your shoes on and walk a mile?
Buying a Maserati and not putting gas in it?
-
Is the point made? What's the Boy Scouts motto? Lots of questions..........
 
The odds are very good that if you find yourself in the same situation as the guy in the Dayton gas station that you won't even get a chance to short stroke the slide. You'll probably never get the chance to retract the slide at all before they overwhelm and disarm you. Then the REAL "fun" starts...

...and that sir is why I only carry in condition 1. Life is too unpredictable. I never want to find myself in a situation such as the one you speak of. That is why situational awareness coupled with preparedness is priceless.
 
Based on my TRAINING and EXPERIENCE I carry a fully loaded and functional pistol (condition 1 if you please).

A person who is fully aware of what/whom he must protect himself from would do nothing less!

As my beloved grandfather was know to say "do what you want, 'cause you will anyway"

Just my 2 bits worth:pleasantry:
 
Here's the video of the Ohio robbery. This guy is a member of another forum I'm on. Ask yourself if you would have time to rack the slide in this real world situation.

 
None taken. However, judging by some of the responses I take it my question has misrepresented my level of experience. I'll take the time to clarify. I'm new to this forum but I am not new to concealed carry by no means. I've been carrying for over a decade. The reason I posed this question is due to a recent debate with my brother-in-law. He was quite critical of the fact that I carry with a round chambered. This blew my mind because I've never known of any other way to carry. He seems to be of the opinion that my way of carry is unsafe and that I should see trouble brewing before hand and have plenty of time to draw my firearm, rack the slide, and engage the threat. I just wanted to see what everyone else thought. I guess I should have assumed that this question has probably been asked a million times. My only assumption was that anyone tired of this topic would bypass this thread but we all know what they say about assuming.

That's cool, and your right on all accounts except one, its not just a million times more like ten million times :sarcastic:
 
Lighten up brother. I would suggest getting more ruffage in your diet. You seem to be experiencing a lot of pain. Even impressed you were able to use "hyperbole" with all that pain going on.
-
I would add that not having a round chambered and ready to go is like going and you find out you don't have any toilet paper.
Cooking a turkey without having a turkey in the oven?
Putting socks on without putting your shoes on and walk a mile?
Buying a Maserati and not putting gas in it?
-
Is the point made? What's the Boy Scouts motto? Lots of questions..........

You sir are WAY to kind, I would have really let him have it, in fact I might anyhow, just who the **** does he think he is a newbe comeing on here and telling a senior member that his comments are stupid, **** him and the horse he road in on
 
now I know why my Mommy told me to stay away from discussion boards so long ago.
Later.

Well then, to quote Stengun.....

Move out of your Moms basement!
As far as this forum is concerned, don't let the keyboard hit you in the azz on the way out!

Later!


Sent from behind Enemy Lines.
 
Just tell your Brother-in-law you decided to carry a revolver from now on. Also, if he ever had an accident of any kind ask him why he didn't avoid it since he should have seen trouble coming as he expects you to see the same. Love to hear his reaction.
 

New Threads

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
49,533
Messages
610,704
Members
75,032
Latest member
BLACKROCK6
Back
Top