One in chamber? Yes / No

Status
Not open for further replies.
Quote Originally Posted by dstryr

Why? That is an answer most often based on emotion and not factual evidence.

A bad guy will be coming in loaded. Wouldn't you want to extend him the same courtesy?


Again, he was being sarcastic. Not sure that you're going to find that progressive of a thought process on this forum.

Holy crap did I miss that bad.:redface:
 
I carry all day, every day. I always have one in the chamber with safety on. Why?........This is not the "Old West" and how many times are you going to get into a quick draw contest. Even so, carrying one chambered could save you 1-3 seconds over the other guy if they have to take safety off, chamber a round before they shoot. It could be the difference between life and death.
 
At this moment there are 5 loaded and chambered guns in the house. One on the table near my wife, one on a table near me, my carry gun chambered and holstered by the bed (where I changed into comfortable sweats) and one in each quick access bedside gun safes.
 
Massad Ayood has reported on numerous ocassions how quickly someone with a knife can close from a dozen feet. This video on YouTube clearly shows exactly what he has reported in print, and makes clear why everyone who carries (and everyone who can should), should carry with on in the chamber.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=syxrpLbaEuY
(Of course, one should have the safety on and train so that removing the safety as part fo the draw is second nature.)
 
I carry all day, every day. I always have one in the chamber with safety on. Why?........This is not the "Old West" and how many times are you going to get into a quick draw contest. Even so, carrying one chambered could save you 1-3 seconds over the other guy if they have to take safety off, chamber a round before they shoot. It could be the difference between life and death.

As somewhat of a old west historian, quick draw almost never occurred in the real world (Hollywood), you were more likely to be shot in back and the only reason you carried you weapon without a round under the hammer was safety to prevent you shooting your horse or self, single action required cocking weapon and moved the empty chamber to a live one.
 
Consider the Tueller drill. Perp can close 20 feet in 1.5 seconds to deliver a fatal stab or blow. No one is racking a slide in time. Chamber the round, holster your gat and don't keep touching it.
.
 
Yep SR,

Absolutely. But being conscious of safety I also have a thumb safety on my Ruger SR40c, one of the reasons I bought that gun.
I do not miss a beat with my Ruger SR40C,I've practice enough that I lose not a nano second dropping the safety in a draw and prepare situation,My Other carry is a Colt Detective 38 Special ,its like the camera -Point and Shoot..I think situational awareness should be considered about a safety being on,mainly that would be the distance between You and any threat and Your ability to see at least 20-to 25 yards in a open circle around Your location.
 
I got to tell, after reading a good part of this thread, I have started to carry one chambered, I'm fairly new to carry and of course didn't see the need to carry one in the chamber, but you guys definitely made me change my mind and have a different perspective of things.
I carry a S.A. XD 9mm Subcompact, and has a trigger safety plus a grip safety, so I think it's safe and convenient at the same time since you don't have to worry about a safety switch, just get a good grip, point ans shoot.

Thanks for this post!!
 
330 posts? Are we done yet? I see the horse... he has been thoroughly beaten.

If you can still recognize it as a horse...it hasn't been beaten enough...

I think the horse just got some CPR:

I got to tell, after reading a good part of these thread, I have started to carry one chambered, I'm fairly new to carry and of course didn't see the need to carry one in the chamber, but you guys definitely made me change my mind and have a different perspective of things.
I carry a S.A. XD 9mm Subcompact, and has a trigger safety plus a grip safety, so I think it's safe and convenient at the same time since you don't have to worry about a safety switch, just get a good grip, point ans shoot.

Thanks for this post!!

Yep, she's ready for another round around the links now!

thug_zps33b56553.gif


LOL

(No offense intended to XD9_MS - after you've seen this thread and several dozens just like it go on endlessly, you'll understand why we're jokin' around about it....kinda! LOL)

Blues
 
I think the horse just got some CPR:



Yep, she's ready for another round around the links now!

thug_zps33b56553.gif


LOL

(No offense intended to XD9_MS - after you've seen this thread and several dozens just like it go on endlessly, you'll understand why we're jokin' around about it....kinda! LOL)

Blues

Do I have the heart to tell Blues that the animal being beaten is a ??? cow? :sarcastic:
 
This topic comes up all the time and it is a no win for either side. If I carry with a round in the chamber someone is going to say I’m an unsafe gun owner, if I carry with an empty chamber someone will say I’m an unprepared gun owner and then the urinating contest begins.

So here’s the deal, I carry my pistol with a round in the chamber because not doing so (IMO) causes far more problems than it solves.

Whether or not you choose to carry with a round in the chamber isn’t going to affect my life even a little bit, so you do your own research, conduct your own risk assessment, make your own decision and you live with the consequences good or bad of that decision.
 
Ok. At this point I think it's safe to say the horse AND the cow have been thoroughly thrashed. :biggrin:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

New Threads

Members online

No members online now.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
49,531
Messages
610,695
Members
75,032
Latest member
BLACKROCK6
Back
Top