For me, the Supertuck is year 'round with the exception of when discretion is paramount then I'll let a trusted LCP ride in the pocket with a flap style pocket holster. You know, like to the post office, school or similar place that is a "no gun" zone but is the most likely target for shoot 'em up thugs...
Even at home when not planning on going anywhere, i just feel more comfy CC. I dunno why, some like Pepsi some like Coke.
Seeing as how outside the waist (standard belt) holsters tend to be more comfortable overall for obvious reasons, I would think your choices there would be much easier. So maybe you could end up being reasonably happy with most any (quality made) OWB holster?
Good luck in your search!