To Chamber or Not to Chamber?

For me it comes down to what type of gun I am carrying. Years ago I used to buy a good handgun, but then go cheap on the holster. Stupid. I was always afraid to carry the G26 with a round in the chamber because of the flimsy holster. I corrected that. I used to feel a little nervous about shooting myself in the leg or butt, but that is just dumb to think that as long as I holstered the gun properly. The ones I own were built with firing pin blocks and safeties for a reason, so I use them the way they were engineered to be used. I practice with them the way I am supposed to so that I can use them without really thinking much about it - I just do it because I have done it so much it has become instinct. We should do as we feel comfortable, but I was practicing once trying to quickly draw and rack a round in the chamber and I was amazed at how many times I would "slip" and not rack the round. (Snap caps) Just my two pennies worth.:laugh:
 
With my S&W Sigma i can carry one in the chamber confidently because the trigger pull is in excess of 10 pounds and thats not going to be accidentally pressed in almost any situation but i can understand how it might make you us-easy to do something like that with a gun that has a 5 pound trigger pull.

Not having 1 in the chamber can be effective if someone gets your weapon and you don't have to worry about them immediately shooting you but since most attacks happen at an arms length you will want to be prepared.
 
With my S&W Sigma i can carry one in the chamber confidently because the trigger pull is in excess of 10 pounds and thats not going to be accidentally pressed in almost any situation but i can understand how it might make you us-easy to do something like that with a gun that has a 5 pound trigger pull.

Not having 1 in the chamber can be effective if someone gets your weapon and you don't have to worry about them immediately shooting you but since most attacks happen at an arms length you will want to be prepared.

Agreed. There are so many scenarios that can happen, very quickly, I think we are kinda chasing our tails trying to figure out who is right and who is wrong on this topic. I'll carry the way it makes me comfortable and leave the rest up to God to decide.:yu:
 
Stuff like that makes me glad to have a heavy trigger pull on my gun. It sucks at the range but makes it safer for me to keep it +1 .

As i have said before if i was carrying something like a Glock with a much lighter trigger it would be a tough decision.
 
Not that I'm by any means an expert, except that qual thing in the Navy, but I don't remember ever reading about a 1911 MOD1 ever discharging while cocked & locked. Please enlighten me if you find anything.

"The smallest minority on earth is the individual. Those who deny individual rights cannot claim to be defenders of minorities." --author and philosopher Ayn Rand (1905-1982)
 
Not that I'm by any means an expert, except that qual thing in the Navy, but I don't remember ever reading about a 1911 MOD1 ever discharging while cocked & locked. Please enlighten me if you find anything.

"The smallest minority on earth is the individual. Those who deny individual rights cannot claim to be defenders of minorities." --author and philosopher Ayn Rand (1905-1982)

Me too, but in the Marines - we are cousins. Anyway, the only accidental discharge I recall is one where the guy next to me on the firing line, drops his series 70 (what we all had) 1911A1, and it goes off and sent the round between us and behind! Guys back there crapped their pants and he spent the next few hours bending and thrusting. :fie:
 
I tend to be happiest with my Glocks with the NY1 triggers in them (it is an easy mod) so that the trigger pull is 8# I believe. Next in line, I would have to say, is my Sig P239. First trigger pull is something like 8.5# and subsequent pulls are about 3.5# I think. (Can't be bothered to look it up). But you get the idea.

If you are squeemish about carrying hot then try the universal cocked and locked experiment; no round in the chamber but cocked and locked (whatever you are using); carry like that for a month and see if you have anything even closely resembling an 'incident'.

I can tell you for a fact that having one in the chamber is no longer a decision for me in any way, shape or form. We (my family and I) were accosted by a sky high druggie at a traffic light with a huge revolver and I had nowhere to hide. Unfortunately I was not carrying at the time (never again where legal) but had I been carrying there is NO WAY IN THE WORLD that I could have racked a semiautomatic and got the drop on the beast. A revolver? Yep, maybe so. So I decided that I would go for the best of both worlds and carry a semiautomatic with a slightly heavier trigger pull, especially on the first round fired. Or a semi with a triple safety (Glock does NOT have a triple safety guys)... I'm talking (1) a thumb safety, and (2) a grip safety, and (3) a trigger guard and good holster for safety. THAT is safety.....

I still love my Glocks but they take special handling as if that trigger gets twitched it goes bang. They are by far the most reliable handguns I own and by far the most dangerous handguns I own. Treat them with respect and care and you will not have a problem. Weigh the benefits against the potential threat and your decision should be obvious.

I am still pondering guys. Still pondering. But one thing I know for an absolute fact. An absolute truth. Your life will one day depend on having one in the chamber and the gun hot.

Oh.... the guy with the revolver and I am unarmed? I just waited until the traffic cleared and he teetered a bit and I hit the pedal to the metal and left him in a cloud of dust hoping that he would not start shooting. He did not.

I now avoid states that will not let me carry concealed like the plague. And living in Canada I am only a few very short years away from full retirement and we are already buying property down south as our base of operations once the kids are ensconced in college and we are fully retired and with motorhome. I just wish that as a U.S. citizen that we were one of "We the People" everywhere but apparently that is not so in several states. Those states we avoid like the plague and include New York, New Jersey, Illinois, Florida and others. If you do not recognize my several concealed carry permits (and I should not require ANY permit) then you do not want my presence nor my tourist dollars nor my resident dollars.

Funny thing is that we are planning on moving to Florida for strictly economic reasons (cheap for the kids to fly down) and hope that the BP oil thing doesn't screw things up for us too much.

And where did I get gun in the nose? Orlando, Florida... broad daylight... home of Mickey. Phoooey. Think they've change the rules as of late and the new statute has a preamble that now states that the definition of a resident is a citizen. That would be me.

In any event, I digress. I hate carrying one in the chamber and hot but it is a necessary evil. Just choose your gun wisely and carry it safely. Revolvers, BTW, are a whole nother story guys... cylinder doesn't revolve cuz your holster is tight you have no issues with AD/ND's, right? And if you want to be really safe if your revolver does not have a firing pin blocking plate then simply carry one less round with the hammer down on an empty hole. Simple.

At home, the gun is filled to the brim with one in the chamber and ready to go. It has the best of night sights and the strongest available gunlight under the barrel so I don't shoot the dog. I also carry the brightest available flashlight to misdirect return fire (mind, after the first round is fired you are going to get lead coming at the muzzle flash anyway). Our alarm is set to light up the downstairs like daylight when tripped to blind the perps and we have (need to replace it actually) a 3 million candlepower battery operated spotlight by the bed as well. One brief shot of that in the face of a perp coming in from the dark and he'll be blinking while being made into swiss cheese. Just make sure the splatter is on the INSIDE of the house and not on the porch.

And make sure YOU get the first accurate shot away. Better yet, make sure that you get several first shots away!

Last but not least... if you REALLY want safe and don't mind 9mm and 8 round capacity, take a look at the HK P7 series (I have a P7M8 and a P7PSP) ... they are squeeze cockers and are the safest and fastest semiauto's on the market but are very expensive and very hard to find these days. I would be comfy carrying one in my pocket with one in the chamber and zero holster. It just will not fire until you squeeze the grip to cock it. I love it except for the weight, except for it being 9 mm and having an 8 round capacity. Pity nobody else has come out with the same concept in polymer/stainless and double stack to at least ten rounds. This thing is all inline too by the way and it is 8 shots in a 25 cent piece sized hole at 25 feet. With your eyes closed (just kidding about the eyes).

Above all - remember that it is a nasty, mean, ignorant, sick in the head, beastly world out there and when the chips are down it is you and only you that will need to protect both yourself and your loved ones. Be prepared to do so and get yourself trained and well practiced so that it is reflexive. And choose your weapon wisely. Your life WILL one day depend on it; of that I can absolutely assure you. We have been held up, accosted, two home invasion attempts (one succesful but non violent), etc. I guess you don't want to be around me... its dangerous.
 
iT DEPENDS ON THE GUN

I carry Israeli draw, SOB. I have practiced presenting and firing at my berm a lot.I do not care if I am carrying a load of groceries. I can buy more. It takes me no more time to present this way than to draw and fire from a loaded chamber.

This is my personal choice. It is what I am comfortable with and how I trained since 2006.

I am happy with it.
 
I carry Israeli draw, SOB. I have practiced presenting and firing at my berm a lot.I do not care if I am carrying a load of groceries. I can buy more. It takes me no more time to present this way than to draw and fire from a loaded chamber.

This is my personal choice. It is what I am comfortable with and how I trained since 2006.

I am happy with it.
WWJD?
I think he would carry with one in the chamber.

Here is a look at the Israeli draw.

From Wikipedia:

The "Israeli Method" is a point shooting system devised by the Israel Defense Force (IDF) for use in training personnel to use rifles, submachineguns, and handguns.

In its initial stages of training, it closely resembles the Fairbairn, Sykes, and Applegate (FSA) method described above. In later stages, training in the rapid acquisition of the sights is taught, as well as a more advanced method of pointshooting.

In the United States and Canada, the term "Israeli Method" is generally believed to refer to the carrying of a semiautomatic pistol with its chamber empty. However, the carrying of the chamber empty served a safety consideration, rather than a tactical consideration. In past decades, due to severe budget constraints, IDF purchased and issued large quantities of antiquated sidearms, the mechanical safety of which was questionable. In recent decades, as budget concerns are increasingly alleviated and more modern, standardized sidearms are issued, this mode of carry is increasingly being phased out. It should also be noted that specialized personnel, such as police and special forces units, have typically carried newer and safer firearms, and have rarely used this mode of carry.
 
I think that if you need to draw your weapon, it should be ready to fire. It cound take too much time to draw, rack, and shoot.

Definetely one in the chamber.
 
Wwjd???

WWJD?
I think he would carry with one in the chamber.

Here is a look at the Israeli draw.

From Wikipedia:

The "Israeli Method" is a point shooting system devised by the Israel Defense Force (IDF) for use in training personnel to use rifles, submachineguns, and handguns.

In its initial stages of training, it closely resembles the Fairbairn, Sykes, and Applegate (FSA) method described above. In later stages, training in the rapid acquisition of the sights is taught, as well as a more advanced method of pointshooting.

In the United States and Canada, the term "Israeli Method" is generally believed to refer to the carrying of a semiautomatic pistol with its chamber empty. However, the carrying of the chamber empty served a safety consideration, rather than a tactical consideration. In past decades, due to severe budget constraints, IDF purchased and issued large quantities of antiquated sidearms, the mechanical safety of which was questionable. In recent decades, as budget concerns are increasingly alleviated and more modern, standardized sidearms are issued, this mode of carry is increasingly being phased out. It should also be noted that specialized personnel, such as police and special forces units, have typically carried newer and safer firearms, and have rarely used this mode of carry.

What does Jesus have to do with this?
When i was Active duty AF we were trained to carry a M-9 with one in the chamber set to fire, hammer down.

I personally like Israeli draw...and...I still don't under stand what Jesus has to do with it?
 
What does Jesus have to do with this?
When i was Active duty AF we were trained to carry a M-9 with one in the chamber set to fire, hammer down.

I personally like Israeli draw...and...I still don't under stand what Jesus has to do with it?

I think he is referring to Jesus as a Rabbi (ie Jewish), as the Israeli's are Jewish.
 
Above all - remember that it is a nasty, mean, ignorant, sick in the head, beastly world out there and when the chips are down it is you and only you that will need to protect both yourself and your loved ones. Be prepared to do so and get yourself trained and well practiced so that it is reflexive. And choose your weapon wisely. Your life WILL one day depend on it; of that I can absolutely assure you. We have been held up, accosted, two home invasion attempts (one succesful but non violent), etc. I guess you don't want to be around me... its dangerous.

Great post man, great post. Especially the last paragraph. I love the attitude.
 
I carry Israeli draw, SOB. I have practiced presenting and firing at my berm a lot.I do not care if I am carrying a load of groceries. I can buy more. It takes me no more time to present this way than to draw and fire from a loaded chamber.

This is my personal choice. It is what I am comfortable with and how I trained since 2006.

I am happy with it.

And so was I until I was accosted by a fellow with a huge honkin revolver while I was seat belted in my van with my family; to have discretely drawn and placed a round might have been possible. However, to have drawn, racked the slide (and if needed flipped the safety) and THEN taken a discrete shot would have been absolutely impossible. On top of that, even the fraction of a second to rack the slide would have decimated the "action beats reaction" theory to death and this whacko would have likely had time to take a bead on my head and let one rip.

So, again, I say that not all situations are going to be criticaly in need of having a round chambered and hot... but I know that in my case that it would have been absolutely essential, life or death. As it turned out, all I needed to do was floor it while he was ranting and waving his gun around and pray that he did not follow us in a hail of lead... which he did NOT do (thank the Lord).

In the end, my PERSONAL decision is that I will choose a firearm that has sufficient safety to permit me to carry it with one chambered and hot (i.e. cocked). The tradeoff in potential ND/AD's is so small that my decision was easy.

I love my Glocks although they are the mose UNSAFE to carry in this way (I have installed heavier triggers in my carry Glocks); and I love other of my guns that are far, far safer to carry 'hot', such as my Springfield XD's, my HK P7M8 and P7PSP and so on. And, of course, revolvers with the hammer down on an empty chamber is always safe as heck - it takes a huge trigger squeeze to get a round away generally. So there are choices to be made and in the end you want to be comfy with what you do but I again reiterate that there will be situations where carrying one in the chamber and hot will make the difference between life and death.

There is no second place winner in a gunfight - be prepared to come out on top whatever it takes and if that means that you need to save up the pennies and buy something a bit safer then you need to really consider that.

The "Israeli" method is not intended to fend off bad guys intent on robbing you, by the way and therefore, the fraction of a second it will take to rack one and fire makes little difference. When you are strapped into your car with a guy at your window with a gun pointed at your head or with a baseball bat asking you politely to step out of your car or better yet to move over so he can get it... you need a gun with a chambered round and hot. THAT will be the difference between a good outcome and otherwise.

A few words of wisdom from one who has been there in both situations (where carrying hot would have made a big difference and where carrying hot made no difference at all). Take it and make YOUR decision. It took me, by the way, something like two years before I came to my conclusion and was comfy carrying chambered and hot. And I have never looked back nor have I ever felt at risk for carrying that way.

Take a Springfield XD and try to get it to 'fire' (empty - dry fire) any way you can excepting pulling on the trigger. And then stuff a bunch of your shirt around the trigger and play with it WITHOUT SQUEEZING on the grip safety. Drop the gun, bang in off a concrete wall, stick it in a paper bag and shake it around for an hour. I can guarantee you that it will not go 'bang' until you squeeze that grip and pull that trigger at the same time. Ditto the HK P7 series.... so safe, in fact, that I have no hesitation tossing one in my pocket sans holster even if I am running down to the corner store or whatever. It simply will NOT happen!

In the end, each to his or her own I suppose; I can only relate my personal journey to carrying hot and chambered and my personal experiences of lethal force incidents. It is YOU that needs to come to the conclusions that I did in order to be comfy. And I think after doing the same research that I did and perhaps thinking about being in the same positions that I was in, you will come to the same conclusion. If I am carrying in the woods to protect myself from predator animals asides from humans, perhaps... but in the big city? Chambered and hot all the time and with the right gun all the time. It is safe and comfy as heck.
 
wow, i have never been happier in my life to not live in the gaza strip or anywhere like it, such as toronto apparently. i do have to say, however, that if you're worried about a double action, striker fired weapon being too dangerous to carry condition 1 then maybe a cudgel is the way to go (i carry a s&w sigma, safe fire double action). a gun is DANGEROUS. period. what makes it safe enough to be at all useful is the possessor i suppose. i carry cond. 1 all the time be it pistol or revolver and never had a mishap (to put it lightly enough). and maybe it isn't the best thing to do but i carry my beretta 92 cond. 1 cocked and unlocked (being a double/single action). my ideologies may change when i add a 1911 to my collection, however :biggrin: but honestly, is that not an "i kill you" gun and not an "i protect me" gun? semantics, i suppose
 
Chamber load on XD9mm subcompact and ready to go. What the use of carrying if not ready?

With all due respect I think that is just what I finished saying. The XD series has a grip safety. One more link in a line of safety devices that makes carrying the gun rapid to first round fired while being safe if your finger happens to remain on the trigger while reholstering or if a piece of shirt gets caught while carrying.

I truly wish that gun owners would learn the intricacies of their firearms before babbling off.

The Glocks, of which I am intimately familiar and have several, are NOT a single action semi with ANY sort of reasonable safety. The fact that they are considered double action is a pure fluke and they are 90% cocked and unlocked with nary a thumb nor grip safey of any kind preventing a ND. In terms of comparing them to a revolver, that is not really valid as a revolver needs to have its cylinder turn to the next 'lineup' in order to be able to fire (assuming they are double action). A revolver stuck in a proper fitting leather holster would make this feat impossible or at least next to impossible.

Please, guys, learn about your firearms before running around with them. They are not toys.

The "Israeli draw" is BS as far as I am concerned. I have several friends who have served in the Israeli military or have carried guns in Israel. It is simply a means of safe carry and nothing more.

The object of the game is, when tactile senses are reduced and your fingers and hands feel like mudpies, to be able to get that first round off rapidly and accurately; hence the reason for carrying a Glock with one in the chamber and living with it, or carrying a 1911 with safety on and a grip safety with one in the chamber and hot. It is fast to first accurate round placement- the difference between life and death.

There are times when I really do think that a much higher standard of training and testing and background checking is needed for those wishing to purchase handguns or ANY guns for that matter regardless of the second amendment.

No imbeciles and no whackos and no felons. That pretty much sums it up. If you fit into one of these groups please pack up your firearms and take them down to the nearest police station for disposal.

Or you can get out and get some training so that you understand the difference between firearms and why the Glock, while being a superb firearm (I carry a G30 at the moment) are NOT double action AND have no safeties asides from the meagre passive safeties incorporated by law.

Jeez.
 
I carry Israeli draw, SOB. I have practiced presenting and firing at my berm a lot.I do not care if I am carrying a load of groceries. I can buy more. It takes me no more time to present this way than to draw and fire from a loaded chamber.

This is my personal choice. It is what I am comfortable with and how I trained since 2006.

I am happy with it.

That is absolutely false. Carrying a 1911 or striker fired gun with a grip safety with one in the tube is INFINITELY faster than racking and firing a Glock that is not hot. There is simply no debate possible as it is physically impossible to rack a round under stress, bring the firearm back under control and to point of aim in the same time it takes to simply raise a 1911 series, flick off the thumb safety and fire. Period. End of story.

Anyone that is going to tell you otherwise, video or not, is simpy full of BS.
 

New Threads

Members online

No members online now.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
49,533
Messages
610,704
Members
75,032
Latest member
BLACKROCK6
Back
Top