One in the chamber.... or not

I carry with one in the chamber. Also my pistol has no saftey. I believe that the second or two it would take to chamber a round is life or death. Every second counts in any stressful situation. If you need your weapon, you need your weapon RIGHT NOW. You may not have time to chamber a round before the bad guy gets to you, or gets a shot off. My advice, carry chambered, but be careful, aware and responcible. That extra few seconds may save your life.
 
Yikes! You guys are scaring me again.

No need to be scared. No one here poses a threat to you.

You are proving nothing to me, except that maybe you don't have an open mind and are over confident. If you are over confident, you scare me more than the criminals.

Actually, you have it backwards. :no:

No one advocating the carry of a pistol with a chambered round is over-confident.

A violent encounter can be complete in less than two seconds with the victim seriously injured (or worse) and unable to defend him- or herself. We know that our human limitations prevent us from responding instantaneously to a threat and that we cannot possibly anticipate every threat. Therefore, we remove those factors that would delay our response time anymore than it already is. There is no need to "prove" it. A reduction of the delay that we call "reaction time" is the best route to a rapid response on the already shaky ground of self-preservation. The best prepared and fastest competitor wins. Darwin and the Boy Scouts of America know it (Be prepared) and I don't believe that you are so vapid as to not "get it."

I do agree that this crowd is totally against me and many may have more experience than me, but that's not a reason for me to change my mind. I even stated that my instructors carry a round in the chamber. Just because they have more experience than me doesn't mean I should blindly follow their choice.

Gotta learn from someone- might as well be those with more experience than you. If your intention is pure intransigence for the sake of engaging in pure intransigence, then nothing, not even valid data (proof) will serve to convince you. We've led you to the water; drink if you want.

I'm not here to prove anything to you, except the fact that I'm willing to listen and change my mind IF you can give me an overwhelming reason to. I'm also proving to you I won't just sit back and take your posts as closed and not debatable. So far you've convinced me of little.

I think everyone can see that. You state that you are not here to prove anything, yet your continued insistence suggests otherwise.

You've been given the most overwhelming reason there is- your self-preservation. If that is not enough, nothing is.

Please bear with me, I know you're going to roll your eyes, but it really makes sense in the situation we're in. Your older and more experienced friend is going to jump off a cliff and says you should too. Should you? (I know, it's ridiculous, but please keep reading.) You have an open mind and want to know why he thinks it's a good idea. He tells you he's been offered 1 million dollars if he jumps. You think, hmmmm, there may be a point here. However, you're still not convinced, because if you do and you die, you won't get the 1 million dollars. So you tell him you think it's a bad idea, but he continually tries to convince you otherwise. So, you say, if he can give you a perfect reason why you should, then you'll change your mind and jump. That's exactly what's going on in this thread.

Your analogy is flawed since it reasons from an underlying conclusion that is implicitly taken as being valid. Carrying a pistol with a chambered round presents no risk of harm to you (unlike jumping off of a cliff) unless you are un(der)trained in the pistol's operation. If that is the case, then you shouldn't be carrying it in the first place.

That condition can be corrected through quality training.

It's "all you" from here on out, big guy. :smile: I've given you all that I have to offer and if you won't accept delivery, there's nothing I, or anyone else, can do.

Out.
 
It's time for me to say this. I didn't before because I can guess what your reaction to it will be, but here goes: I have seen video and heard about many, many, many accidental discharges of guns. (Negligent discharges, whatever it is). And, quite a few of them were by people that had training, IE cops. (I heard your feelings about cops, just using them as an example I can think of where they did receive training.) Now, listen very carefully to this next part. I bet you every single one of them heard the same things I did and thought, "that will never happen to me, it can't." I've thought the exact same thing. However, I'm smart enough and open minded enough to realize that if it can happen to them, it probably can happen to me. So, if it's imposssible for this to happen, why does it? And if it's impossible for it to happen to someone like you, why does it? So, my point is, why take the risk? I'm erring on the side of safety. Why am I still in this discussion? Still defending my opinion and hoping at least some of you will take away something I'm saying. I've already had a few people say I've had some good points. I also think a few are at least agreeing with me that they should have an open mind. Should you all come with me on the dark side? No, you shouldn't, because you should take away what you want from this and so should I. You also should think for yourself, which is what I do and will continue to do until someone convinces me otherwise.
 
One more thing: why does this post even exist if there wasn't an argument or a debate to be made? If all of you are absolutely correct, the question would never have been asked. Therefore, even though I seem to be the only one here that chooses not to chamber a round, there must be others out there and I doubt they're all wrong.
 
It's time for me to say this. I didn't before because I can guess what your reaction to it will be, but here goes: I have seen video and heard about many, many, many accidental discharges of guns. (Negligent discharges, whatever it is). And, quite a few of them were by people that had training, IE cops. (I heard your feelings about cops, just using them as an example I can think of where they did receive training.) Now, listen very carefully to this next part. I bet you every single one of them heard the same things I did and thought, "that will never happen to me, it can't." I've thought the exact same thing. However, I'm smart enough and open minded enough to realize that if it can happen to them, it probably can happen to me. So, if it's imposssible for this to happen, why does it? And if it's impossible for it to happen to someone like you, why does it? So, my point is, why take the risk? I'm erring on the side of safety. Why am I still in this discussion? Still defending my opinion and hoping at least some of you will take away something I'm saying. I've already had a few people say I've had some good points. I also think a few are at least agreeing with me that they should have an open mind. Should you all come with me on the dark side? No, you shouldn't, because you should take away what you want from this and so should I. You also should think for yourself, which is what I do and will continue to do until someone convinces me otherwise.

No offense, but your "lack" of knowledge of the subject really is showing. What you fail to understand is we ALL know NDs happen. But, I would almost guarantee that the video & incidents you're referencing is TOTALLY irrelevant to this particular topic.

In negligent discharges improper trigger discipline or Mexican carry are usually the primary culprits and usually has NOTHING to do with carrying plus1. If you know of ANY videos or news stories that point to plus1 carry causing a ND please let us know; by posting the links. It's improper & unsafe gun handling practices that lead to an ND; not a firearm setting plus1 in your holster.

-
 
So, my point is, why take the risk?
Indeed.

So why are you even carrying a gun AT ALL when you could ELIMINATE the risk by going unarmed, and indeed by not OWNING a firearm?

My cousin in Chicago is NEVER going to have a negligent discharge... because she's against OWNING a firearm and is NEVER going to HAVE anything to have a negligent discharge WITH.

By your OWN standards you are wildly irresponsible.
 
Hate to burst your bubble croute but cops are one of the most inept groups when it comes to firearms safety. I've seen or heard of them shooting off their duty weapons at the range, in cars, in the squad room, at the gym in the locker room, shall I go on?
And hey, if you want to carry unchambered, fine, go for it. But beating this unchambered dead horse is a waste of time on this forum.
 
And hey, if you want to carry unchambered, fine, go for it. But beating this unchambered dead horse is a waste of time on this forum.

I'll say.

Is anyone else here beginning to get the impression that croute is an anti-gunner posing as a someone wrestling with this issue in the hope that we'll all be disuaded from CCW-ing and OC-ing by this persistent discourse?
 
I'll say.

Is anyone else here beginning to get the impression that croute is an anti-gunner posing as a someone wrestling with this issue in the hope that we'll all be disuaded from CCW-ing and OC-ing by this persistent discourse?
It was more of a CONCLUSION than an "impression" and something like ten pages ago.

The AHSA fifth columnists have been out in force on firearms discussion boards since the first of the recent mass shootings.

Notice how he didn't respond to my comment about "reasonable gun controls"?
 
One more thing: why does this post even exist if there wasn't an argument or a debate to be made? If all of you are absolutely correct, the question would never have been asked. Therefore, even though I seem to be the only one here that chooses not to chamber a round, there must be others out there and I doubt they're all wrong.
There are a LOT more who would legally outlaw CARRY of ANY kind than would carry with an empty chamber. Do you think THEY'RE "all wrong"?

And by the way, what's your opinion on a renewed "assault weapon" ban?
 
It was more of a CONCLUSION than an "impression" and something like ten pages ago.

The AHSA fifth columnists have been out in force on firearms discussion boards since the first of the recent mass shootings.

Notice how he didn't respond to my comment about "reasonable gun controls"?

Deanimator,

Yeah, I must've missed that. Came late to the party and only skimmed through the first 30 pages. That's what I get for hurrying.

After I realized that every one of croute's responses could be used as an exemplar for non sequitur, it hit me. Liberals, incapable of even simple reason, can only emote when faced with facts that contradict their position.

Now I know and will no longer post on this thread.

No more food for the troll.
 
One more thing: why does this post even exist if there wasn't an argument or a debate to be made? If all of you are absolutely correct, the question would never have been asked. Therefore, even though I seem to be the only one here that chooses not to chamber a round, there must be others out there and I doubt they're all wrong.
This thread exists because there are others who, unlike you, are open to "new" ideas. Deanimater compared your rhetoric to that of Bloomberg and the like... Let's see, you attempt to create fear with your accidental discharge mantra, then, when someone who has followed your line of reasoning is unable to defend themselves, you can say, "See! Carrying a gun doesn't do any good!"
 
Deanimator: good point. I did make a mistake with that post. What I meant to say is, “is everything they say wrong?” Not that all of them are wrong for believing one shouldn’t be chambered. Again, I don’t think you guys are all wrong either. Also, I have to admit I agree with you on the whole ban thing, but again, is everything they’re saying wrong? I am against a ban on guns, however I don’t think everything they say is wrong. I agree that they have some good points, but they also haven’t convinced me that they’re right. Once again, to all of you telling me to leave my gun at home, let it go, it really is a lame argument. I say again, leaving my gun at home where I have no possibility of using it and having it with me where I still can use it are two completely-different things. Being the safest possible while carrying, and to have my gun as ready as possible to where I think it's reasonable, and still useful, is my goal. Before you say it, that doesn't mean leaving the clip out of it either.
 
I am against a ban on guns, however I don’t think everything they say is wrong.
REALLY???

What is it that they say that's "right"?

Once again, to all of you telling me to leave my gun at home, let it go, it really is a lame argument.
The "argument" for not carrying (or indeed OWNING) is the SAME as YOUR "argument" for not carrying with a loaded chamber. There is simply NO rational basis for arbitrarily stopping at unchambered carry. If the danger from carrying a loaded firearm is THAT great, why shouldn't it be ELIMINATED instead of marginally lessened (in fact INCREASED by unnecessary handling of a firearm to load it during a dire emergency). You could have an ND WHILE or AFTER chambering a round, and people have. You could make that IMPOSSIBLE by not POSSESSING a firearm, and that is EXACTLY the "argument" made by Bloomberg, Schumer, Sugermann and Brady.

If the argument for not carrying is "lame", then YOUR argument for not carrying with a loaded chamber is even MORE SO, given that NOT carrying ELIMINATES the danger of an ND, while carrying with an unloaded chamber actually INCREASES it. Conceptually, they are utterly indistinguishable.
 
Hate to burst your bubble croute but cops are one of the most inept groups when it comes to firearms safety. I've seen or heard of them shooting off their duty weapons at the range, in cars, in the squad room, at the gym in the locker room, shall I go on?
And hey, if you want to carry unchambered, fine, go for it. But beating this unchambered dead horse is a waste of time on this forum.

Not to mention, I just heard that NINE of the victims at the Empire State building were actually shot by the police and NOT the shooter!

http://www.foxnews.com/us/2012/08/25/nypd-shooting-bystander-victims-hit-by-police-gunfire/

-
 
I have a Glock 33 and a full magazine in it. Usually not racked unless travelling at night or in unfamiliar territory. Wife has her Ruger LCR .357 magnum in her purse and fully loaded all the time.
 
Well, it looks like I hit the nail on the head with this one (as did a few others). This has turned into one hell of a troll. And, people keep responding to him.

SMMFH

iKonixx
 
We're getting off track again guys. I've been answering your questions because I think there is some good conversation, but we're so off base now that I'm not going to continue down that road. The forum is about whether to have a bullet chambered or not. Unless you have any questions, comments or concerns about that, I won't answer anymore. I'm sure that will please all those who still think I'm a troll.
 
We're getting off track again guys.
Actually, we're firmly on the tracks, making 60 knots, hot, straight and true like a Long Lance torpedo.

Your statement that gun banners have things "right", and your sudden refusal to expand on that tells us more than enough about you and what your TRUE motivations are.

A "troll"? That's FAR too innocent of an explanation.
 

New Threads

Members online

No members online now.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
49,533
Messages
610,704
Members
75,032
Latest member
BLACKROCK6
Back
Top