One in the chamber.... or not

Great posts guys. No offense taken. I also agree that each person should do what they think is right. I guess that was my point throughout this entire post. I don't know a darn thing about you or your situation. I'm certainly not going to try and push my opinion on you. However, I'll defend mine, as you've certainly seen in here :)
 
OK guys, once again you're reading way too much into my some of my posts and not reading enough from the others. I never said I was an expert on anything nor did I ever hint that I'm infallable. I also won't try to persuade you not to have a round chambered. I'm not going there so give it up. I believe I have clearly stated why I don't have a round chambered. Now, if I have a choice between drawing my gun or using my other skills in a situation that only gives me 2 seconds to react, I will choose not to draw my gun every time. I'm finally going to use the word "wrong." If you think that you should draw your gun in ANY situation EVERY time, I'm going to call you wrong. However, that's not the topic of this post and that's why I haven't said it until now.
Croute. There is no choice. There is no time to think. There is no decision. The reaction to a deadly threat is instinctive. The attacks others are speaking of are extremely violent, come without warning and are over in tenths of a second. Responding comes with training and working drills until you're sick of them. It requires practice in properly drawing a gun a thousand times. I taught Krav Maga for a long time. The only time that helps me is if I completely missed the attack coming and he got to me. And even then I'm probably getting cut, stabbed or killed. If it was a gun I've lost.

As I said. This is a dead horse. There is no question as to the best method for effective defense. Lot's of the regular posters are instructors, police, military officers and are well trained and some highly paid to teach this stuff. As an experienced instructor I learn something from them every day on these forums. Some have been cut, beat, shot at, etc. They know from experience and training. If you're not comfortable by no means carry it chambered. Just remember that the man who loses is usually the one caught behind the reactionary curve. But to think you can ever know or anticipate how an attack will unfold and what your reaction will be shows a need to get trained., or take amidnight ghetto walk.. for your own good, not ours.

There's an old saying. "When you find yourself in a hole, stop digging." Learn. Never stop learning.
 
Good stuff, BC1!

I don't know why folks think that they'll have the time to do something like chamber a round prior to an attack. It's not like a UFC match where the ref steps out and asks each participant, "Are you ready?" and then tells 'em, "Fight!"

An attacker who knows what he is doing and is serious about doing it will not telegraph his intentions. Hell, he may even smile at you as he approaches to draw you further off-guard and then he'll move very quickly to disable you (hurt you as badly as he can as rapidly as he can) in order to minimize his risk of injury. In such circumstances, a pistol without a round in the chamber carries two liabilities- 1.) you have to waste time bringing the gun to a condition of readiness, and 2.) you may not have a second hand available to do so.

Forgive me for being so direct as I mean no offense to anyone here, but... If you won't chamber it, don't bother carrying it.
 
I think the majority of people new to CC carry it unchambered, but then they learn that's stupid.

I know, because I did.

Then, I realized it was foolish not to have a firearm ready to go.

I carry a G26, 13 in the magazine, one in the chamber. If, God forbid, I ever have to use it, I have simply to draw it and pull the trigger.

I never, ever, unholster it under any condition, except for that of emergency.

If you don't think you can resist the urge to impress your buds by showing them your gun, then, just empty it and walk around with nothing in it.
 
An attacker who knows what he is doing and is serious about doing it will not telegraph his intentions. Hell, he may even smile at you as he approaches to draw you further off-guard and then he'll move very quickly to disable you (hurt you as badly as he can as rapidly as he can) in order to minimize his risk of injury.
Exactly.

I have a video from a casino camera in Atlantic City showing how this happens. Two girls hit a good payout on a slot. They left the casino and were walking down from the boardwalk (beach head) to the street on the side of the casino. Well lit, well traveled. Two guys, yuppie looking in sport coats, are walking toward them laughing and talking. They don't seem to even notice the two girls walking toward them. As the two couples pass, the guys turn and deliver a horrific blow to the head of each girl. Down and out. Not moving. They take the purses and run back toward the parking area and out of sight of the cameras. No warning. extremely close, they don't look like perps, don't tip their hand, surprise attack, extremely violent. The girls were giggling away over their small win. Professional take-down in every sense. Unless those girls were practicing near perfect situational awareness and purposefully moved away not to walk directly past the guys they stood no chance. Further investigation identified the two thugs in the casino. They saw the girls win a small slot jackpot. They Observed their potential victims, Oriented to the situation and surroundings, Decided to make the move and Attacked (OODA). Chamber a round first? Never gonna happen.

I have another video I like to show in PP classes. Mall parking lot security camera shows a guy walking to his car with a small bag. Lot's of cars parked around him. Well lit. people in the background going about business. As he reaches for his car door one perp pops up from behind his car and nails him on a dead run with an elbow to the side of the head. Distance of perp was less than 10 feet. Guy falls against the car. Second perp comes from nowhere and beats him to the ground. I don't think he was conscious after the first running hit. He's down and not moving. They took his watch, chain, bag and wallet. A small car zips in and the perps jump in. Blurry video. No license ID. Perps never caught.

There ends the lesson on chambering. These attacks were so violent and so fast that the only chance of a defense would have been astute/intense situational awareness, a proper drawstroke and a chambered round. And by a proper drawstroke I don't mean fast hands. I mean someone who has practiced the steps of access, grip, pull, rotate, rock and fire at at range of 1-2 feet hundreds if not thousands of times. Some of my fastest shooters are guys in their fifties and sixties. Years of doing it.


Remember, some of these rodents will kill you for little more than a thought passing through their head. Others are so tweeked out they don't know planet they're on. But they share a common trait... they're professional. They've done this many times, they're good at it, they don't feel fear, sympathy or empathy. They can't be reasoned with. They're sociopathic in nature. There's always been only one way to deal with such an element. This is why I teach students if they're gonna carry a gun, then carry it. Properly. Loaded. Chambered. And practice, practice, practice.
 
Exactly.

I have a video from a casino camera in Atlantic City showing how this happens. Two girls hit a good payout on a slot. They left the casino and were walking down from the boardwalk (beach head) to the street on the side of the casino. Well lit, well traveled. Two guys, yuppie looking in sport coats, are walking toward them laughing and talking. They don't seem to even notice the two girls walking toward them. As the two couples pass, the guys turn and deliver a horrific blow to the head of each girl. Down and out. Not moving. They take the purses and run back toward the parking area and out of sight of the cameras. No warning. extremely close, they don't look like perps, don't tip their hand, surprise attack, extremely violent. The girls were giggling away over their small win. Professional take-down in every sense. Unless those girls were practicing near perfect situational awareness and purposefully moved away not to walk directly past the guys they stood no chance. Further investigation identified the two thugs in the casino. They saw the girls win a small slot jackpot. They Observed their potential victims, Oriented to the situation and surroundings, Decided to make the move and Attacked (OODA). Chamber a round first? Never gonna happen.

I have another video I like to show in PP classes. Mall parking lot security camera shows a guy walking to his car with a small bag. Lot's of cars parked around him. Well lit. people in the background going about business. As he reaches for his car door one perp pops up from behind his car and nails him on a dead run with an elbow to the side of the head. Distance of perp was less than 10 feet. Guy falls against the car. Second perp comes from nowhere and beats him to the ground. I don't think he was conscious after the first running hit. He's down and not moving. They took his watch, chain, bag and wallet. A small car zips in and the perps jump in. Blurry video. No license ID. Perps never caught.

There ends the lesson on chambering. These attacks were so violent and so fast that the only chance of a defense would have been astute/intense situational awareness, a proper drawstroke and a chambered round. And by a proper drawstroke I don't mean fast hands. I mean someone who has practiced the steps of access, grip, pull, rotate, rock and fire at at range of 1-2 feet hundreds if not thousands of times. Some of my fastest shooters are guys in their fifties and sixties. Years of doing it.


Remember, some of these rodents will kill you for little more than a thought passing through their head. Others are so tweeked out they don't know planet they're on. But they share a common trait... they're professional. They've done this many times, they're good at it, they don't feel fear, sympathy or empathy. They can't be reasoned with. They're sociopathic in nature. There's always been only one way to deal with such an element. This is why I teach students if they're gonna carry a gun, then carry it. Properly. Loaded. Chambered. And practice, practice, practice.
BC1,

Wow.

Reading the descriptions of those two videos sent a chill down my spine.

It can all be over so amazingly fast, yet there are those who'd just as soon walk around with the figurative equivalent of having one arm tied behind their back (an empty chamber).

The "real world" is an unforgiving place.
 
TWright, how did you post your avatar. I can't seem to find the correct page, button, or what/whereever it is. tnx in advance, Mikey in WNC
 
OK guys, once again you're reading way too much into my some of my posts and not reading enough from the others. I never said I was an expert on anything nor did I ever hint that I'm infallable. I also won't try to persuade you not to have a round chambered. I'm not going there so give it up. I believe I have clearly stated why I don't have a round chambered. Now, if I have a choice between drawing my gun or using my other skills in a situation that only gives me 2 seconds to react, I will choose not to draw my gun every time. I'm finally going to use the word "wrong." If you think that you should draw your gun in ANY situation EVERY time, I'm going to call you wrong. However, that's not the topic of this post and that's why I haven't said it until now.

So when would you imagine yourself drawing? I wonder how much ground you estimate someone can cover in 2 seconds? You won't draw unless the bad guy is more than (how many?) feet away?

Also, I have doubts that someone could rack a slide in 1 second under duress. If you practice A LOT, maybe.
1 handed? If no table is handy (out on the street, maybe? ) probably not at all before a bg could get to you. Racking using a belt or pocket would be too slow in my opinion.


Sent from my Xoom using Tapatalk 2
 
Ah, NavyLCDR, although I'm really tired of people telling me to leave my gun at home, that is a very good question and I'll answer it. First of all, I'm going to say it again, not having a bullet in the chamber and leaving my gun at home are two totally-different things. If I leave my gun at home, there's no possibility of using it. I can still use it if I have it with me. So stop telling me to leave it at home. Now onto the answer: I took karate when I was young to stop being bullied. I'm now 46 and realize I'm not as limber as I used to be, so I decided to get a gun as another way to protect myself. Now, before you take this as "I can't use karate anymore," that's not what I'm saying. Just that I might not be quite as good as I used to be. gunsandgardens: yes, that's the rule and it's a good one, but it doesn't mean the gun has to have a bullet chambered at all times.
The fact is NOT having one in the chamber ready to go significantly reduces both the time you have and the absurdness of having the first round go bang. Also just so you know you would never put a BULLET into the chamber of a semi auto this would be useless as bullets unless propelled by powder contained in the CARTRIDGE or thrown REALLY REALLY hard are completely ineffective in a defensive situation.
 
The cardinal rule is treat every gun as if it were loaded. Why not let it be then? Safety is the number one practice. Always one in the chamber. Just my opinion. Stay safe and happy shooting!

Lol rule #'s are different depending who you follow..but the "cardinal" rule should definitely be to “always keep your firearm loaded" :-)
 
I think the majority of people new to CC carry it unchambered, but then they learn that's stupid.

I know, because I did.

Then, I realized it was foolish not to have a firearm ready to go.

I carry a G26, 13 in the magazine, one in the chamber. If, God forbid, I ever have to use it, I have simply to draw it and pull the trigger.

I never, ever, unholster it under any condition, except for that of emergency.

If you don't think you can resist the urge to impress your buds by showing them your gun, then, just empty it and walk around with nothing in it.

I have to admit that's how it went for me. I didn't have confidence in my handling skills and the gun's safeties at first. Just takes time.
 
I see we're back to useless posts (note, I didn't say all of them) and the same thing we've covered a hundred times. Still no real substance to prove a point. To the question of how much time should I have to make a decision- I don't know. That's a good question and maybe we should start another thread to discuss that one. What I do know is I won't ever draw my gun if the situation immediately tells me I don't have time. Again, whether I have a round chambered or not. And I truly believe you shouldn't either. (Note, I didn't say you're wrong, just that I consider it unwise.) You may end up winning the fight, but you may not. I don't care who you are or how good. You guys seem to think you have the experience and I don't. Maybe you're right, but I've already stated that I could get all the real-life training available in the world and I still wouldn't change my stance on that one. If I get killed someday in a situation where I only had 2 seconds to react, and I'm able to look back on it, I'm pretty sure I would stand by my decision not to have drawn my gun. Because I could have been just as dead if I drew my gun. I'd rather err on the side of safety.
 
I see we're back to useless posts (note, I didn't say all of them) and the same thing we've covered a hundred times. Still no real substance to prove a point. To the question of how much time should I have to make a decision- I don't know. That's a good question and maybe we should start another thread to discuss that one. What I do know is I won't ever draw my gun if the situation immediately tells me I don't have time. Again, whether I have a round chambered or not. And I truly believe you shouldn't either. (Note, I didn't say you're wrong, just that I consider it unwise.) You may end up winning the fight, but you may not. I don't care who you are or how good. You guys seem to think you have the experience and I don't. Maybe you're right, but I've already stated that I could get all the real-life training available in the world and I still wouldn't change my stance on that one. If I get killed someday in a situation where I only had 2 seconds to react, and I'm able to look back on it, I'm pretty sure I would stand by my decision not to have drawn my gun. Because I could have been just as dead if I drew my gun. I'd rather err on the side of safety.

Son, you don't have two seconds to react. You don't get to make a decision. Another thread to discuss how much time you have to make a decision is pointless. I've shown you by examples and the Teuller drill shows you by practical application. The matter of time & reaction is closed. It's been closed for decades. It's finite and not debatable. There is no argument. This is beginning to sound like a very stubborn game of tag. I once had an "intro" computer science student who questioned every point of science and engineering I taught. He argued everything to the point of madness. He was very bright. He also failed my class. Perhaps a "touchy-feely" career in some subjective area would better suit him than engineering and physics. You made your point that it's not something you're comfortable with and that's OK. But to expound on a point that it is just as effective to those with the expertise that exists in this forum is much like that kid I failed. Only if you fail at this you won't be able to look back at your decision not to draw your gun. Forget the ones who insulted you but take the genuine advice you've been given as they're correct.

My suggestion to you is find another topic and let this go. I know this crowd after interacting with them for a long time. Look at the large number of highly experienced posters that have tried to reason with you. If this continues your future posts will generally be treated with lack of credibility and you'll start taking it on the nose for much of what you say. Sort of like wearing a "hit me" sign on your back.
 
Safety on, one in the pipe and full clip. You need to be ready using only one hand.
If you need to protect yourself, you may not have time or the ability to use
both hands.
 
Yikes! You guys are scaring me again. (No, that's not a compliment.) First of all, I didn't start anything, unless just by posting 1 initial opinion you think I did. I'm only defending my position after so many told me I was wrong. You are proving nothing to me, except that maybe you don't have an open mind and are over confident. If you are over confident, you scare me more than the criminals. I do agree that this crowd is totally against me and many may have more experience than me, but that's not a reason for me to change my mind. I even stated that my instructors carry a round in the chamber. Just because they have more experience than me doesn't mean I should blindly follow their choice. I'm not here to prove anything to you, except the fact that I'm willing to listen and change my mind IF you can give me an overwhelming reason to. I'm also proving to you I won't just sit back and take your posts as closed and not debatable. So far you've convinced me of little. I didn't bring up the "time" issue, someone else did and I stood by my decision, despite the fact that it will take me a second longer to rack my slide. If seconds are a factor, I would rather try and use both hands to defend myself than only one. And I certainly don't want to give my attacker a chance to take my gun and use it against me. So, are two hands better than one? I think so. Is giving the attacker a chance to get your gun worth the risk? I don't think so. If I only have one arm and the attacker has my gun and is shooting me with it, am I better off? I don't think so. Here's an analogy that I wish I'll never hear again and I wish I never had to use, but it fits the situation perfectly. Please bear with me, I know you're going to roll your eyes, but it really makes sense in the situation we're in. Your older and more experienced friend is going to jump off a cliff and says you should too. Should you? (I know, it's ridiculous, but please keep reading.) You have an open mind and want to know why he thinks it's a good idea. He tells you he's been offered 1 million dollars if he jumps. You think, hmmmm, there may be a point here. However, you're still not convinced, because if you do and you die, you won't get the 1 million dollars. So you tell him you think it's a bad idea, but he continually tries to convince you otherwise. So, you say, if he can give you a perfect reason why you should, then you'll change your mind and jump. That's exactly what's going on in this thread.
 
I think there is a reson why all cops carry with one in the pipe, can we now just let this go? There are so many arguments FOR it and so few and mostly very hypothetical what ifs against it there isn't much else to be said about it. We can not convince CROUTE of this, and I respect his opinion (even though I also think he is off target on it, pun intended ;-)) so let him do what he seems to need to.
 
Consider, a loaded revolver is always chambered. That's why my S&W BUG has a 13# trigger - so when it comes out of my pocket, with my finger on the trigger, it doesn't blow my Twinkies off. Grip activated Crimson Trace allows a shot from the hip. Usually if you have to go to the BUG, you're deep in it and need help fast.
Now my G30 is a different set of rules: 3# trigger and chambered - finger on the trigger close to or after I set the aim point (how much time? Count one thousand - one, BLAM!
In either case, if I draw my firearm, I intend to fire it, therefore, I consider an unchambered gun is useless.
 
Also, I have doubts that someone could rack a slide in 1 second under duress. If you practice A LOT, maybe.
1 handed? If no table is handy (out on the street, maybe? ) probably not at all before a bg could get to you. Racking using a belt or pocket would be too slow in my opinion.
MUCH more importantly, in YEARS of these debates, I have YET to see somebody who claimed, much demonstrated an ability to properly chamber a round one handed while somebody was trying to choke, beat or stab them to death.

What's the mantra of the empty chamber types? "Your gun might go off 'accidentally'!" Let's see, my gun's going to go of "accidentally" while its in the holster, BUT it's NOT going to go off when, during a chaotic physical struggle, I POINT IT AT MYSELF while trying to snag part of it on my belt or pocket in order to chamber a round. Some of these people have to be high on bath salts.

I have a solution. Just pull a Tupperware cart like the ones we use to deliver computers, behind you everywhere you go. At least you won't be pointing the gun at YOURSELF as you try to work the slide on the edge of the cart while somebody is frantically trying to KILL you.
 
I have to admit that's how it went for me. I didn't have confidence in my handling skills and the gun's safeties at first. Just takes time.
It's perfectly reasonable to TEST a single action gun the first time it's carried by having it cocked and locked on an empty chamber. I did that with my Norinco M1911 and Browning Hi Power. After a few hours of the safeties NOT being accidentally disengaged, I carry both with loaded chambers and never would any OTHER way.

There's a world of difference between prudence and paranoia fueled by ignorant rationalizations.
 
If I get killed someday in a situation where I only had 2 seconds to react, and I'm able to look back on it, I'm pretty sure I would stand by my decision not to have drawn my gun. Because I could have been just as dead if I drew my gun. I'd rather err on the side of safety.
You WON'T be able to look back. You won't be able to DO anything. You'll be DEAD.

Again, your "argument" is a FAR better justification for not carry AT ALL.

I may be eccentric, but GUARANTEEING that I'll be murdered in order to avoid an ND NEVER seems like a better solution than giving myself a CHANCE to live by accepting the infinitesimal POSSIBILITY of an ND. Again, your "argument" is uncannily similar to that of the anti-gunners who claim the CERTAINTY of being MURDERED execution style is BETTER than the POSSIBILITY of being WOUNDED by somebody shooting a mass murderer.

You parrot exactly the rhetoric of Bloomberg, Sugermann and Brady, yet seem perplexed at being called a troll. I'll bet you believe in "reasonable gun control" too...
 

New Threads

Members online

No members online now.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
49,533
Messages
610,704
Members
75,032
Latest member
BLACKROCK6
Back
Top