One in the chamber.... or not

To: maine04619- I don't know how many times I need to state my case on that one, but here it is again, just for you: I've already said that it will only take me about 1 second more than you to draw and rack at the same time. If I'm in a situation that 1 second makes a difference, I would not draw my gun, chambered or not. I also stated that if your life depends on just 1 second and you draw your gun, there's a very good chance that the bad guy can take it from you and use it against you.
Now we are getting somewhere. So your assertion is if the required 1 second ( or whatever amount of time ) was not available you would not bother. This tells me allot. You assertion that the bg would "take it from you" is a prime reason to HAVE IT READY!! also another great reason for TRAINING. It is fairly easy to teach someone to keep hold of there firearm. Having them absorb it and PRACTICE it is another matter. Time is your issue. So let us look at a few scenarios. You in a store the BG having just took the money from the registers is not heading towards you and your wife ( friend mother daughter son or whatever ) stopping and taking what he can from folks on the way you have lots of time to draw and get ready to take action before he gets to you. You have two major issues one when you put the firearm out to rack the slide it will be SEEN then it will be HEARD. Guess what you just became the primary target and those near you will be fodder. How about you come out of a business and are walking down the street a person come up behind you then out of nowhere they strike you in the head fight or flight kicks in and now your running full tilt do you really want to chance that your weapon will load correctly while your running? I can go on and on and on with these. These are not stuff I have made up but things that have happened IRL read them on the NRA site and others. This boils down to one thing either your going to be READY to defend yourself with a shot ready or your going to play a game of lets hope the weapon charges properly under stress and in whatever situation I am in. I can rattle the people on the line fairly easy and cause them to be unable to rack the slide correctly by yelling or the trusty spray bottle of water. People who swear they can function under the stress of attack can be defeated by water and yelling. I look forward to your response to this.
 
I just got my XD9SX back from service yesterday ... tried to rack the slide to safety check the chamber and my hand slid off because it was a bit oily ... just more food for thought.
 
Hey Guys,

Actually, I am the original poster. I have been watching, and listening, but have not posted until now. I notice a few things. It seems most carry with one in the chamber, those who do believe the risks (and yes, there are some risks) outweigh the risks of having to rack one at a time of need, those who don't believe the risks are less the other way (and people are surprisingly adamant about either way). I actually was looking for more arguments to use with my wife to carry with one in the chamber (lessen the nag factor). There was some good discussion, and some not so good discussion. I am surprised to see some of the attacks on this site, Hadn't seen much of that in the other posts I've read here. This is a site where we can all come to share our experiences good and bad (shot the truck...Da__ that's gotta hurt!). I thank all of you who constructively gave your opinion. What I get out of this is simple...

Carry how you feel comfortable. carrying with one in the chamber has rewards in some situations, and some risks in others... But with or without, we are all safer because we are carrying, and have a chance with the bad guys.

Thanks to all who posted!
Dennis
 
My daily carry weapon has been a 1911 .45 pistol for about 30 years or so. Currently, I carry a Kimber Raptor .45, and In that time I have always had one in the pipe, hammer back, safety on, and have never had an incident. Even with the best situational awareness training and constant vigilance, a deadly confrontation can appear in the blink of an eye. Even if you see a possible bad situation developing before you, showing your hand by having to pull your sidearm and charge it is not ideal, to say the least.
If you're not comfortable with the style of firearm you carry, maybe a revolver or double action pistol would be a better choice?
In a stress fire situation, It's best to eliminate any un needed or additional steps from holster to fire position. I'm left handed and carry in a Crossbreed. I practice the draw constantly, even now after all these years of carry. Right hand to chest while pulling my shirt and clearing leather, tight stance, eye on target, index trigger finger, double grip, thrust forward. I have done this over and over so many times I can do it in my sleep. I never want to have to think about the step between, knowing I need my pistol, and looking down the barrel of it. And racking a slide facing a possible unintended discharge or lost time is not one of those steps.
 
I notice a few things. It seems most carry with one in the chamber, those who do believe the risks (and yes, there are some risks) outweigh the risks of having to rack one at a time of need, those who don't believe the risks are less the other way (and people are surprisingly adamant about either way).
The percentage that carry without a loaded chamber is not significant enough to measure. What risks are there with carrying with a loaded chamber? I have done so just about every day for 25 plus years and never had a issue. The only RISK would be due to the USER not the firearm. On the other hand not carrying one in the chamber is much more likely to pose a very high risk to the person carrying the weapon. Given the choice and the risks involved any rational person would pick loaded and ready for use.
 
Hey Guys,

Actually, I am the original poster. I have been watching, and listening, but have not posted until now. I notice a few things. It seems most carry with one in the chamber, those who do believe the risks (and yes, there are some risks) outweigh the risks of having to rack one at a time of need, those who don't believe the risks are less the other way (and people are surprisingly adamant about either way). I actually was looking for more arguments to use with my wife to carry with one in the chamber (lessen the nag factor). There was some good discussion, and some not so good discussion. I am surprised to see some of the attacks on this site, Hadn't seen much of that in the other posts I've read here. This is a site where we can all come to share our experiences good and bad (shot the truck...Da__ that's gotta hurt!). I thank all of you who constructively gave your opinion. What I get out of this is simple...

Carry how you feel comfortable. carrying with one in the chamber has rewards in some situations, and some risks in others... But with or without, we are all safer because we are carrying, and have a chance with the bad guys.

Thanks to all who posted!
Dennis

The tricky part was installing a new pane of glass in the front window before my wife got home. The hole in the old 63 oxidized white chevy was easy, white caulk. My pride took a well deserved beat down. I humbled up real quick, and took that lesson to heart. I taught my son how to HANDLE safely, a firearm when he was 5 or 6, as soon as I knew his hands could grip the 1911. He is a pleasure to shoot with, and cautious to a fault. He has out shot me since he was 12, he's 22 now with a new wife to protect. I was lucky, nothing more. "DA" is being nice, thanks
 
Looks like I need to clear a couple things up again. I came here and posted my belief. I thought I was done after that. Then you guys barraged me with posts saying I was wrong. I then felt I needed to defend my position and find out why you were saying I was wrong. I never said you guys were wrong. So, I feel it's up to you to enlighten me. I'm not going to try to prove you wrong, because I don't necessarily think you are. Nor do I think I can change your mind. But you seem to think you can change mine. And, since I have an open mind, I'm willing to hear your case and change if you give me a good reason to. Let me try to explain those situations where you say you can draw your gun just in time and end the confrontation. First, if you can and it works, great, congratulations. However, if you draw your gun and it doesn't work out, I believe you made a mistake. maine04619: I’ve already stated that you can have your gun taken from you and I explained why. If the bad guy has your gun and it’s chambered, he can shoot you instantly. If he has my gun, it will just go “click.” Also, if someone already has a gun pointed at me, I wouldn’t draw my gun. If it’s a robbery, I’d just give him the money. Why risk getting shot? So, that's why I feel it's best to determine whether you should draw your gun or not. Honestly, in most cases I wouldn't. Why? Because I believe there are a lot of situations where drawing a gun isn't necessary to diffuse the problem and stay alive, nor is it wise. Rabbitcreekok: The main hangup we've had is situations where someone is taken by surprise and there's only 1 or 2 seconds to react. Again, I would not draw my gun in that situation. I would rather use both my arms to fend off the attack, and my karate skills. I may then get a chance to draw my gun at a later point, or maybe not. Can you draw faster than me? I've already said you can. Should you draw, I don't think so. Deanimator: I have never been in any threatening situation in real life. I’m thankful for that. I have had training to defend myself if one ever happens. All my instructors carry one in the chamber. Should I just because they do? No. Should I just because all of you do? No.
Another question was whether I can rack my slide with one hand. (Warning, listen before you leap). I have been trained to do that and, yes, it is very difficult and extremely time consuming. If I'm in a situation where one of my arms is disabled, I would be at a disadvantage. That's why I've stated earlier that you guys have had some good points. However, that one situation won't get me to put one in the chamber for all the rest of the situations where I don't think it's a good idea. Again, I’m more defensive than offensive. If I can get out of a situation without drawing my gun, I won’t draw. If I’m forced to draw my gun and I have enough time, I would draw my gun and shoot. I have no problems with shooting someone, but only if it’s necessary and wise. I think I’ve answered all the questions raised, even if I didn’t mention your name. If I missed one and you think I didn’t cover it in here, please let me know.
 
^^^You still haven't addressed why you think carrying with an empty chamber is better than plus 1.^^^

If you believe this, please share your reasons.

We already realize you're some sort of highly trained, great martial arts expert "Karate" man that will have all the time in the world to disarm any attacker and rack your slide.

But, not all of us have such high levels of expert training. What I want you to do is share with us "WHY" your way is better.

Please, educate the rest of us.

-
 
Deanimator: I have never been in any threatening situation in real life.
Your first is apt to be your last.

If I had to bet, I'd wager that your martial arts mindset is as unrealistic as that involving firearms. I had a college room mate very much like you. He had a black belt in Judo and thought himself quite the little Anton Geesink. He challenged a friend of mine to a martial arts match. My friend didn't have a belt in any martial art. What he did have was very practical training from a swim coach who'd been a Navy SEAL. He proceded to savagely batter the overconfident judoka with palm strikes to the face and kicks to the knees, then choked him out one handed. I wouldn't be at all surprised if you would be similarly flummoxed upon running into some predator who'd spent most of his life in and out of jail and prison. There you do what works or you don't do anything, including breathe.

By your own admission, your life's never been in danger from another person. Mine has, although when our assailant saw the loaded HK93 I was pointing at him, he took off going about 100mph. Carjacking's not nearly as much fun when you realize you can get shot to pieces trying it.

Unlike you, I try to learn from other people's experiences, at least to the extent that I don't repeat their mistakes.
 
Folks, I think this is what's called "a dead horse." You can beat it some more but it's already dead.
 
In MHO I think a gun shouldn't be "ready to fire." I use a semi-automatic and figure I'll have time to pull the slide. If I don't, I'm not sure it would really matter in the situation I'm in at that time. It's too easy to have your gun go off unexpectedly and just as easy to ready it.

Carry the firearm in the condition that you would be most comfortable and safe.

Guns don't go off unexpectedly, there is usually a finger involved. Usually in the wrong place (on the trigger).
 
OK guys, once again you're reading way too much into my some of my posts and not reading enough from the others. I never said I was an expert on anything nor did I ever hint that I'm infallable. I also won't try to persuade you not to have a round chambered. I'm not going there so give it up. I believe I have clearly stated why I don't have a round chambered. Now, if I have a choice between drawing my gun or using my other skills in a situation that only gives me 2 seconds to react, I will choose not to draw my gun every time. I'm finally going to use the word "wrong." If you think that you should draw your gun in ANY situation EVERY time, I'm going to call you wrong. However, that's not the topic of this post and that's why I haven't said it until now.
 
Croute,

Why take the chance of a bad guy getting your gun at all? If you feel your karate skills are good enough, leave the gun at home for target practice.
 
The cardinal rule is treat every gun as if it were loaded. Why not let it be then? Safety is the number one practice. Always one in the chamber. Just my opinion. Stay safe and happy shooting!
 
Ah, NavyLCDR, although I'm really tired of people telling me to leave my gun at home, that is a very good question and I'll answer it. First of all, I'm going to say it again, not having a bullet in the chamber and leaving my gun at home are two totally-different things. If I leave my gun at home, there's no possibility of using it. I can still use it if I have it with me. So stop telling me to leave it at home. Now onto the answer: I took karate when I was young to stop being bullied. I'm now 46 and realize I'm not as limber as I used to be, so I decided to get a gun as another way to protect myself. Now, before you take this as "I can't use karate anymore," that's not what I'm saying. Just that I might not be quite as good as I used to be. gunsandgardens: yes, that's the rule and it's a good one, but it doesn't mean the gun has to have a bullet chambered at all times.
 
Ah, NavyLCDR, although I'm really tired of people telling me to leave my gun at home, that is a very good question and I'll answer it. First of all, I'm going to say it again, not having a bullet in the chamber and leaving my gun at home are two totally-different things. If I leave my gun at home, there's no possibility of using it. I can still use it if I have it with me. So stop telling me to leave it at home. Now onto the answer: I took karate when I was young to stop being bullied. I'm now 46 and realize I'm not as limber as I used to be, so I decided to get a gun as another way to protect myself. Now, before you take this as "I can't use karate anymore," that's not what I'm saying. Just that I might not be quite as good as I used to be. gunsandgardens: yes, that's the rule and it's a good one, but it doesn't mean the gun has to have a bullet chambered at all times.

I for one would 'never' tell a law abiding citizen such as yourself to 'leave their gun at home'. And I somewhat agree with you that I would rather have my sidearm with me without one in the chamber as opposed to having no sidearm with me whatsoever.

However,
There are many situations that have happened & will happen again where not having a round in the chamber can get someone seriously injured or killed by a determined and overly aggressive assailant.
 
Looks like I need to clear a couple things up again. I came here and posted my belief. I thought I was done after that. Then you guys barraged me with posts saying I was wrong. I then felt I needed to defend my position and find out why you were saying I was wrong. I never said you guys were wrong. So, I feel it's up to you to enlighten me. I'm not going to try to prove you wrong, because I don't necessarily think you are. Nor do I think I can change your mind. But you seem to think you can change mine. And, since I have an open mind, I'm willing to hear your case and change if you give me a good reason to. Let me try to explain those situations where you say you can draw your gun just in time and end the confrontation. First, if you can and it works, great, congratulations. However, if you draw your gun and it doesn't work out, I believe you made a mistake. maine04619: I’ve already stated that you can have your gun taken from you and I explained why. If the bad guy has your gun and it’s chambered, he can shoot you instantly. If he has my gun, it will just go “click.” Also, if someone already has a gun pointed at me, I wouldn’t draw my gun. If it’s a robbery, I’d just give him the money. Why risk getting shot? So, that's why I feel it's best to determine whether you should draw your gun or not. Honestly, in most cases I wouldn't. Why? Because I believe there are a lot of situations where drawing a gun isn't necessary to diffuse the problem and stay alive, nor is it wise. Rabbitcreekok: The main hangup we've had is situations where someone is taken by surprise and there's only 1 or 2 seconds to react. Again, I would not draw my gun in that situation. I would rather use both my arms to fend off the attack, and my karate skills. I may then get a chance to draw my gun at a later point, or maybe not. Can you draw faster than me? I've already said you can. Should you draw, I don't think so. Deanimator: I have never been in any threatening situation in real life. I’m thankful for that. I have had training to defend myself if one ever happens. All my instructors carry one in the chamber. Should I just because they do? No. Should I just because all of you do? No.
Another question was whether I can rack my slide with one hand. (Warning, listen before you leap). I have been trained to do that and, yes, it is very difficult and extremely time consuming. If I'm in a situation where one of my arms is disabled, I would be at a disadvantage. That's why I've stated earlier that you guys have had some good points. However, that one situation won't get me to put one in the chamber for all the rest of the situations where I don't think it's a good idea. Again, I’m more defensive than offensive. If I can get out of a situation without drawing my gun, I won’t draw. If I’m forced to draw my gun and I have enough time, I would draw my gun and shoot. I have no problems with shooting someone, but only if it’s necessary and wise. I think I’ve answered all the questions raised, even if I didn’t mention your name. If I missed one and you think I didn’t cover it in here, please let me know.

I'm not in the business of berating. If you want to carry what amounts to an unloaded weapon, I don't care. I have no dog in the fight, and I'm not going to argue the point because I can't change your mind any better than you can change mine. I did however, post my personal opinion on how I carry my weapon, and exactly why I carry it that way. As far as being disarmed by an attacker, sure, that could happen. A lot of things could happen, but I carry a loaded firearm for defense. That means to me, that it needs to be at the ready so it can be deployed as quickly as possible with a few step as possible. Being stabbed to death or bludgeoned by an attacker while I try to chamber a round just isn't going to work for me. If it's something that you can manage, Thats fine, and I have no comments about your methods. You certainly don't need to defend your preference to me, and Im sorry if you took my post as criticism of your personal method of self defense.
 

New Threads

Members online

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
49,533
Messages
610,704
Members
75,032
Latest member
BLACKROCK6
Back
Top