One in the chamber.... or not

OK, you guys suckered me back into this. Good conversation going now. My apologies to those who think I'm wasting bandwidth. To those who posted videos: they haven't changed my thought process. In the first couple, I believe I would have successfully drawn my weapon & racked my slide, and fired in time in one of them, in the other I would not have drawn my gun, chambered or not. In the last video: although I can't tell what's happening off screen to the right, I'm pretty sure I wouldn't have drawn my gun in that situation. I may be wrong, but I believe most of you would draw your gun in just about any situation. I think that's a big mistake. Have you not thought about diffusing the situation and get out with your life? For those of you saying I should get training, I've had enough training and it hasn't changed my stance. Could I use more? Of course, everybody can benefit from more/different training. Would more training change my mind, no. Here's why I'm still not convinced: nobody provided an answer to my scenarios where I believe you would be at a disadvantage having your gun ready to fire. If you have, I must have missed it. Once again, if you're jumped unexpectedly and draw your weapon, you have a very high chance of having it taken and used against you. In that case, if it's ready to fire, you're in immediate trouble and I'm not. If you don't think someone can get your gun from you because you're highly trained or big and strong, think again. I've been trained to get a gun from a bad guy, it does work and it doesn't matter how big he is. So, if you still think I'm wrong, you'll have to provide more compelling evidence that I'm better off with one in the chamber.
 
You may have missed my post. I have been relieved from my gun by a Bad Guy. I fought for my life over a S&W mod 19 .357. I was able to control the cyclindar. I was unable to disarm him until I got some help though. If I had been armed with my Glock and he had relieved me of that weapon I may not be here now. Even If I was able to control the slide, one shot would have been fired, hopefully I would have been on it quick enough to keep the shot away from me. Even though I have been through this I still carry with one in the chamber. I would never tell someone they are nuts for doing what they think is right for them. The training I received saved my life as did my back up. I still rely on the training that I received, in the way in wich I carry. Thats all there is.
 
:nhl_checking:

In fairness, you didn't ask to be convinced in the OP, croute. You said, "...majority rules, does it really make a difference, is it worth the "risk", I need opinions..."

The majority reply and opinion is uniformly:

1. Yes, it makes a difference;
2. more training creates more comfort with carrying locked/loaded;
3. the risk is carrying unchambered; and
3. you are the final authority on what is best for you.

What's left? That pretty much covers the bases.
 
So, if you still think I'm wrong, you'll have to provide more compelling evidence that I'm better off with one in the chamber.

I apologize if this has been metioned in this thread as I did not read all of it. I did do a search and came up empty. Regardless of how it all started, if you believe his account of the struggle and shooting, do you thing George Zimmermann could have chambered a round while fighting with Treyvon Martin? I think I will still carry chambered all the time in a good quality holster.
 
I may be wrong, but I believe most of you would draw your gun in just about any situation. I think that's a big mistake. Have you not thought about diffusing the situation and get out with your life?
Once again, if you're jumped unexpectedly and draw your weapon, you have a very high chance of having it taken and used against you. In that case, if it's ready to fire, you're in immediate trouble and I'm not.
So, if you still think I'm wrong, you'll have to provide more compelling evidence that I'm better off with one in the chamber.

1) It's not that you may be wrong 'Croute', You 'are' wrong.
2) Your belief is not our 'reality'.
3) You are making many 'asinine assumptions' that the majority of us here would rather draw & use our sidearms instead of de-escalating or 'diffusing' a threat situation. Whenever you Assume, you make an A$$ out of U & Me.
3) The majority of us here do not 'have a very high risk' of ever allowing ourselves to be 'jumped unexpectedly' because of our own situational awareness. Some folks like yourself may tend to walk around with your heads in the clouds while dreaming about gummi bears and rainbow colored butterflies, but I can assure you that the majority of us here do not.
4) Yes, I still think you are wrong -correction- Actually, I 'know' that you are wrong.
5) We don't have to provide any more 'compelling evidence' for you because you are clearly not here to actually 'learn' anything, you are simply here to 'bloviate'.
6) 'I believe' that you are just another forum Troll imvho.
7) (Have a nice day). :dance3:
 
Some of you seem to think I started this post. I didn't, I just responded. Am I here just to chat, no. Am I here to tell you that you shouldn't have a round chambered, no. But you seem to think you need to tell me to have one chambered. Do I have my mind made up, not necessarily, that's why I continue to respond. I have an open mind. Seems like some of you don't. When you tell me I'm wrong, you need to have a very strong case for me to believe you. So far nobody has provided a strong enough case. Billy B, I saw your post. That's not a reason for me to change my mind, but at least you're more on track than others. The Outlaw, you continue to mock me, but haven't shown me a viable reason to side with you. All I did was respond to the post with my opinion. You guys sparked this conversation by questioning my decision. Now you're questioning why I'm here. So, if you're going to gang up on me because I have a different opinion, then you better have a compelling reason to prove me wrong.
 
Some of you seem to think I started this post. I didn't, I just responded. Am I here just to chat, no. Am I here to tell you that you shouldn't have a round chambered, no. But you seem to think you need to tell me to have one chambered. Do I have my mind made up, not necessarily, that's why I continue to respond. I have an open mind. Seems like some of you don't. When you tell me I'm wrong, you need to have a very strong case for me to believe you. So far nobody has provided a strong enough case. Billy B, I saw your post. That's not a reason for me to change my mind, but at least you're more on track than others. The Outlaw, you continue to mock me, but haven't shown me a viable reason to side with you. All I did was respond to the post with my opinion. You guys sparked this conversation by questioning my decision. Now you're questioning why I'm here. So, if you're going to gang up on me because I have a different opinion, then you better have a compelling reason to prove me wrong.

:pleasantry:....................................
 
ALWAYS carry with one in the chamber. If not, you are only carrying an undersized club that has the POTENTIAL to be a pistol.
 
:nhl_checking:

In fairness, you didn't ask to be convinced in the OP, croute. You said, "...majority rules, does it really make a difference, is it worth the "risk", I need opinions..."

The majority reply and opinion is uniformly:

1. Yes, it makes a difference;
2. more training creates more comfort with carrying locked/loaded;
3. the risk is carrying unchambered; and
3. you are the final authority on what is best for you.

What's left? That pretty much covers the bases.
I stand corrected and offer this edit to the above. "In fairness... the OP... said..."

Hate it when I have to quote my own post. :secret:
 
1) It's not that you may be wrong 'Croute', You 'are' wrong.
2) Your belief is not our 'reality'.
3) You are making many 'asinine assumptions' that the majority of us here would rather draw & use our sidearms instead of de-escalating or 'diffusing' a threat situation. Whenever you Assume, you make an A$$ out of U & Me.
3) The majority of us here do not 'have a very high risk' of ever allowing ourselves to be 'jumped unexpectedly' because of our own situational awareness. Some folks like yourself may tend to walk around with your heads in the clouds while dreaming about gummi bears and rainbow colored butterflies, but I can assure you that the majority of us here do not.
4) Yes, I still think you are wrong -correction- Actually, I 'know' that you are wrong.
5) We don't have to provide any more 'compelling evidence' for you because you are clearly not here to actually 'learn' anything, you are simply here to 'bloviate'.
6) 'I believe' that you are just another forum Troll imvho.
7) (Have a nice day). :dance3:

I think you're right Outlaw.

The truth is we've offered up enough evidence. I now think we have nothing but a lying troll on our hands. (Either that, or a complete & total IDIOT.)

I was giving the guy the benefit of doubt & believed he was sincere about learning. But, he says he's an expert and has had enough training. Personally, my BS meter has gone off the charts. So, I think I'm done with this one. :dance3:

-
 
Some of you seem to think I started this post. I didn't, I just responded. Am I here just to chat, no. Am I here to tell you that you shouldn't have a round chambered, no. But you seem to think you need to tell me to have one chambered. Do I have my mind made up, not necessarily, that's why I continue to respond. I have an open mind. Seems like some of you don't. When you tell me I'm wrong, you need to have a very strong case for me to believe you. So far nobody has provided a strong enough case. Billy B, I saw your post. That's not a reason for me to change my mind, but at least you're more on track than others. The Outlaw, you continue to mock me, but haven't shown me a viable reason to side with you. All I did was respond to the post with my opinion. You guys sparked this conversation by questioning my decision. Now you're questioning why I'm here. So, if you're going to gang up on me because I have a different opinion, then you better have a compelling reason to prove me wrong.

If we thought you hi-jacked this thread, you kinda did. I don't think anyone cares how you carry or if you carry. We gave you our opinions, we gave you evidence as to why we believe as we do. Keep your opinion. I would say when you grow up you can carry like the big boys but that would be rude.
 
I have been having this discussion lately, and am out of ideas. So, majority rules, does it really make a difference, is it worth the "risk", I need opinions to further my argument.

Thanks,
Dennis

Cocked and locked, all day every day.
I carry a semi auto that has a safety/decocker and can operate in either single or double action mode.
I chamber a round, decock, and put the safety on. If I need to fire I can just thumb the safety off and fire the first shot double action.
The likelihood that the safety could accidentally come off and the trigger be pulled is practically 0.

In the unlikely event that I am ever going to need to draw in self defense, I am not wasting any time racking the slide and chancing a misfeed.
I want that first round in battery and ready to go.

It's all about how much risk you are willing to accept I guess.
 
I'm going to agree with you guys that I should stop. Obviously you're not able to convince me that I should have a round chambered. BTW I'm grown up- 46. An "idiot?" I believe my college degree would satisfy most that I'm not. I never said I was an expert, just that I had enough training. I came here to possibly learn something that I didn't know. I thought the thread was interesting and gave my opinion. When I was challenged, I thought, gee, it seems everyone in here disagrees with me, I wonder why. Maybe they know something I don't. Let's see if I can learn something. Well, I didn't learn much. I'll move on.
 
I'm going to agree with you guys that I should stop. Obviously you're not able to convince me that I should have a round chambered. BTW I'm grown up- 46. An "idiot?" I believe my college degree would satisfy most that I'm not. I never said I was an expert, just that I had enough training. I came here to possibly learn something that I didn't know. I thought the thread was interesting and gave my opinion. When I was challenged, I thought, gee, it seems everyone in here disagrees with me, I wonder why. Maybe they know something I don't. Let's see if I can learn something. Well, I didn't learn much. I'll move on.
Don't defend yourself. It just invites more responses. If you're personally not comfortable with one in the chamber that should be respected. I hold that in much higher esteem than a guy who carries chambered and then puts one in his foot. You know your own limitations and that makes tou safer.
 

New Threads

Members online

No members online now.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
49,533
Messages
610,704
Members
75,032
Latest member
BLACKROCK6
Back
Top