One in the chamber.... or not

Obviously you guys are in a daily life-threatening situation that I don't experience.

Obviously you have a crystal that will predict when you will and will not encounter a life-threatening situation that will allow you the time to load your gun, and will predict that your gun will not malfunction when loading when you most need it. I don't possess such a crytstal ball and apparantly neither did any of the victims that have been shot in movie theaters, poilitical events, schools, restaurants and churches.

To me carrying a round in the chamber is like wearing a seat belt. The benefits of having either the gun or the seat belt 100% ready to use should the event occur to need it, no matter how unlikely that event is, far outweighs the miniscule risk associated with having the gun or selt belt 100% ready to go. I don't possess the crystal ball that you apparantly rely upon to tell me when I am going to need or not need either my seat belt or my gun.
 
Why would you not carry a loaded gun? Perhaps then I might know how to answer you. My s&w 38 spl is always ready and so is my s&w 1911 e series. I wouldn't do it any other way. Now, when I first got my 1911 I didn't carry with it until I had a lot of range time and even then I didn't carry it in cond1 until I was comfortable with my holster/weapon/carry method. During this time I carried my 1911 in cond1 with no ammo in the chamber. Why? Because this model has an ambi safety and I wanted to make sure that nothing that I do or did in my edc activities would cause the safety to come off. Start with safe gun handling pratices and I don't think you will have problems. Start cutting corners and you will. Quality guns, holsters, belts and safes are part of the deal. You won't hear of an AD/ND as long as you practice both at the range and at home the same activities each and every time. The weapon won't fire itself.
 
Always with one in the pipe. If you are using one hand to ward off an attack, you will not be able to chamber one. Fight lost. If one hand is injured, same outcome.
 
there is training to rack your slide on your belt buckle or table or something but why risk having to do all that but to each their own
 
there is training to rack your slide on your belt buckle or table or something but why risk having to do all that but to each their own
However, NOBODY I've seen claim they could do that, had ever tried it while in a hand to hand fight for their life.

Isn't it interesting that people who profess to be afraid of an accidental discharge from a properly safe and holstered handgun, in the next breath talk about chambering a round, ONE HANDED, during a vicious hand to hand struggle?

As you say, "to each their own"...
 
To me carrying a round in the chamber is like wearing a seat belt. The benefits of having either the gun or the seat belt 100% ready to use should the event occur to need it, no matter how unlikely that event is, far outweighs the miniscule risk associated with having the gun or seat belt 100% ready to go.

Well said Navy. Never used this perspective before but I will from now on. (I tend to run into this discussion a lot)
 
One in the chamber at all times!! If it ever come down to it the B.G. will not give you time to rack and load. Just keep SAFETY in mind and you'll be okay!!
 
It's all about training and confidence using your weapon. I might suggest "Frontsight" or another professional training facility. There are a few out there. " any gun will do - if you will do "
Train well and often MHO
 
I've posted before on this issue and I do carry one in the chamber but..... Years ago I got into a fight with a suspect and somehow the perp got my holstered 357. We began to fight over the gun and I was able to control the cylinder and finially some got asistance in the situation. No one was hurt but it was a life and death situation. Thinking back ifI had been carrilng my glock wilth just an internal safety I think the perp would have been able to get one shot off even if I controled the slide. The situation as it was probably would have cost me my life. Its just a thought, but still I would carry with one in. I was young and made some mistakes and the equipent availabe at that time was not as good as it is today.
 
When I first got my license to carry, I carried fully loaded. (one in the chamber). Then I thought better of it and decided for safety's sake to not keep one in the chamber. At no time did I face any incidents of being sorry for my decision.

Then a few months later I decided it would be safer if didn't have the magazine in the gun, so I started carrying the magazine in a pouch of it's own. Then I had a safe gun.

But I figured out one day that that was pretty risky so I took the ammo out of the magazine and carried for 40 years since then with the satisfaction of knowing that I was the safest concealed carrier in the world.
 
Both my 9mm and my 40sw are DAO and the safety are in the triggers. No lever to flip nor button to push, just pull the trigger. They are loaded with the rounds in the pipes.
 
I keep one .357 round in each of my SP101's 5 chambers. :-P

Haha. As for semi-autos, I think modern guns are designed with enough safety mechanisms to prevent accidental discharge when handled by an educated gun owner who practices safe carry and handling methods. Don't skimp - make sure you have a good holster.
 
I have been having this discussion lately, and am out of ideas. So, majority rules, does it really make a difference, is it worth the "risk", I need opinions to further my argument. Thanks, Dennis
If it is for DEFENSE then not having one in the chamber is the risk.
 
It doesn't do you much good if you are not ready...if you are going to carry for protection, one in the chamber and you are ready
 
I recently started carrying with one in the chamber and now thinking back I'm not sure why I didn't before.

If you can't safely handle a firearm, you probably shouldn't be carrying it for protection.

No risk involved, bigger risk is being taken without one in the chamber Imo.
 
With any modern weapon from a reputable manufacturer there really is no risk. Put one in the chamber and put it in a decent holster with the trigger and guard covered and go on your merry way. The few seconds it will take to draw and chamber a round will make a difference. Plus the fact that in the heat of the moment you could easily slip up and not pull the slide hard enough or lose grip and then you're really screwed.
 
As I said before, no disrespect intended for those who wish to carry unprepared, or unchambered, its fairly well accepted that in a completely unexpected tense situation you would be lucky to have time to deploy your weapon and get a half aimed shot off, let alone take that extra second or two to rack the slide, and in the case of a revolver that same type of guy would carry it with the hammer parked over a empty chamber, I just ask this show me one LEO that carrys unchambered, and if I hear that they are well trained, I would argue then why do some shoot themselfs and others handleing there weapon, just like non LEOs, LOL, and in certain cases I would question there shooting ability, I have been to the range when some are there, and I think they could use more practice,..........keep one chambered, KNOW what your hand and fingers are doing 110% of the time.........and be safe
 
Finally we're having a better discussion with some good points, without the potshots. I now appreciate the feedback. I'm also open to changing my ways if someone gives me a clear reason why I should have a round chambered. So far I'm not convinced. I'm still not sure you're getting my point of situations where I believe you shouldn't draw your gun. Those are the only cases where I believe it's better not to have one in the pipe. And since I don't know when that situation may happen, I don't keep the gun ready to fire. Again, if I'm jumped or cornered unexpectedly, the last thing I'd be thinking about is trying to draw my gun. I'd be focused on how to either take down the opponent or get away. At least until an opportunity presents itself where I would have a chance to draw it. In that case, I don't think racking the slide while drawing is going to make a huge difference- a total of 1 second.
 
The sound just may stop an aggressor in his tracks.

However, I carry with one in the chamber. LCP or LC9 are carry guns here. LCP doesn't have a safety, I leave the LC9's safety off to be consistent with how I practice with the LCP. Both guns are in a holster that covers the trigger.

I was stating that solely from a legal point of view, depending on the situation. The courts may see it differently. Always carry with one in the chamber.
 
So far I'm not convinced.
The thing which "convinces" you may in fact KILL you.

But again, that's your choice.

In that case, I don't think racking the slide while drawing is going to make a huge difference- a total of 1 second.
Have you TRIED chambering a round, ONE HANDED, while somebody is physically assaulting you?

If not, you're planning for a worst case event using a best case scenario.

That rarely works. Ask the Japanese who fought on Guadalcanal and New Guinea.
 

New Threads

Members online

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
49,533
Messages
610,704
Members
75,032
Latest member
BLACKROCK6
Back
Top