One in the chamber.... or not

Are you willing to bet your life on your assumption that you will have enough time to rack the slide? Are you willing to bet your life that you will have both hands free to rack the slide? Are you willing to bet your life that your gun will not malfunction during manually loading the first round from the magazine? Are you willing to bet that in the heat of the moment your hand won't slip off the slide while attempting to chamber the round?.

If he's carrying an empty chamber the answer , by definition, is yes.
 
I have been having this discussion lately, and am out of ideas. So, majority rules, does it really make a difference, is it worth the "risk", I need opinions to further my argument.
Thanks,
Dennis

Risk? If you are a risk carrying with one in the chamber, perhaps you should not carry. Sooner or later one has to be there if you are going to use it. If you are not competent to carry that way, then maybe you are not competent to use it in public. It will not go off by itself.
 
Just learn to carry the gun properly. Good holster that covers the trigger and retains the gun. Learn and practice the proper draw stroke so you don't get inside the trigger guard when drawing. Practice, practice, practice. And lastly, don't pet your piece. You loaded it. You racked it. You holstered it. Now keep your hands off it.

I've carried a Glock G27 chambered both IWB and OWB for years. No safety, yet never had a problem.
 
1 in the pipe, always. Been around firearms my entire life, never once had a discharge from one that I was in control of that I didn't make happen myself.
 
In MHO I think a gun shouldn't be "ready to fire." I use a semi-automatic and figure I'll have time to pull the slide. If I don't, I'm not sure it would really matter in the situation I'm in at that time. It's too easy to have your gun go off unexpectedly and just as easy to ready it.

Nothing to say to that except it is wrong. You have to do something for it to go off unexpectedly (so what you mean is negligently). If you don't have time to rack the slide then one in the chamber won't matter? Never ready to fire? Then you are "using" it for emotional support, not self-defense.
 
For the crowd who feels the need to carry an unloaded gun, how about this as an expriment: load or have someone load a primer into a piece of empty brass so you basically end up with a one time use snap cap - no powder, no bullet, just empty brass and a primer. Drop the brass in the chamber and close the slide on it. One time isn't going to break your extractor.

Now insert your magazine and carry like you normally do. If you have to use your gun the way that you plan to use it, when you rack the slide to load your gun in your emergency situation, the empy brass will just be ejected anyway. Now, the experiment is...see how long that piece of brass stays in the chamber without the primer getting popped. If there is a "negligent discharge" you won't get anything more than a louder than usual pop like an extra strength cap gun, but nothing will come out of the gun and the slide will not cycle.

And heck, if you are worried about your 16 year old daughter or her friends - if one of them grabs your gun like you are worried about and pulls the trigger, the pop will scare the hell out of them and teach them a lesson they won't soon forget.
 
One area of thought is that the chambering of a round could be considered an "aggressive" gesture. Best always to leave one in the chamber.....

The sound just may stop an aggressor in his tracks.

However, I carry with one in the chamber. LCP or LC9 are carry guns here. LCP doesn't have a safety, I leave the LC9's safety off to be consistent with how I practice with the LCP. Both guns are in a holster that covers the trigger.
 
One in the pipe or don't bother carrying, you WILL NOT have the time to pull it out and chamber a round. This have been proven time and time again, if think you have the ninja skills to do it, it's your life not mine.
 
I prefer a pistol with a de-cocker rather than an external safety. I found it too easy to put the safety back on during the process of clearing a malfunction.
 
The truth is, whether you have one in the pipe or not you may not have enough time to even react draw quick enough either way in many situations because the attacker ALWAYS has the element of surprise against you.




You may have time to rack the slide you may not then again you may not even have time to draw at all.

The unchambered carry method may still save you in some situations and one in the pipe may in several more, but either way there is no garantee so go with which way you feel more comfortable. I understand the ups & downs of both
 
thanks for the vid on that ..tox that kid looked similar to trayvons age too i wonder how old he was? glad the cop acted quickly and to answer the op topic yes i keep one in the chamber i'm sitting here now rigged and ready fully loaded cuz ya never know when some ahole going to try their luck......
stay safe and keep one in the chamber!

He was in his 30's. (I think?)
He's also a repeat offender who has attacked & been shot by a LEO before.

The point I want to make to some people here that are afraid to carry +1 is: "you never know when you may be attacked; OR by who."

Sure this guy attacked an officer. But, he could have just as easily attacked the driver of the SUV; or even walked down the road an attacked someone else. This BG didn't give any clues to anyone before he was within 10' of the officer.

The officer had been TRAINED to handle bad situations; and may have been able to deflect & rack the slide. But, most "citizen" CCers probably would have stood there with that "deer in the headlights" look until the BG was slicing them to pieces.

I wonder how easy it would be to rack the slide with this 200lb BG cut'n you up with a butcher knife?

BTW;
This actually happened in an area where I used to work daily.

-
 
If you don't feel comfortable carrying concealed with one in the chamber I don't see how you are comfortable carrying concealed.
 
it's your life not mine.

And that is what it really boils down to. Like the OC v. CC argument. Both sides have presented their reasons they feel their way is better, both sides have present counter-arguments. Now it's just up to each person to decide how they want to carry..... but I'll bet this particular discussion goes on for at least another entire page of posts :-)
 
i agree if you're going to carry keep one in the chamber no doubt and if you're not comfortable then don't carry till you are but it also depends what kind of gun you have .......i have a da so i feel very comfortable fully loaded knowing it's not going to just go off ..plus i have a safe holster that covers the trigger guard well which i'm borrowing but i ordered a supertuck from crossbreed combat style horseskin so i'm looking forward to that to arrive! dang thing total cost 101 usd pretty expensive for a piece of leather and some kydex imo but that's what i think is the perfect holster for me and this sunday i'm going to the gun show get me a good belt for it to as i think they may be cheaper prices there than on line......at anyrate know your gun well enough to feel comfortable with it +1 as it's not just going to shoot in a good holster and mindfulness
 
The sound just may stop an aggressor in his tracks.
No sir! "Homey" and "Flaco" don't know what planet they're on. Violence and guns are part of their daily life. This is not a deterrent. One should not bet their life on it. If one is going to carry a gun, then "CARRY IT." Ready to rock and roll at the drop of a hat. Hoody can close a 25 foot gap and inflict a fatal blow or stab in about 1.5 seconds. Even with one chambered most of us will barely be able to get that heater out... thus the speed-rock and Tueller drill are taught in our PP classes. Click on the drill for more info.
 
that's a new term for me the 'speed rock' do you have a video on that i can see to know if i've practiced that maneuver before cuz if not i'd like to learn it and what's a 'pp' class sorry new to all that lingo thanks
 
that's a new term for me the 'speed rock' do you have a video on that i can see to know if i've practiced that maneuver before cuz if not i'd like to learn it and what's a 'pp' class sorry new to all that lingo thanks
PP - Personal Protection

Speed Rock - Used to get the first 1-2 shots off quicker when the goblin is moving in fast at close range.

Draw stroke steps while retreating or moving to cover (shooting hand / support hand). Remember, speed doesn't come from fast hands. It comes from economy of movement... by eliminating unnecessary movement. Some of the fastest, most accurate shooters I've seen were in their 50's & 60's.

  1. Access / chest
  2. Grip / chest
  3. Pull / chest
  4. Rotate / chest
  5. Slightly rock hip upward during rotate / Chest
  6. Fire / chest or blocking attacker (don't shoot your support hand)
  7. Join hands
  8. Extend
  9. Fire

Note the slight upward rock of the hip as he rotates the gun

 
[video=youtube;frsqw3Z5LRQ]http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=endscreen&NR=1&v=frsqw3Z5LRQ[/video]

another good vid on speed rock.....i've practiced this but didn't know it was called 'speed rock' and will continue to practice it for life
 

New Threads

Members online

No members online now.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
49,533
Messages
610,704
Members
75,032
Latest member
BLACKROCK6
Back
Top