One in the chamber.... or not

OP-
Do you think you'd have time and/or the presence of mind to rack your slide in this situation?

What if you were the man in the truck and the guy came after you; would you have time then?

 
:angry: It's STUPID not to carry a full magazine plus one. If you can't trust yourself to carry that way, lock it up in your safe or better yet, just sell the damn thing.
 
The video in post #21 is a great real life example of why 1 in the hole is important. Imagine if this guy had to take the time to rack one into the chamber. You also risk a malfunction doing that. So by have 1 ready to go you eliminate that element..... The 21 ft rule is also very important , good point that was made in outlaws video .
 
Some interesting videos, while we are not security guards or police something can be learned. First of all have one in the chamber, second, if you believe someone is a danger don't get too close to that person. Third if someone comes up and attacks, get away from them so you can draw your gun.

Better to draw your gun and advise a person you have a gun than to be lethargic and let him close in on you.
If attacked with a knife, fend them off with your non-shooting hand, or maybe kick him in the groin and move enough so you can draw your weapon. Once you do draw shoot and keep shooting till the threat is cleared.

Why would you even want to think of having to rack the slide in an emergency? Carry one in the chamber.

:triniti:
 
thanks for the vid on that ..tox that kid looked similar to trayvons age too i wonder how old he was? glad the cop acted quickly and to answer the op topic yes i keep one in the chamber i'm sitting here now rigged and ready fully loaded cuz ya never know when some ahole going to try their luck......
stay safe and keep one in the chamber!
 
In MHO I think a gun shouldn't be "ready to fire." I use a semi-automatic and figure I'll have time to pull the slide. If I don't, I'm not sure it would really matter in the situation I'm in at that time. It's too easy to have your gun go off unexpectedly and just as easy to ready it.

Are you willing to bet your life on your assumption that you will have enough time to rack the slide? Are you willing to bet your life that you will have both hands free to rack the slide? Are you willing to bet your life that your gun will not malfunction during manually loading the first round from the magazine? Are you willing to bet that in the heat of the moment your hand won't slip off the slide while attempting to chamber the round? What if you are with your wife or children at the time you need to use your firearm. Would you rather use your free hand to push them to safety or rack the slide on your gun? If your attacker approaches from behind and surprises you, would you rather have your free hand available to push them away and defend yourself from their attack, or need it to rack the slide of your gun?

Can you predict when your gun will malfunction? You need to shoot, you draw your gun, you rack the slide, thrust the gun forward, squeeze the trigger and get a click because the round was not stripped from the magazine completely and the slide is either partially open or closed on an empty chamber. Where would you rather correct a malfunction? In the relative safe confines of your home, or with the bad guy you are attempting to shoot at bearing down on you? Would you rather bet your life on the first round chambering properly, or be able to take the time to ensure that the round is properly chambered under controlled conditions?

99% of negligent discharges happen when the gun is either being loaded or unloaded. Being able to load the gun under controlled conditions in the relative safety of your home greatly decreases the chances of a negligent discharge while loading the gun.

There is a reason why there isn't a cop alive who carries their gun without a round in the chamber. If a person cannot insert, remove or carry their gun in their holster without activating the trigger and causing a negative discharge than the issue is with training and/or negligence, not if there is a round in the chamber or not. If you have a gun that is in the habit of discharging by itself, without activating the trigger, than you shouldn't be relying upon a broken gun to save you life anyway.
 
First and foremost, it is your firearm and you need to be comfortable with how you carry it.

With that said, here are my thoughts and why I carry the way I do. Inform yourself about the Tueller drill. It is a drill that states through empirical data that if someone is 21 feet (7yards) from you with a knife, it will take them 2 seconds to reach you. With a level 2 tactical holster I can get a off a shot in 1.7 seconds. With a Serpa CQC holster, I can get the shot off in 1.3 seconds. However, for kicks and giggles, I decided to try doing this drill without a round in the chamber, but having to rack the slide first. With both types of holsters, I was over 2 seconds. I, therefore, always carry with one round in the chamber at all times. Even if it gives you a 0.5 second advantage, it is worth your life to practice, practice perfectly, and practice safely that way. I have carried and practiced for many years with one in the chamber and have never had an "accidental fire". Every time I want the gun to go bang it does and when I don't want it to go bang it doesn't.

Best wishes on your decision.
 
I don't keep one in the chamber.

this thread reminded me of these recent articles...lol..

Police chief injured in accidental shooting

Ex-State Police investigator accidentally shoots himself at Sears - Times Union

without checking any statistics, I believe I am more likely to be accidentally shot, than to be shot during a crime.

I also have a 16 year old daughter and her friends around my house, every attempt is made to deter access but I can't watch them 24 hours a day, in my mind any extra step is a step away from an unwanted tragedy.
 
Almost all personal protection guns are always chambered: the pocket gun, the bedside gun, the in the car gun, the living room gun, the garage gun - all chambered. The only exception is the Mossberg 500. Nothing like that sound to let someone know you mean business.
 
Are you willing to bet your life on your assumption that you will have enough time to rack the slide? Are you willing to bet your life that you will have both hands free to rack the slide? Are you willing to bet your life that your gun will not malfunction during manually loading the first round from the magazine? Are you willing to bet that in the heat of the moment your hand won't slip off the slide while attempting to chamber the round? What if you are with your wife or children at the time you need to use your firearm. Would you rather use your free hand to push them to safety or rack the slide on your gun? If your attacker approaches from behind and surprises you, would you rather have your free hand available to push them away and defend yourself from their attack, or need it to rack the slide of your gun?

Can you predict when your gun will malfunction? You need to shoot, you draw your gun, you rack the slide, thrust the gun forward, squeeze the trigger and get a click because the round was not stripped from the magazine completely and the slide is either partially open or closed on an empty chamber. Where would you rather correct a malfunction? In the relative safe confines of your home, or with the bad guy you are attempting to shoot at bearing down on you? Would you rather bet your life on the first round chambering properly, or be able to take the time to ensure that the round is properly chambered under controlled conditions?

99% of negligent discharges happen when the gun is either being loaded or unloaded. Being able to load the gun under controlled conditions in the relative safety of your home greatly decreases the chances of a negligent discharge while loading the gun.

There is a reason why there isn't a cop alive who carries their gun without a round in the chamber. If a person cannot insert, remove or carry their gun in their holster without activating the trigger and causing a negative discharge than the issue is with training and/or negligence, not if there is a round in the chamber or not. If you have a gun that is in the habit of discharging by itself, without activating the trigger, than you shouldn't be relying upon a broken gun to save you life anyway.

Very well said!
 
I don't keep one in the chamber.

this thread reminded me of these recent articles...lol..

Police chief injured in accidental shooting

Ex-State Police investigator accidentally shoots himself at Sears - Times Union

without checking any statistics, I believe I am more likely to be accidentally shot, than to be shot during a crime.

I also have a 16 year old daughter and her friends around my house, every attempt is made to deter access but I can't watch them 24 hours a day, in my mind any extra step is a step away from an unwanted tragedy.

1. There are so many negligent discharges by police officers that there is a huge movement for police officers to carry their guns without a round in the chamber, right? (The correct answer is NOT). You do understand that there is a much greater chance of being the victim of a violent crime as a Joe Citizen than as a police officer, right? Police officers are generally less likely to be the victim of a violent crime while in uniform and on duty than Joe Citizen is...so why do they carry their guns with a round in the chamber? Why don't they just chamber a round when they think they might be going into an especially dangerous situation, but leave it without a round in the chamber at all other times?

2. There is a huge difference between carrying a gun in a holster on your belt and leaving that gun unattended in the house for the kids to access it. Nobody here is saying to keep a round chambered when you put your gun away for storage. We are discussing when the firearm is being carried for self-defense. If you can't keep your kids or their friends from keeping their hands off a gun in a holster on your belt than you have much bigger problems than keeping a round in the chamber.

Many times more people die from violent criminal attacks than from negligent discharges, therefore I will do everything I can to prevent what is more likely to happen to me.

Do you folks also not wear your seat belts until you see an accident coming? I mean, after all, there is a chance the seat belt will trap you inside your car when you might need to escape, right? That's why fire departments and rescue personnel carry seat belt knives, right?
 
EXCELLENT reminders to maintain control of your weapon at all times (especially when loading/unloading or dropping your drawers) and to not be a nincompoop. As is often said, "Complacency is the enemy."

And in fairness to not-those-two, each of the incidents occured on the same day 800,00 police and 5-million people with CCW permits didn't shoot themselves.

For me, the Smith & Wesson 642 is alwys five up; Sig P938 has a full magazine and one in the pipe, cocked and locked. I was a little uncomfortable the first time someone tossed me some C-4 and a Claymore mine. If cocked/locked makes you uncomfortable then follow your own instincts to be safe; or get a revolver (or a DA auto); or establish more training better familiarizing youself with the mechanical safeties inherent in you particular firearm.

Empty, it's a paperweight.
 
Carrying an empty chamber is a sign of inadequate training and a lack of confidence in ones firearms handling skill as it concerns self defense.
 
If you can't carry with confidence in condition 1 maybe you should either get a revolver or better yet hang up the gun belt......You might be a danger.
 
Always one in the chamber. If someone is 10-15 ft from you and runs at you with a knife you could be stabbed 2-4 times by the time you pull the gun and load one and fire.
 
More negligent discharges happen due to a round in the chamber and an inexperienced hand on a firearm than encounters that require an instant response of gunfire in 2.5 seconds. We have had several cases of negligent discharge of a firearm by a CCW License holder, listed on this site. ( Man shoots himself in the Butt) (DEA Agent Negligent Discharge) Etc. The Media and Anti-Gunners love these incidents. Bottom line, if you do not have the right training and want to carry fully loaded, get trained or carry a Revolver.
 
If there is not one in the chamber the gun is unloaded. I'm willing to bet the bad guy is carrying a loaded gun. Why let him have an advantage over you.
 
Better to draw your gun and advise a person you have a gun than to be lethargic and let him close in on you.

Quite possibly the worst advice I have ever read.

We only draw when we are in reasonable fear of losing our life or being seriously injured if we don't.

Drawing as a "warning" is called aggravated menacing in most jurisdictions.
 

New Threads

Members online

No members online now.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
49,533
Messages
610,704
Members
75,032
Latest member
BLACKROCK6
Back
Top