Live round in the chamber

Thanks for taking the time to post what you did. I'm not anti gun at all. I'm just pro safety. Looking at the numbers you speak of, you have convinced me an AD is highly unlikely. I'm just concerned because I have seen a few too many AD's with rifles in various situations that had made me suspicious, especially light triggers and a bit of a bump that sets them off.

I still feel if I were to C&C in the US that I would not have a round in the chamber. If that is the cause of my demise, than so be it. :)

Rifles, particularly AR/M16 platforms have a much different safety mechanism than your standard pistol. most semi-automatic pistols have a positive safety mechanism, meaning that there is not only a lock on the trigger mechanism, but also a block on the firing pin as well. dropping a modern semi auto pistol with a chambered round will not result in a discharge. semi-auto rifles (as well as pump action shotguns, any long gun for that matter), however, have a non-positive safety - meaning the safety only prevents the trigger from being pulled, but does nothing to prevent the internal mechanisms from letting loose. this is why most AD situations are typically from long guns. Most LE agencies always carry pistol with round chambered and long-guns with a full mag and an empty chamber.

ultimately, the best "safety" for your weapon is your brain and your training.
 
At the end of the day, if your attacker initiates the attack, you're pretty much ******!!
Actually, if you create artificial handicaps for yourself and GIVE UP, you're boned.

Unless you're committing an unlawful assault on another person when would your attacker NOT "initiate the attack"? If YOU initiate the attack, YOU are the "attacker".

The two drooling imbeciles in the Dayton gas station attack "initiated the attack". The victim had a round in the chamber and didn't give up. The results were:
  1. Victim safe
  2. One assailant shot twice in the abdomen
  3. One assailant fleeing
 
Actually, if you create artificial handicaps for yourself and GIVE UP, you're boned.

Unless you're committing an unlawful assault on another person when would your attacker NOT "initiate the attack"? If YOU initiate the attack, YOU are the "attacker".

The two drooling imbeciles in the Dayton gas station attack "initiated the attack". The victim had a round in the chamber and didn't give up. The results were:
  1. Victim safe
  2. One assailant shot twice in the abdomen
  3. One assailant fleeing


Now see here, Deanimator- STOP using logic to make your arguments! :sarcastic:


Levity aside, your point is well made- given adequate preparations (having a round in the chamber among them) and the correct mindset (Refuse to accept defeat.), it is possible to beat the lag/delay created by the reactionary curve.
 
Actually, you are kinda are wrong. The
Glocks and others with strikers are not fully cocked until the trigger is pulled.
The striker is in a state of partial cock. Pulling the trigger releases the firing pin block and finishes cocking the the striker before it is released.

Absolutely right. I can send you a video (trailboss) of my XDM's trigger being pressed. The striker/indicator actually moves back and out about 1/32-1/16" before being released and sent forward. You can also clearly see the striker being fully cocked during the trigger press if you look between the slide and the frame.

oops:agree:

I sold my Glock and XD a couple years ago.:cray:

Got my hands on some this weekend.:pleasantry:

I see with a round in the chamber the striker is only 95% back.:biggrin:

So they would be conditon 1.5.:sarcastic:




Anyway, if you do not carry every day and/or do not carry with a round in the chamber. :eek:

Why carry at all. :no:

In an emergency situation, you probably will make things worse for yourself.:stop:

If you dissagree, then you will never understand and should sell all your guns.:help:
 
Anyway, if you do not carry every day and/or do not carry with a round in the chamber. :eek:

Why carry at all. :no:
I work in a CPZ.

If I don't go out again after coming home from work, I don't carry that day.

That doesn't mean I shouldn't carry when I CAN.
 
I find it curious that neither the op in this thread or the other that I posted in responded to my question as to how and why they think an AD/ND might occur.
 
I find it curious that neither the op in this thread or the other that I posted in responded to my question as to how and why they think an AD/ND might occur.
Most times these things are grounded in ignorance of basic firearms mechanics and irrational fear.

Guns aren't magical talismans. They don't "just go off" of their own accord. Something has to SET them off, either (in the overwhelming majority of cases) an intentional or negligent action by the possessor, or a malfunction of the mechanism.
 
I was kidding....but I don't blame you for taking me seriously.



I think you could train your whole life to cater for every single foreseeable possibility. At the end of the day, if your attacker initiates the attack, you're pretty much ******!! The video speaks for itself. 21 feet of distance required to draw and fire to stop an attacker. If you're astute enough to identify a threat from that far away, you should be drawing before they charge you. I doubt such a confrontation is ever the case in reality.

Do you wear body armor everywhere you go? Do you mount a camera to the back of your head streaming video to your sunglasses? Do you hire armed bodyguard to walk with you everywhere? Where do you draw the line?

I'm in the camp where I don't feel the need to be overly paranoid. Knowing I have a pistol that is ready to go within a couple of seconds is good enough for me.

A couple of seconds is more time than you have in most violent encounters. Believe it or don't, it is what it is. There is a difference between being prepared and being paranoid.
 
:dance3: Wise up and keep one in the chamber, you may not have time to rack a slide, it could cost you your life.

Why would you NOT want your gun ready to shoot if something happens?

Keep one in the chamber :triniti:
 
A couple of seconds is more time than you have in most violent encounters. Believe it or don't, it is what it is. There is a difference between being prepared and being paranoid.

Hey, just cause you think they're after you doesn't mean they're not. Cocked & Locked, the only way to carry.
 
Ok that would be one PD
I've heard of others. Can't recall specifics right now.

Edit: Didn't LAPD SWAT use M1911s? I vaguely recall Springfield having a model with some connection to them.

Close, the LAPD SWAT Team carries a Kimber 1911 TLE (Tactical Law Enf) but that really doesnt equate to the convo, as any SWAT Team is all Business and most likely allows the individual to decide, But being that it is such a surgical type of weapon carried by an elite team, in my experience they wld have the hammer cocked w a Straight Finger on slide !
 
I'd like to see a video of a person racking the slide with only 1 hand while being attacked.
I want to answer a threat with my trump card....but don't want to sort the deck in front of 'em!
 
I'd like to see a video of a person racking the slide with only 1 hand while being attacked.
I want to answer a threat with my trump card....but don't want to sort the deck in front of 'em!

With that I agree 100% Most violent encounters start at 10 feet or less. Most get killed at 5 feet or less. No one in the world is fast enough at that distance to draw the gun and rack the gun. If I person isn't sure enough of himself that he worries about one in the chamber I would suggest leave the gun at home or carry a revolver instead of a pistol.

Also one more thing almost all gunfight will start out hand to hand. Never forget that part of your training. After all you do have to make enough distance to bring your weapon into play be it a gun or a blade. Also at that distance don't bet a gun will always trump a blade
 
Actually, if you create artificial handicaps for yourself and GIVE UP, you're boned.

Unless you're committing an unlawful assault on another person when would your attacker NOT "initiate the attack"? If YOU initiate the attack, YOU are the "attacker".


True most of the time but not always. Many times if you wait for the attacker to give you final confirmation the fight is started It will come as injury or maybe death to you. You are allowed to preempt the strike by attacking first many times
 
Actually, if you create artificial handicaps for yourself and GIVE UP, you're boned.

Unless you're committing an unlawful assault on another person when would your attacker NOT "initiate the attack"? If YOU initiate the attack, YOU are the "attacker".


True most of the time but not always. Many times if you wait for the attacker to give you final confirmation the fight is started It will come as injury or maybe death to you. You are allowed to preempt the strike by attacking first many times
If somebody pulls a knife or gun on me, I don't have to wait for him to stab or shoot me.

That DOESN'T mean that I can just shoot somebody without some overt indication of a threat of death or great bodily harm.
 
Have seen this done before, never said you can't rack a round, again no threat, pistol on table and racked beautifully, do it with pistol in holster while a person 21' away is on you with a knife (rubber), will still carry cocked and locked.
 
I'm a supporter of CCW and an Australian who cannot carry.

What I don't understand is why people carry with a round in the chamber. It only takes a second to rack the slide, a lot less time to aim and draw, I just don't understand why people feel the need to do that.

I'd rather not risk the chance of accidental discharge. My thoughts only. Happy to be proven wrong. :)
Hard to rack one handed, can be done but harder and takes longer. Modern properly functioning firearms don't accident go bang unless something pulls the trigger. Just my 2 cents.
 
I'd like to see a video of a person racking the slide with only 1 hand while being attacked.
I want to answer a threat with my trump card....but don't want to sort the deck in front of 'em!
Racking the slide isn't that hard one handed, depending on holster or belt you use. I practice one handed rack sliding, but as an injury drill.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LMsAvWOEj-k&feature=youtube_gdata_player

That said I carry with a round in the chamber, and if carrying 1911 cocked and locked.
 

New Threads

Members online

No members online now.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
49,533
Messages
610,704
Members
75,032
Latest member
BLACKROCK6
Back
Top