Live round in the chamber

I don't know about Australia but here in the US each State does his own thing about gun laws, at least to some degree. My home State does not issue permits to non-citizens so I had to get a Utah non-resident permit which my State does acknowledge as valid. So I am a German with a greencard living in NC and carrying with a UT permit, gun is an XD so it was made in Croatia. Go figure ;-)

Here's Florida's requirement for non-citzens:

http://licgweb.doacs.state.fl.us/weapons/cw_license_eligibility_requirements_web.pdf

Concealed Weapons or Firearm Program - Division of Licensing, FDACS
 
I think it's silly to carry without a round in the chamber. If I ever need to use my weopon, I want every second and partial second for me to get the weopon out and on target. I never want to worry if there is a round in the chamber. Just my thoughts
 
I don't know about Australia but here in the US each State does his own thing about gun laws, at least to some degree. My home State does not issue permits to non-citizens so I had to get a Utah non-resident permit which my State does acknowledge as valid. So I am a German with a greencard living in NC and carrying with a UT permit, gun is an XD so it was made in Croatia. Go figure ;-)

Funny story. :) But you have a greencard. What i'm really trying to work out is if i can get a CCW permit with just a visa. The government regulations stipulate you cannot get a CCW permit if you are an illegal alien. Happy to be accepted as an alien carrying a ray gun, but i'm not illegal if i have a visa right?
 
Funny story. :) But you have a greencard. What i'm really trying to work out is if i can get a CCW permit with just a visa. The government regulations stipulate you cannot get a CCW permit if you are an illegal alien. Happy to be accepted as an alien carrying a ray gun, but i'm not illegal if i have a visa right?

I can't say for each State of course, as I mentioned they are all different. But at least here in NC you can not get a CCW permit with a visa only. You can purchase and own guns as long as there's no other reason making that illegal but CCW ... no luck. Anybody with a greencard or a visa is of course not an illegal alien ... people talk so much about them they often don't even know that there are perfectly legal ones, too.
 
people that dependant on a sefety are either doing too much....

where they probably shouldnt be carrying anyway.

or not enough training and confidence in their own abilities...

where they probably shouldnt be carrying anyway.

JMO
 
Ok, this has been beat to death and recently but I'll ask the op the same question I asked the last guy: How and why do you think there would be a problem as in AD/Nd with one in the chamber of a semi-auto? I got no answer before {and didn't expect one**
 
Just for argument's sake, if you CC w/out one in the chamber, have you ever had an accidental trigger pull or hammerfall without one in chamber? Carry with a snap cap in the chamber. Same question. If you are considering one-in, carry with a cap in and after some time look at yourself objectively and assess your reasoning. If you're safe, well, then you're safe. If carrying one-in makes you think 'oh, ****', then maybe carrying isn't for you at all.
 
Cops carry in Condition 1, and if that is not a good enough reason for a citizen to do so, I don't know what would be. Can anyone cited a police force anywhere in the world that does not carry in Condition 1?

There's a reason carrying a full magazine and no round chambered is called "Israel carry." :smile: Although I do agree with most everything else you said, well put.

Anyway, at the OP, Google "My CCW Shooting AAR" and read the story. I've posted it elsewhere here on the site so I didn't post the link, but it's a first-hand account of a self-defense shooting where deactivating his safety tipped off the bad guy and caused him to start shooting. Now imagine if he had to rack the slide too! He wouldn't have been around to tell us this story and show us these pictures.

I will carry without a round loaded for one purpose and one purpose only: testing a new firearm I bought to make sure it won't discharge in the methods that I carry it, but it only lasts about 2-3 days. It's not that I don't trust the name, the holster or the piece, but firearms and holsters are made by human hands, the same human hands as yours and mine that can easily cause errors. It was also to acclimate myself with the new firearm and holster a bit before causing an ND. Some might not agree with it, but it makes me feel a bit safer and gives me a little piece of mind.

Anyway, if I ever had to use it during the trial period I'd just reach for the other one right by it that's administrative loaded. :laugh:
 
There's a reason carrying a full magazine and no round chambered is called "Israel carry." :smile: Although I do agree with most everything else you said, well put.

Anyway, at the OP, Google "My CCW Shooting AAR" and read the story. I've posted it elsewhere here on the site so I didn't post the link, but it's a first-hand account of a self-defense shooting where deactivating his safety tipped off the bad guy and caused him to start shooting. Now imagine if he had to rack the slide too! He wouldn't have been around to tell us this story and show us these pictures.

I will carry without a round loaded for one purpose and one purpose only: testing a new firearm I bought to make sure it won't discharge in the methods that I carry it, but it only lasts about 2-3 days. It's not that I don't trust the name, the holster or the piece, but firearms and holsters are made by human hands, the same human hands as yours and mine that can easily cause errors. It was also to acclimate myself with the new firearm and holster a bit before causing an ND. Some might not agree with it, but it makes me feel a bit safer and gives me a little piece of mind.

Anyway, if I ever had to use it during the trial period I'd just reach for the other one right by it that's administrative loaded. :laugh:

I've been playing around with my new glock I bought the other day. I like the safety features (that the striker needs to cock back a little further before it can drop) and the confidence of the manufacturer that they state how stringently tested they are, and the only way the firearm would discharge is by pulling the trigger.

If joe blow built me a custom 1911, I wouldn't necessarily trust it not to ND. I think wearing it in condition 1.5 (I made that up - essentially condition 1 without a round in the chamber) for a few days is a sensible idea.

A good compromise might be to carry a double action semi-auto in condition 2. No need to worry about the safety then, not that it's hard to deactivate when you draw, but that 5lbs trigger pull might mean the difference between life and death. :laugh:

I personally think if people believe every second counts, they should be at the range every 2 weeks keeping their skills in check. I know my skills drop considerably when I don't shoot for a 1-2 months.

I'm fairly sure Victorian police carry Israeli style (condition 3) as i've seen training videos where they draw, rack and aim.
 
I've been playing around with my new glock I bought the other day. I like the safety features (that the striker needs to cock back a little further before it can drop) and the confidence of the manufacturer that they state how stringently tested they are, and the only way the firearm would discharge is by pulling the trigger.

If joe blow built me a custom 1911, I wouldn't necessarily trust it not to ND. I think wearing it in condition 1.5 (I made that up - essentially condition 1 without a round in the chamber) for a few days is a sensible idea.

A good compromise might be to carry a double action semi-auto in condition 2. No need to worry about the safety then, not that it's hard to deactivate when you draw, but that 5lbs trigger pull might mean the difference between life and death. :laugh:

I personally think if people believe every second counts, they should be at the range every 2 weeks keeping their skills in check. I know my skills drop considerably when I don't shoot for a 1-2 months.

I'm fairly sure Victorian police carry Israeli style (condition 3) as i've seen training videos where they draw, rack and aim.

I do like the Glocks as well. I carried a Glock 22 for duty for a few years.. it got knocked around a LOT and I never once worried it was going to go off. I like my XDM because it also is striker fired and has the three internal safeties, but it also has the grip safety. I'm kind of on the fence about keeping it or pinning it, but for now I think I'll keep it just for that extra piece of mind. It also has a 5-6lb trigger, but once you get past that small amount of take-up it takes a good amount of force to actually make it go boom, which I really like. It's not like NYPD's 11lb trigggers, but it's still a considerable amount that makes me like it. With that said, I don't like carrying handguns with external safeties for a few reasons, but then again that's just me.

I also believe in hitting the range as much as you can reasonably afford, at least twice a month to stay sharp. I know first hand in a situation you will revert to the lowest form of training\practice you achieved, and hitting the range twice a year won't cut it. I also feel drawing drills, movement drills, malfunction drills, reloading drills and many other things you could very well encounter should be practiced on each trip, not just standing in place shooting at a target. I also practice all of these drills at home with snap caps for extra piece of mind. I do the same with my AR-15, as well as transition drills. That $15 box of ammo is going to cost you a lot less than life in prison or civil lawsuits for shooting a bystander.

Oh, and I won't have Joe Blow make me a custom 1911 in the first place.. all custom firearms are either done up by me or by very reputable companies. :smile:
 
Mots tupperware guns (glock, I had two of them)
when you rack a round the firing pin (striker) is held back. when the trigger is pulled it releases the striker.
so it is "cocked" if a round is in the chamber.


No the striker is not pulled back with the trigger pull. its not on a glock or an XD ( had one of them too)

Actually, you are kinda are wrong. The
Glocks and others with strikers are not fully cocked until the trigger is pulled.
The striker is in a state of partial cock. Pulling the trigger releases the firing pin block and finishes cocking the the striker before it is released.
 
Actually, you are kinda are wrong. The
Glocks and others with strikers are not fully cocked until the trigger is pulled.
The striker is in a state of partial cock. Pulling the trigger releases the firing pin block and finishes cocking the the striker before it is released.

Absolutely right. I can send you a video (trailboss) of my XDM's trigger being pressed. The striker/indicator actually moves back and out about 1/32-1/16" before being released and sent forward. You can also clearly see the striker being fully cocked during the trigger press if you look between the slide and the frame.
 
Partially cocked, I guess that's why most do not have a strike two ability.

As for practice, you should be at the range once a week.
IMO.
Or live in the country with your own range in the back yard. :)

Sent from my HTC Evo 4G using Tapatalk
 
Carry however you want...but Wyatt Earp, Bat Masterson, Wild Bill Hickock, and Buffalo Bill always carried one in the chamber, actually they had revolvers which were always fully loaded, just pull the trigger.

:triniti:
 
Carry however you want...but Wyatt Earp, Bat Masterson, Wild Bill Hickock, and Buffalo Bill always carried one in the chamber, actually they had revolvers which were always fully loaded, just pull the trigger.
Probably not so much.

Hickock carried .36 Navy Colts in which the hammer could be lowered BETWEEN chambers.

The rest in all likelihood carried with the hammer down on an empty chamber, as was common with Colt SAAs at the time, which had no hammer rebound or block.

Unless you're carrying a Colt Navy or a Peacemaker, there's probably no good reason to carry either with an empty chamber or with the hammer down on an empty chamber in a revolver.

By the way, MOST of them carried single action revolvers. With one of those, "just pull the trigger" gets you a rather disappointing result.
 
I'm a supporter of CCW and an Australian who cannot carry.

What I don't understand is why people carry with a round in the chamber. It only takes a second to rack the slide, a lot less time to aim and draw, I just don't understand why people feel the need to do that.

I'd rather not risk the chance of accidental discharge. My thoughts only. Happy to be proven wrong. :)

I disagree.

I could post my reasons but I really don't think you would change your mind regardless.
I'm jaded I guess, because this topic has been discussed at length here before, with pretty much that result.

I'm curious - what training exercises have you done with an attacker rushing you? Or with an attacker already close?
How big is your "safe zone"? (The distance you can draw and fire before you are in a physical confrontation)
 
That's a great video, but how many confrontations involve someone holding a knife threatening to attack you from over 21 feet away? !!!!

As a civilian, if someone was trying to mug me at knife point, i'd give him my wallet, let him walk away, then shoot the fucker!!!

And in no way would that be called justifiable homicide, in any court of law in this country.
 
And in no way would that be called justifiable homicide, in any court of law in this country.

I was kidding....but I don't blame you for taking me seriously.

I disagree.

I could post my reasons but I really don't think you would change your mind regardless.
I'm jaded I guess, because this topic has been discussed at length here before, with pretty much that result.

I'm curious - what training exercises have you done with an attacker rushing you? Or with an attacker already close?
How big is your "safe zone"? (The distance you can draw and fire before you are in a physical confrontation)

I think you could train your whole life to cater for every single foreseeable possibility. At the end of the day, if your attacker initiates the attack, you're pretty much ******!! The video speaks for itself. 21 feet of distance required to draw and fire to stop an attacker. If you're astute enough to identify a threat from that far away, you should be drawing before they charge you. I doubt such a confrontation is ever the case in reality.

Do you wear body armor everywhere you go? Do you mount a camera to the back of your head streaming video to your sunglasses? Do you hire armed bodyguard to walk with you everywhere? Where do you draw the line?

I'm in the camp where I don't feel the need to be overly paranoid. Knowing I have a pistol that is ready to go within a couple of seconds is good enough for me.
 
This training video demonstrates the utter importance of having a round in the chamber and proper distance.
The two key elements needed to survive a violent attack....


Happy to have proven you wrong mate...Cheers. =-)
Yep, The B.G. sure won't let call "TIME OUT!!!"
 

New Threads

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
49,533
Messages
610,704
Members
75,032
Latest member
BLACKROCK6
Back
Top