How many carry a Glock or XD with one in the chamber

I've got an XD-40 and XD-40 SC, both of which are in a gun safe when not on my hip while around the house. When I'm wearing around the house - I'm trying to get myself use to carrying - I've got a round in the chamber. However, I have children in the house and so never leave the weapon just lying around - even on top of a book shelf - nor do I leave a round in the chamber if I'm home during the day and the weapon is in the gun safe. I don't "play" w/the pistols loaded if I'm doing something along the lines of practicing my draw w/a holster (picked up a couple of different types over the last two weeks), but make sure to check the "tells" of my pistols every so often to remind myself that they're loaded.

At night, however, I keep the 4" loaded and ready to go while it's in the safe. Once I leave for the day, I unload it and put it back in the safe. I'd rather not take any chances that one of my children might somehow manage to open the safe while I'm gone. Call me paranoid on that one, but that's just how I prefer to keep the weapons when I'm not home. The magazines are next to the weapon in the safe, just that the weapons are unloaded when no one is home.

I was a bit nervous at first about this line of pistols not having a de-cocking lever, but now that I'm a bit more accustomed to them, it's not quite as much of a big deal. Just making sure that I continue on w/my good habits as I really don't want an accidental discharge to happen - whether anyone gets hurt or not.

.
 
XD - 40, XDm - 40...Always one in the chamber. I understand your need to feel comfortable but a lot can happen in that split second. Including, if it ever went down, being comfortable from that point on.
 
I carry the XD45C mostly and of course loaded. If your are uneasy about this drop the mag and rack the slide and carry it for a day. It will be in the same condition at the end of the day and this will prove to you that the weapon will not discharge unless all the safeties are engaged and the trigger is pulled.
 
Just wondering how many people carry a XD or Glock with one in the chamber? I have a XD but feel very unsafe carrying with one in the chamber. I have several 1911 .45 that I would feel uncomfortable carrying with out one in the chamber.

W.D.Murray,

My question, do you have a ccw license? If so, you already took ccw class and went to the shooting range with NRA CCW Instructor, right. You did well one load in the chamber when the CCW instructor commands "fire", you pulled out your gun and shoot at the center mass, and then re-insert back your firearm in the holster. How do you feel ? Scare or Nada ?

I have no problem with one load in the chamber on my Glocks. :biggrin: FAITH!
 
If you carry a semi auto like a glock you'd better have one in the chamber. Otherwise don't carry a semi auto. It is unsafe to have a piece that cannot be instantaneously depended upon to operate. Revolvers are great carry guns if a chambered semi auto scares you. Just this guy's opinion.
 
If you carry a semi auto like a glock you'd better have one in the chamber. Otherwise don't carry a semi auto. It is unsafe to have a piece that cannot be instantaneously depended upon to operate. Revolvers are great carry guns if a chambered semi auto scares you. Just this guy's opinion.

Can you explain more details ? Why you mentioned don't carry a semi-auto like Glock ?
 
Can you explain more details ? Why you mentioned don't carry a semi-auto like Glock ?

(RRGlock- correct me if I misunderstand you)

He's saying that any semi-auto that has no round in the chamber may as well be a paperweight. Do you carry a paperweight, or leave it on the desk?

OK, so the SAFE options would be:
1) Carry with a round in the chamber
2) Carry a revolver
3) Hire a 24/7/365 Armed Security Service
 
Glock with a chambered round

From reading your post I have the distinct impression that you are frightened about the "danger" of a chambered round in a semi-auto. For that reason I suggested a revolver as an alternate. A loaded revolver has five or six chambered rounds and the weapon will operate if the trigger is pulled. That is the response that you want. A glock or any semi-auto without a chambered round is for all intensive purposes an "unloaded" weapon and useless to you for personal defense. Nothing will happen if you pull the trigger. Your gun will certainly be safe and so will your perpetrator. You will be history. You will never have time to rack the gun and use it if you ever had to. Every police officer that carries a glock or other semi-auto either places a round in the chamber and then inserts his magazine to have a full load, or places the magazine and then racks the gun before placing it in his holster. My advice is unquestionably carry a racked loaded gun whenever it is on your person so it is operational. Your semi-auto must always be racked or have an additional first round manually placed into the chamber. As an additional measure of "safety", whenever I'm packing my glock I have a back-up fully loaded revolver in my pocket just in case the glock ever jams. Every police officer does. Just like every smoker carries two lighters. I sure hope you got my drift. I want you to stay "safe".
 
(RRGlock- correct me if I misunderstand you)

He's saying that any semi-auto that has no round in the chamber may as well be a paperweight. Do you carry a paperweight, or leave it on the desk?

OK, so the SAFE options would be:
1) Carry with a round in the chamber
2) Carry a revolver
3) Hire a 24/7/365 Armed Security Service

Oh I see...I always one round in the chamber my semi-auto glock I loved it
 
Thanks for all the info.

I have started to carry the XD with one in the chamber, I have become very comfortable with it. I posted this question when I was just starting to carry the XD and not the 1911, it was just the difference in the safeties between the 1911 and XD that had me nervous. I just felt the 1911 was a safer gun but now have no worries about the XD.
 
Thanks for all the info.

I have started to carry the XD with one in the chamber, I have become very comfortable with it. I posted this question when I was just starting to carry the XD and not the 1911, it was just the difference in the safeties between the 1911 and XD that had me nervous. I just felt the 1911 was a safer gun but now have no worries about the XD.

does your firearm has hammer on semi-auto ? Some Kimberly, and other guns have a hammer on semi-auto. Be carefully !! Bang ! Glock has no hammer, just pin. But keep finger and object away from the trigger. :biggrin:
 
Good to read you are now comfortable carrying with a round in the chamber. Flip side of comfort is ALWAYS!!! be sure your piece is UNLOADED by first removing the magazine and then MANUALLY OPERATE THE SLIDE BACK to release the chambered round and then TURN THE GUN ON THE SIDE AND DUMP THE CHAMBERED ROUND INTO THE PALM OF YOUR FREE HAND. Now your gun is unloaded and safe for storage. Removal of the magazine alone does not unload the chambered round the weapon. Another useful and safe method of loading is to do it outdoors with the muzzle of the gun pointed at the soil. On very rare occasions the sheer vibration of racking the round first being chambered could cause the weapon to fire. This is most probably caused by a substandard cartridge. Most police agencies advise racking outside and always pointed down. I always follow the methods I am suggesting that you follow as well. Always be safe; you can never be sorry.
 
On very rare occasions the sheer vibration of racking the round first being chambered could cause the weapon to fire. This is most probably caused by a substandard cartridge.
I've never heard of this happening. Do you have any links to any stories where this has happened?
 
Of course one in the hole

I carry one of 3 glocks with one in the chute- a 29, a 26 or a 19- all have one in the chamber. No need to not have one ready to go, glocks have the trigger safety- i feel that as long as you are conscience of how to operate your weapon, you will not have any mishaps-
 
No, I do not have any links on this other than to tell you that my police department put out an advisory on this many years ago. I can tell you that this incident actually happened to a highway patrol colleague and it is a very bad event if it ever happens. He was suiting up in his basement where his duty equipment/safe is located and his glock fired upon racking. I always insert a magazine with several rounds and rack the gun (outside of course). I then remove that magazine and replace it with a fully loaded one. The result is one round in the gun and a full magazine on board, two spares on the belt and a back-up detective special revolver, holstered, in the pocket. That is duty carry power. It is also good off duty defensive protection.
 
On very rare occasions the sheer vibration of racking the round first being chambered could cause the weapon to fire.

No, I do not have any links on this other than to tell you that my police department put out an advisory on this many years ago. I can tell you that this incident actually happened to a highway patrol colleague and it is a very bad event if it ever happens. He was suiting up in his basement where his duty equipment/safe is located and his glock fired upon racking.

Don't take it personally, because I'm not attacking you but that's a load of bull and that advisory must have been put out by someone that has as much firearms knowledge as I have about nuclear physics and string theory combined. Like very little- if any.

Vibration will NOT set ammunition off.

If vibration would set ammunition off, prop driven airplanes would have never had machine guns mounted on them. Most guns were mounted in the engine cowling of fighter aircraft until just before WWII and that would be one of the places most subjected to vibration on the aircraft. In my experience, LEO's that actually know something about firearms (opposed to those that think because they carry one for a living they know all) are a small minority, so I'd take that advisory with a grain of salt.

The compound used in primers is sensitive to sudden increases in pressure against it. (Not steady pressure, otherwise you couldn't press new primers in when you are reloading ammunition nor could you get new ammo for that matter.) Unless you smack it around or you focus all the pressure on a very small area of the face of the primer and push on it hard, it's actually quite stable.

If the gun when off while chambering a round, comes down to an issue with the gun ( worn sear, high spot or bur on the breechface around the mouth of the firing pin hole, ... to name just a few possibilities), an issue with the ammunition (high primer most likely) or operator error (like not keeping his booger picker off the trigger).
 
I have both a Glock 19 and a XD40. They are stored locked in a safe with no round in the chamber; they are carried with a round in the chamber. Both the Glock and the XD are designed with internal safeties and meant to be carried with a round in the chamber. Anyone who fears their Glock or XD will go off by itself has the option of leaving the chamber empty until they need it loaded, (hopefully they will also have the time to do a proper rack, a good feed, and still have time to engage the target.
 
Have XD Aways Have One In The Chamber

Just my two cents but not having one in the chamber could cost you your life. If you consistently practice safe firearm handling skills having one in the chamber is not an issue. Having to clear clothing or concealment (under duress) rack a round, (again under duress) could cost you the split second you needed to survive.
 
No, I do not have any links on this other than to tell you that my police department put out an advisory on this many years ago. I can tell you that this incident actually happened to a highway patrol colleague and it is a very bad event if it ever happens. He was suiting up in his basement where his duty equipment/safe is located and his glock fired upon racking. I always insert a magazine with several rounds and rack the gun (outside of course). I then remove that magazine and replace it with a fully loaded one. The result is one round in the gun and a full magazine on board, two spares on the belt and a back-up detective special revolver, holstered, in the pocket. That is duty carry power. It is also good off duty defensive protection.

I heard this was due to chambering the same round over and over again. I was instructed by a Glock armorer to not keep using the same round in the chamber after 5 times either shoot it out or replace it.

Sorry I didn't pay attention to exactly why chambering the same round would eventually make it go off. I just remembered to remove the round after the fifth time chambering it.

I should have payed attention it seems that this only causes the bullet to be set back in the case and could cause your gun to blow up or that is for Glocks. Some one else said that it can cause the primer to get deformed and if your gun has a firing pin instead of a striker it could cause the round to fire.
 
Just wondering how many people carry a XD or Glock with one in the chamber? I have a XD but feel very unsafe carrying with one in the chamber. I have several 1911 .45 that I would feel uncomfortable carrying with out one in the chamber.

newb!
 

New Threads

Members online

No members online now.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
49,533
Messages
610,704
Members
75,032
Latest member
BLACKROCK6
Back
Top