I'm guessing that your best resource in this matter would be your local sheriffs office. It seems to me that if you restricted her access to your weapon, whether it be locking it away or on your person, it would not be any different than having children in the house. Just a guess.
Now there could be some loop holes around this but I'm not sure. I would have them call there local LEO and ask. Every state is different about this. You can also look up your states gun laws and find out what it says about restricted persons and see what it defines possession as.
This is a federal law and you would have to comply with both State and federal law. Since they are infact prohibited persons by federal law State law really doesn't matter because they would be in violation of federal law by default.
This sounded like a hypothetical question but if it is not or becomes reality later just like any legal matter I would suggest contacting a lawyer to make sure. But I am almost 100 percent sure that the felon would be in violation of the law if the gun is in the house no matter which state you live in.
The felon would not be in violation as long as the gun owner were present or the guns were locked up one way or another. Either would be OK. This was a federal ruling from a long time ago.
Could you cite the case please? I am not questioning your word just curious to see it.
I think I saw a case before that said the opposite. Even if the owner was there unless it was on there person the felon still had access to it. And locking it up, if it was a key lock unless the key is locked some how then the felon is in possession of the key (can keep going in circles here) and if a combination lock there is no way the felon can prove he didn't know the combination. The last part really bugged me because the felon wouldn't have to prove anything the burden of prof lies with the prosecution.
I tried looking for the case I was reading before but could not find it, if you could point me to one that says otherwise please do so. Like I said that combination part really got to me and I couldn't believe it when I read it.
I would not ask a leo. They do not seem to be that versed on the law do the lack of retraining as laws change.
I would contact a lawyer that specializes in 2nd amendment.
Never, ever , under any circumstance do you ask a cop for legal advice. If the answer is that important to you pay the consult fee and ask a lawyer
Here we go again. No thread can be complete without having at least one anti-cop post...
Apparently it is better to pay the rich (insert expletive here) lawyer some money to tell you what is good for you rather than ask our hard working boys in blue, or do the research on your own.
As always, talk to a lawyer to make sure that you have all the legal specifics figured out. You can marry, it's just a high stakes game that you are playing and there is no margin for error.
And if the cop gives you bad information on the phone, do you REALLY think that is going to help your case in court?
Would you ask the oil change guy at Jiffy Lube to rebuild your NASCAR racing engine for you? It's not cop bashing. It's telling the truth about what can be reasonably expected of a person given their profession. How many cases get tossed out of court because the charges were improper? You question two cops about what is legal or illegal and eventually you are going to get a differing opinion on something.
Cops are not legal experts. That's why governments have prosecuting ATTORNEYs. The prosecuting attorney sorts out the evidence the cops give them and decide if their case has enough merit to it to go to court or not. Cops aren't legal experts - otherwise they would have to go to four years of law school to become one.
Here we go again. No thread can be complete without having at least one anti-cop post...
Apparently it is better to pay the rich (insert expletive here) lawyer some money to tell you what is good for you rather than ask our hard working boys in blue, and/ or do the research on your own if you dont get a solid response from the police. Sure not every cop is an expert on the most confusing laws, but to dismiss them as unknowing and untrustworthy is over the top.
B2Tall:246473 said:As always, talk to a lawyer to make sure that you have all the legal specifics figured out. You can marry, it's just a high stakes game that you are playing and there is no margin for error.
Yeah. If I remember correctly the firearm must either stay in possession of the legal owner or be secured in a way that the felon doesn't have access to it.
I am more so advocating to do research on laws on your own. But hey this is America, and apparently we shouldnt have to do anything on our own because thats what we have "experts" for. I love "experts" telling me whats best for me, dont you?