One in the chamber.... or not

Listen guys. I looked at croutes other posts and definitely don't see a troll. I saw legitimate questions and some good points. He's new so cut him some slack. Save the troll accusations for the provocateurs who come here speciically to raise your ire, defend the anti-gun liberal mindset and generally aggravate you with their poltitics. If you cry "wolf" every time you don't agree with someone that makes you... well, I won't say it.

On second thought, yes I will... ignorant!

The reason I labeled croute a troll is because he's been given the info he asked for by many people and still wants to beat a dead horse. His mind is obviously made up so why ask over and over for more explanations?

Croute, if you are not trolling us, then I wholeheartedly apologize. But, this thread has probably run its course I think.

iKonixx
 
Listen guys. I looked at croutes other posts and definitely don't see a troll. I saw legitimate questions and some good points. He's new so cut him some slack. Save the troll accusations for the provocateurs who come here speciically to raise your ire, defend the anti-gun liberal mindset and generally aggravate you with their poltitics. If you cry "wolf" every time you don't agree with someone that makes you... well, I won't say it.

On second thought, yes I will... ignorant!

The reason I labeled croute a troll is because he's been given the info he asked for by many people and still wants to beat a dead horse. His mind is obviously made up so why ask over and over for more explanations?

Croute, if you are not trolling us, then I wholeheartedly apologize. But, this thread has probably run its course I think.

iKonixx

He already confessed to trolling. :rolleyes:
 
You guys really crack me up. I'm actually loving the fact that you think I'm a troll. I honestly had to look up the definition of a troll. And I can see why you think I am. I certainly fit the profile. I know I won't be able to convince you otherwise. Again, for those of you who say I should have been convinced by now just because everyone's saying I should have a round chambered- I repeat, just saying I should doesn't prove a thing. Some of you have offered what you considered a reason why I should, but I believe I've shown the flaws in your claims. If you're unwilling to accept my rebuttals, well, I guess I can also say that I'm beating a dead horse.
 
The argurment turns moot when your talking about a revolver; however I believe first aqnd foremost it is a matter of personal preference.

As an instructor, I teach my students that the safety on a firearm is a mechanical device, and like any mechanical device, it is prone to wear and potential failure over time and use.

I also teach my students that practice is not just for the range, but also they must practice and become proficient on drawing their firearm from concealment. Sadly most students advise that they do not practice the draw much if at all.

To those students I advise them not to carry cocked and locked as they are more likely to shoot themselves in the leg during the draw than be shot by some thug. Following the draw it takes not more than 1 second to rack the slide.

First and foremost when teaching should be the skill levels and capabilities of our students. I believe it would be wreckless to advise a student who is not proficient in the draw to carry with one in the chamber.
 
Nightmare45, I just gave you an out, do you really want to go there? Just an advanced warning- I can easily put 20 holes in that story without thinking much.

Start shooting up till about 1997 I was a paramedic in Texas, Houston area. PS: Guy we worked on is still alive, not the only one, between gun shots, stabbings, heart attacks and delivering children very busy area, later in life moved to working transport ambulance and working concerts, auto racing. Point of story which you seem to miss is unless you are highly skilled and practiced with racking a round into empty chamber, you will be slow, I gave you an out when I said carry as you wish, you ask for an opinion about no round in chamber and were given numerous answers most was carry a round in chamber. One last time, carry however you wish, just my opinion, you are the one who will find out if you can rack a round faster than you can be stabbed or shot. God Bless, unless you prefer something else. You may verify my claim with the Texas Department of Health Services, last name Godbold..
 
I wasn't going to chime in on this discussion but I feel I must.... Two things happen in an armed confrontation. 1.) Everything you think will happen doesn't. 2.) Anything that you don’t think will happen does.
Every advantage however slight must be utilized to protect oneself or loved ones from harm. Proving to yourself that you have the wherefore all of a trained Mossad agent isn't in the picture. Remember one thing: Those guys get killed too... Mainly by what they don't expect or see.

All of us train with a paper target or a partner in hand to hand training in controlled settings. Neither of those things are out to kill us or do bodily harm. The guy with the knife flailing around like a live octopus with one thing on his mind and the motivation to do great bodily harm does... He is different and we need to take every advantage to prevent him from hurting or killing us. He will need to be subdued in a manner that will not allow him to continue his assault. If that means shooting him so be it.
I was taught and trained that once an attacker gets inside arms length it can be anybody’s game no matter how hard you train. You don’t know what he knows. You don’t know his level of training. Just because he is a bad guy at that very moment doesn’t mean he doesn’t have a well trained past. All you know is he is motivated to harm you and he will use any means to do so. You must use every advantage you can to prevent this from happening.

Carrying a round in the chamber is what guns are designed to do. That is why there are safeties and loaded chamber indicators… If you are in a controlled environment like an office you could carry on empty chamber. The possibilities of an armed individual charging you unexpectedly are next to non existent. On the street, in a convenience store, at an ATM, that is a whole other matter. Anything can happen there and having that split second advantage may save your life.
I carry concealed with a round in the chamber. It is my advantage. Sometimes I carry a snubnose in my pocket without a holster. I know it is there and I know it is loaded. If I ever have to use it I will just shoot through my jacket pocket, again it is to my advantage. I understand a firearm is a dangerous tool just like any other dangerous tool and should be treated with respect.

I know it is an old worn out cliché but I would rather be judged by 12 than carried by six.
Carry however you want but remember whatever happens it will be nothing like you thought it would be and hopefully are not maimed or killed to learn from your experience.

PS: I am not an armchair quarterback…. I have danced with the devil twice and have the scars to prove it…..
 
I repeat, just saying I should doesn't prove a thing. Some of you have offered what you considered a reason why I should, but I believe I've shown the flaws in your claims.
Here it is laid out easy for YA.. When involved in a situation that requires you to draw your weapon please tell me ONE thing that would justify the wasting of the time required to rack a slide? The truth is you do not listen. If you actually went to a SINGLE live training exercise you would learn how wrong you are the first time out. You ignored that after I said it TWICE. So as stated on this subject your are in fact a troll. Simply disregarding provided information because you do not agree with taking the research and facts behind it is foolish. As stated this is America and as long as your carrying legally you can do it however you wish even if it is simply stupid to do so in the manner you state. I will ask you this ask ANY pro involved in a shooting be they military or police if they would every carry with a empty chamber. Then ask any instructor the same question. Then ask anybody who carries a firearm for defense. Let me know how many say sure that a great idea.
 
Glad some of you seem to be getting value from all of this. To all of you saying I'm not listening, I hope you realize I have been all along. Listening in here means reading each post and making a decision based on the content. I have read each post. I've responded to many of them. If I didn't respond, it probably means I got nothing out of it and had nothing to say about it. I've responded to some others that were absolutely ridiculous because I just couldn't let it go. Are you listening? I would say most of you aren't because I keep seeing the same thing over and over from you. Once again, I'm NOT the original poster of this thread!! And, telling me a hundred times that I should just have a round chambered because it's best is not going to convince me of anything. My feeling is a lot of you just have a round chambered because that's just the way it's supposed to be. I also feel many of you think you're infallible and take the "this could never happen to me" approach. I don't care if everybody thinks differently that I do. I'm not going to jump on the bandwagon just because I'm the only one that doesn't do things the way everyone else does. However, I do ask myself "why?" And seriously want to know the answer. That's why I'm here.

That is the category I fall into. Every bit of training that I have ever had - military and civilian - taught by people who know what they are doing, tells me that's the way it's supposed to be. I carry with a round in the chamber confidently. Not because "it could never happen to me" (whatever "it" is supposed to mean). But because I know that in the manner I carry it, my weapon will not discharge unless I draw it, disengage the safety, and pull the trigger.

It's not a Glock, it can't go off all by itself.
LOL!! Sorry, I couldn't resist.
 
To: maine04619- I don't know how many times I need to state my case on that one, but here it is again, just for you: I've already said that it will only take me about 1 second more than you to draw and rack at the same time. If I'm in a situation that 1 second makes a difference, I would not draw my gun, chambered or not. I also stated that if your life depends on just 1 second and you draw your gun, there's a very good chance that the bad guy can take it from you and use it against you.
 
OK everyone, I feel it's time for me to say this. I'm using complete sincerity, I truly mean it. Forget everything that's gone on in here and just pay attention to this one post of mine. I harbor no ill feelings towards any of you. I know I took some shots back at some of you, but admit it, you deserved my response. I certainly don't want enemies with guns! If I lived back in the day when the Earth was flat, I would have been the only one, or one of the few, that believed it was round. Now, before you go off again, I'm not saying I'm right here. Just using that as an example of how I'm one against many. If you've been following my posts, I never, ever said you guys are wrong. That's not my mission. My mission is to find out why you guys think I'm wrong. There's a difference. Please do me a favor and keep an open mind. Not for my sake, but for yours. I promise you and open mind is much better than a closed one. I give that advice to all my friends. Peace to all.
 
OK everyone, I feel it's time for me to say this. I'm using complete sincerity, I truly mean it. Forget everything that's gone on in here and just pay attention to this one post of mine. I harbor no ill feelings towards any of you. I know I took some shots back at some of you, but admit it, you deserved my response. I certainly don't want enemies with guns! If I lived back in the day when the Earth was flat, I would have been the only one, or one of the few, that believed it was round. Now, before you go off again, I'm not saying I'm right here. Just using that as an example of how I'm one against many. If you've been following my posts, I never, ever said you guys are wrong. That's not my mission. My mission is to find out why you guys think I'm wrong. There's a difference. Please do me a favor and keep an open mind. Not for my sake, but for yours. I promise you and open mind is much better than a closed one. I give that advice to all my friends. Peace to all.


Ok,
First thank you for clarifying your good will & intentions.

If I may, you are asking us why we think you're wrong. We don't think your wrong; "IF" that is the way you feel most comfortable.
(Carrying the way you feel the most comfortable is fine with everyone here.)

The reason you have been getting flack from some people is the fact that you are not offering any counter reasoning to why you "THINK" you are right; and you seem to be unwilling to learn from the advice you have been given by PROFESSIONALS & more experienced members here in this forum.

A whole lot of people come to forums like this to seek KNOWLEDGE. The knowledge they find in places like this could save a life. But, it could also cost someone their life if they get & use something suggested that is wrong & dangerous.

So, why don't you share your knowledge & try to convince us that carrying plus 1 is wrong. But, please be aware, if someone acts on the advice you share here & it costs someone their life, you will have to live with that. (That's why everyone here stresses "Professional Training".)

I personally do not know one single "professional" firearms instructor that agrees with carrying a firearm with an empty chamber. (UNLESS, the person is not quite comfortable with plus 1 carry.)

That being the case, every instructor I know will advise a person that is uncomfortable with Plus 1 carry to get the necessary training to get comfortable with it; because the SD benefits from plus 1 carry far out away the risks of carrying with an empty chamber.

I'll continue to keep an eye on this thread. But, now I want you to try to convince the rest of us why you are right & we are wrong.

(Ready, set go!)


-
 
I've already said that it will only take me about 1 second more than you to draw and rack at the same time.
...unless you find yourself in a life or death struggle with two drug addled simpletons bent on beating you into a stupor... or worse.

Saying it don't make it so.


If I'm in a situation that 1 second makes a difference, I would not draw my gun, chambered or not.
Then you're probably never going to draw it no matter what.
I also stated that if your life depends on just 1 second and you draw your gun, there's a very good chance that the bad guy can take it from you and use it against you.
The morons in the gas station in Dayton tried to get the victim's gun. One of them just got a couple of bullets. People with .452 blow holes tend not to take ANYTHING from ANYONE.

You "state" a lot of things, NONE of them borne out by real experience.

You remind me of the kid in usenet rec.guns who insisted that he didn't need a real gun because the FAKE gun he carried would "protect" him.

Make believe is a REALLY lousy survival strategy.

Delusion is a LOT worse.
 
I think even after all the retoric, I have to stand by my original post, if not comfortable carrying chambered you maybe should not carry the gun at all, you must be confident enough in your abilitys to properly handle a gun, and that includes one thats ready to fire
 
To: maine04619- I don't know how many times I need to state my case on that one, but here it is again, just for you: I've already said that it will only take me about 1 second more than you to draw and rack at the same time. If I'm in a situation that 1 second makes a difference, I would not draw my gun, chambered or not. I also stated that if your life depends on just 1 second and you draw your gun, there's a very good chance that the bad guy can take it from you and use it against you.

I shoot a drill where I fire five rounds in one second. It is not hard to do with a gun that shoots single action. So, if I am determined to defeat you, I can put five holes in you while you are racking your slide. If, as you say, you choose not to draw and rack your slide, I just don't have to shoot so fast to put those five holes in you.

Now, perhaps the bad guys don't practice that drill, but you get the point.

As I stated earlier, if your training and skill level does not allow you to carry a fully loaded gun, then you should work to attain that necessary skill level so you can adequately protect yourself and your loved ones. Or don't carry a gun at all.

Have you gone through the thought process to determine whether you are willing to employ deadly force at all? If not, you must prepare yourself for that eventuality in you carry a firearm.
 
To: maine04619- I don't know how many times I need to state my case on that one, but here it is again, just for you: I've already said that it will only take me about 1 second more than you to draw and rack at the same time. If I'm in a situation that 1 second makes a difference, I would not draw my gun, chambered or not. I also stated that if your life depends on just 1 second and you draw your gun, there's a very good chance that the bad guy can take it from you and use it against you.

Can you do it with one hand?
 
I shoot a drill where I fire five rounds in one second. It is not hard to do with a gun that shoots single action. So, if I am determined to defeat you, I can put five holes in you while you are racking your slide. If, as you say, you choose not to draw and rack your slide, I just don't have to shoot so fast to put those five holes in you.

Now, perhaps the bad guys don't practice that drill, but you get the point.

As I stated earlier, if your training and skill level does not allow you to carry a fully loaded gun, then you should work to attain that necessary skill level so you can adequately protect yourself and your loved ones. Or don't carry a gun at all.

Have you gone through the thought process to determine whether you are willing to employ deadly force at all? If not, you must prepare yourself for that eventuality in you carry a firearm.

I haven't bothered to read all of the contentious "back & forth", but this is by far the best perspective that I've read.

Assuming that there will be enough time ahead of an armed confrontation to bring your pistol to a condition of readiness is a recipe for utter failure. If you are already "behind the curve" (the one who must react to an assailant who has initiated a life-threatening assault) the time you think that you'll have to spend chambering a round is, and should be, the time you should be spending returning fire or, if possible, seeking cover.

Action beats reaction. It's immutable and it's the law. :smile:
 
Kudos to CharlesMorrison! Finally somebody came up with a decent answer to my question of safety in a situation where you're jumped with a bullet chambered. Perfect answer? Probably not for most of you, and I have no doubt EVERYBODY isn't going to have THAT gun if they're going to have one chambered, but still a great answer. If you have a gun with more than one safety feature, I wouldn't question your decision to chamber a round. Way to go Charles!

Thank you. I also forgot to mention that the SR40 has a chamber loaded indicator. It is a visual aid as well as tactile. You can run your finger along the top of the slide and feel that it's loaded.
Just wanted to mention that.
 

New Threads

Members online

No members online now.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
49,533
Messages
610,704
Members
75,032
Latest member
BLACKROCK6
Back
Top