One in the chamber.... or not

One area of thought is that the chambering of a round could be considered an "aggressive" gesture. Best always to leave one in the chamber.....

I got a chuckle out of this one!

I can't think of a defensive situation where I would draw my weapon without the intention of firing it. If I'm not going to shoot, (I am not convinced that I or a loved one is about to DIE) it stays holstered.
I can assure you that me racking the slide isn't nearly as aggressive as what's gonna happen a split second later.
 
I'm going to agree with you guys that I should stop. Obviously you're not able to convince me that I should have a round chambered. BTW I'm grown up- 46. An "idiot?" I believe my college degree would satisfy most that I'm not. I never said I was an expert, just that I had enough training. I came here to possibly learn something that I didn't know. I thought the thread was interesting and gave my opinion. When I was challenged, I thought, gee, it seems everyone in here disagrees with me, I wonder why. Maybe they know something I don't. Let's see if I can learn something. Well, I didn't learn much. I'll move on.
Unless your degree in in real world shooting situations then it is irrelevant. A college degree may offer you more education in a subject or two it does not make you smarter then everybody as to many seem to think. If you did not learn then you where not reading the responses. You ever get to Maine let me know you can come by my place and I will show you in 5 minutes why your stance on carrying a weapon without ti being ready to use is seriously flawed. One better I could get out the Simunition kits and show you first hand. A few blue dots and you will change your mind real fast. Ask yourself this simple question why does nobody else carry this way? Why do the police not carry on a empty chamber? You want to carry this way that is your right. Unfortunately it seems the ONLY way your going to learn is when you actually NEED your weapon and your not going to be able to use use it because it will not be loaded. Of course it will be to late by then..
 
I'm going to agree with you guys that I should stop. Obviously you're not able to convince me that I should have a round chambered. BTW I'm grown up- 46. An "idiot?" I believe my college degree would satisfy most that I'm not. I never said I was an expert, just that I had enough training. I came here to possibly learn something that I didn't know. I thought the thread was interesting and gave my opinion. When I was challenged, I thought, gee, it seems everyone in here disagrees with me, I wonder why. Maybe they know something I don't. Let's see if I can learn something. Well, I didn't learn much. I'll move on.

You don't learn because you don't listen. And yes, please stop. Do you know how much time I just wasted at work reading post after post waiting to see if the light would ever come on? Man, it was like bad T.V.:-)
 
We went from carrying with a round in the chamber to college degree, amazing, okay, I have a college degree and a cocked and locked 45 on my hip as I type this. You ask for an opinion, here it is, don't need the 45, will have cut your throat with my folding knife while you are racking a round into your chamber, take you gun away and use it on you. Get the drift, skill mean practice, practice, muscle memory. Racking a round is slow, but as I have said before you carry how you wish to carry. I think your family would rather have you around to raise the kids than dead or in the hospital. Maybe the medics should have a key to their gear carried in the glove box when they need a compress for your serious knife wound. One last time, racking a round into the chamber is SLOW. Please prove to me that you are not.
 
OH MY GOSH, you guys just won't let me stop. I seriously need to unsubscribe from this thread. You guys scare the heck out of me. (Don't take that as a compliment, it's not meant to be one.) I don't know whether to laugh at you or cry. Please, please, please tell me you know the definition of "idiot!" Really, just lie to me so I can feel better about the people in this forum. Navycdr, I don't think James Holmes is an idiot, in fact, I think he might be smarter than me. Mentally unstable? ABSOLUTELY! I'm neither an idiot nor am I mentally unstable, thank god. Deanimator, I think anyone further ahead of me in life can't be an idiot, although I could be wrong. The only exception might be someone fed with a silver spoon and living off their parent's money. Nightmare45, learn proper English and I might pay attention to your comments. YIKES people!
 
OH MY GOSH, you guys just won't let me stop. I seriously need to unsubscribe from this thread. You guys scare the heck out of me. (Don't take that as a compliment, it's not meant to be one.) I don't know whether to laugh at you or cry. Please, please, please tell me you know the definition of "idiot!" Really, just lie to me so I can feel better about the people in this forum. Navycdr, I don't think James Holmes is an idiot, in fact, I think he might be smarter than me. Mentally unstable? ABSOLUTELY! I'm neither an idiot nor am I mentally unstable, thank god. Deanimator, I think anyone further ahead of me in life can't be an idiot, although I could be wrong. The only exception might be someone fed with a silver spoon and living off their parent's money. Nightmare45, learn proper English and I might pay attention to your comments. YIKES people!
Now, now.... Scared??? Remember, "sticks and stones..."
 
Yes, veeeerrrrry scccaaaarrred. I'm more scared of idiots with guns than the criminals. I've decided to become a real troll now. I think I'll be much better off.
 
Not too long ago, a guy pumping gas in a Dayton gas station was jumped by a couple of room temperature IQ druggies. They hit him from front and rear simultaneously.

By his own admission, if he hadn't had a round chambered, they probably would have prevailed over him. Instead, one got shot twice in the abdomen and the other headed for the hills.

No self-defense plan I will ever have will involve assuming that an assailant (or multiple assailants) will LET me chamber a round.

The only way your gun can go off "unexpectedly" is if you don't expect it to fire when the trigger gets pulled.

Even if he couldn't get his EDC uncovered, he still had a formidable weapon in his had. The gas nozzle. Spray them in the face with fuel. That'll give them enough pause to get to your weapon.
 
Yes, veeeerrrrry scccaaaarrred. I'm more scared of idiots with guns than the criminals. I've decided to become a real troll now. I think I'll be much better off.

It's your choice how you carry but, to be honest, your responses scare me more than anything anyone has said to you. You kept asking for reasons to carry with one in the chamber, you were given reasons, many of them, but you choose to ignore them, apparently. Nobody here wants to see you dead but many are concerned about new people reading your posts and making the same decision, which many feel is the wrong one. I'm 63 with a college degree, a Ruger SR9c, 10 + 1 and 17 on the side. Good luck!
 
Even if he couldn't get his EDC uncovered, he still had a formidable weapon in his had. The gas nozzle. Spray them in the face with fuel. That'll give them enough pause to get to your weapon.
That's my plan when I visit my relatives in Apartheid Chicago. By law, I have a duty to be unarmed, and if at all possible, a victim. That won't stop me from using my vehicle or gasoline as a weapon if necessary.
 
I for one didn't call anybody an idiot here. We should respect each other's opinions, no matter how wrong we think they are. But I also honestly think enough valid points were made on why carrying with an empty chamber is just simply not the most effective way of carrying to let that subject rest.
 
I have to hand it to you , croute. I haven't seen a troll this good in a long, long time. Very well done.

Edit to actually add to the discussion: I always carry +1 because it's the smart thing to do.
 
There is no such thing as an Accidental Discharge. An accident is, for example, the engine falling of of an airliner and hitting your house, and that is probably not an accident since someone messed up somewhere.

What we have is Negligent Discharges and they are caused by negligence on our part. I have never heard of a gun laying on a table and suddenly discharging a round with no external influence.

My feelings about this whole discussion is if you don't feel that your training and experience level won't allow you to carry a round in the chamber, then you should not carry a round in the chamber. But don't try to justify that action by saying it will be OK in the long run because that is just not correct. You will not be able to get your gun into action as quick as is sometimes needed. It might work out OK, but you are at a disadvantage because the guy you are defending yourself against will most certainly have a round in the chamber.

If you are at that point where you don't feel your training and skill level will not support carrying a round in the chamber, then you should get the training and experience that will fully allow you to protect yourself and your loved ones. Only you can make the assessment of your training and skill level, but don't rationalize away either your lack of training and skills or your fears by saying not being fully prepared to protect yourself or your loved ones will probably work out OK.
 
Yes, veeeerrrrry scccaaaarrred. I'm more scared of idiots with guns than the criminals. I've decided to become a real troll now. I think I'll be much better off.

Are you related to any of the following resident Trolls? :p

Kwimby
Shoobee ( I call him Trollbee)
OtisM

So we can now add croute to the list of resident trolls?

17+1 FTW!
 
OK, you guys suckered me back into this. Good conversation going now. My apologies to those who think I'm wasting bandwidth. To those who posted videos: they haven't changed my thought process. In the first couple, I believe I would have successfully drawn my weapon & racked my slide, and fired in time in one of them, in the other I would not have drawn my gun, chambered or not. In the last video: although I can't tell what's happening off screen to the right, I'm pretty sure I wouldn't have drawn my gun in that situation. I may be wrong, but I believe most of you would draw your gun in just about any situation. I think that's a big mistake. Have you not thought about diffusing the situation and get out with your life? For those of you saying I should get training, I've had enough training and it hasn't changed my stance. Could I use more? Of course, everybody can benefit from more/different training. Would more training change my mind, no. Here's why I'm still not convinced: nobody provided an answer to my scenarios where I believe you would be at a disadvantage having your gun ready to fire. If you have, I must have missed it. Once again, if you're jumped unexpectedly and draw your weapon, you have a very high chance of having it taken and used against you. In that case, if it's ready to fire, you're in immediate trouble and I'm not. If you don't think someone can get your gun from you because you're highly trained or big and strong, think again. I've been trained to get a gun from a bad guy, it does work and it doesn't matter how big he is. So, if you still think I'm wrong, you'll have to provide more compelling evidence that I'm better off with one in the chamber.

You keep changing the scenario. First you say there are times when you shouldn't draw your gun (which I wholeheartedly agree with). Then you manufacture a scenario where you draw your gun, when you shouldn't have. So which is it?

Are you going to leave your gun holstered in the event the bad guy is too close when the situation develops (as you should)? In it's holster, the weapon is safe whether there is a round in the chamber or not. Starting with the weapon in it's holster, in a struggle it is much easier for me to keep the weapon holstered (even one handed) than it is for someone else to take it out. At least in the manner I carry - concealed on my waist at 3:30.

At this point I am not in a gun fight, I am in a hand to hand fight. Or even better, I'm not in a fight but asses and elbows on my way out of there.

If I have a round chambered, the distance where I can draw and stop an aggressor is smaller. And I have one less thing to think about. Simpler is better. The fewer actions I have to take, the better. Personally I like that, and for me carrying with a round in the chamber is an acceptable risk.
 
I'm going to agree with you guys that I should stop. Obviously you're not able to convince me that I should have a round chambered. BTW I'm grown up- 46. An "idiot?" I believe my college degree would satisfy most that I'm not. I never said I was an expert, just that I had enough training. I came here to possibly learn something that I didn't know. I thought the thread was interesting and gave my opinion. When I was challenged, I thought, gee, it seems everyone in here disagrees with me, I wonder why. Maybe they know something I don't. Let's see if I can learn something. Well, I didn't learn much. I'll move on.

I have an option for you to consider.
I carry a Ruger SR40. The weapon has a manual safety, a trigger safety (just like a Glock) and a magazine disconnect safety.
With multiple safety functions, to me , it is a very secure weapon to carry with one in the chamber.
I would hope that the manual safety would buy me some time to regain control of the weapon. Worst case, I eject the magazine and it renders the weapon useless.
Just food for thought...
 
1) It's not that you may be wrong 'Croute', You 'are' wrong.
2) Your belief is not our 'reality'.
3) You are making many 'asinine assumptions' that the majority of us here would rather draw & use our sidearms instead of de-escalating or 'diffusing' a threat situation. Whenever you Assume, you make an A$$ out of U & Me.
3) The majority of us here do not 'have a very high risk' of ever allowing ourselves to be 'jumped unexpectedly' because of our own situational awareness. Some folks like yourself may tend to walk around with your heads in the clouds while dreaming about gummi bears and rainbow colored butterflies, but I can assure you that the majority of us here do not.
4) Yes, I still think you are wrong -correction- Actually, I 'know' that you are wrong.
5) We don't have to provide any more 'compelling evidence' for you because you are clearly not here to actually 'learn' anything, you are simply here to 'bloviate'.
6) 'I believe' that you are just another forum Troll imvho.
7) (Have a nice day). :dance3:

Well said, but you're wasting your time with Inspector Clouseau. There is no one so blind as he who will not see:rolleyes:
 
I just popped back in to see how this discusion was going. 22 pages. That's amazing.
What a waste of time! I doubt anyone really changed his/her mind.
 

New Threads

Members online

No members online now.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
49,533
Messages
610,704
Members
75,032
Latest member
BLACKROCK6
Back
Top