New York laws

[BC1]

Just spoke with my buddy. The decision affects the NYS Penal Law for the entire state not just the district where the ruling came from. Here's a link to the actual decision ---. Link Removed

CORRECTION!!!
.
The ruling further compromises decent people. At what point is some judicial district line crossed causing an arrest?

 

[jrs]

CORRECTION!!!
.
The ruling further compromises decent people. At what point is some judicial district line crossed causing an arrest?

So, are you saying that the ruling only applies in the judicial district in which it was made? If so, we'll need to have judicial maps to see where we can legally load more than 7 rounds. This is UNBELIEVABLE!!!! If the law is Constitutional.... then the law applies to the whole state, BUT... if found to be UN-Constitutional.... then it only applies to the judicial district????? WTF!!!

Where and when can we expect to hear what the ruling REALLY means?

 

[2Awarrior]

The NYSRPA just emailed me that they'll be sending out a summary of what the ruling means to us and outline what their next court action will be.
I am beyond furious about this.

 

[2Awarrior]

Here's the content of that email -

"Ladies and Gentlemen,

As promised from the start your NYSRPA will be filing the attached Notice of Appeal in Federal Court today, our second step on the way to the U.S. Supreme Court. I know many of you were disappointed by what you perceived as a huge loss on New Years Eve but that is simply not so. In the coming days we will release a statement regarding the decision and our future intentions.

We thank you for your continued support.

Tom King"

Big f---ing deal.

 

[nogods]

So, are you saying that the ruling only applies in the judicial district in which it was made? If so, we'll need to have judicial maps to see where we can legally load more than 7 rounds. This is UNBELIEVABLE!!!! If the law is Constitutional.... then the law applies to the whole state, BUT... if found to be UN-Constitutional.... then it only applies to the judicial district????? WTF!!!

Where and when can we expect to hear what the ruling REALLY means?

Judicial districts are of equal weight. A decision in the WDNY is not binding on the EDNY, the SDNY, or the NDNY.

Were it otherwise then the first district judge to rule on an issue would be the controlling decision, thereby emasculating the equivalency of the districts.

Same is true for the Circuit Courts of Appeals.

 

[2Awarrior]

Anybody see this? - got it from NYSRPA -

"Some district attorneys in New York, including Monroe County's Sandra
Doorley and William Fitzpatrick of Onondaga County, had questioned
whether the ruling was applicable to state courts or if it was
binding outside of the state's western district.

But Gov. Andrew Cuomo and Kehoe indicated that the ruling is the law,
unless it is overturned. The state is appealing the decision."

"Kehoe said the association recommended enforcing the
10-round-capacity limit, not seven.

"Our best analysis of it is it probably applies statewide," Kehoe
said Monday. "There's been a court of competent jurisdiction that
said parts of it are unconstitutional. If (sheriffs) aggressively
enforce something that they've had notice is unconstitutional, then
we think they expose themselves to liability."