How many carry a Glock or XD with one in the chamber

Don't take it personally, because I'm not attacking you but that's a load of bull and that advisory must have been put out by someone that has as much firearms knowledge as I have about nuclear physics and string theory combined. Like very little- if any.

Vibration will NOT set ammunition off.

If vibration would set ammunition off, prop driven airplanes would have never had machine guns mounted on them. Most guns were mounted in the engine cowling of fighter aircraft until just before WWII and that would be one of the places most subjected to vibration on the aircraft. In my experience, LEO's that actually know something about firearms (opposed to those that think because they carry one for a living they know all) are a small minority, so I'd take that advisory with a grain of salt.

The compound used in primers is sensitive to sudden increases in pressure against it. (Not steady pressure, otherwise you couldn't press new primers in when you are reloading ammunition nor could you get new ammo for that matter.) Unless you smack it around or you focus all the pressure on a very small area of the face of the primer and push on it hard, it's actually quite stable.

If the gun when off while chambering a round, comes down to an issue with the gun ( worn sear, high spot or bur on the breechface around the mouth of the firing pin hole, ... to name just a few possibilities), an issue with the ammunition (high primer most likely) or operator error (like not keeping his booger picker off the trigger).

From what I know of the supposed ( accidents) with Glocks, the problem more often than not is caused by a out of place Booger finger, and most don't even realize it, and I cannot completly fault the LEO, his or her departments improper training is most likely at fault, and then there is the Officer that views his weapon as a tool nothing more, kind of like a mechanic and a wrench or screwdriver, and the weapons use becomes something that does not get the thought and care it should, and one day the booger finger is not where it should be and oops, the dam thing just went off:angry:
 
How about this for a suggestion for those that do not carry a round chambered...

Get a reloader to put a primer in a piece of empty brass for you. Breech load the empty brass in the chamber and then insert a fully loaded magazine in the gun. If your gun has a negligent discharge it will only pop the primer in the loaded brass and do nothing else. If you want to shoot, when you rack the slide, the empty brass will simply be ejected and not affect the functioning of the gun in those circumstances.

Then, in the years that you carry the primed brass around in your gun, you will know how many negligent discharges were prevented.
 
If you have a holster that covers the trigger and you keep your finger of the trigger while you draw it's quite safe. There's a reason so many PDs use Glocks.
 
If you have to stop to load your gun, it kind of defeats the purpose of carrying one. It should be ready if and when you need it.
 
my glock19 and xd45 always have a round in the chamber,when and if a bad guy comes at you there probably won't be enough time to chamber a round,one less thing to worry about
 
I carry an XD-40SC every day and everywhere it's legal to do so. ZERO issues with one in the chamber. At first, I was a bit worried about it, but after just a couple of days it's become second nature. I keep my Bugger Hooker off the Bang Button and all is well.
 
I don't have my CWP yet. However When I carry around my home, or on family property, I have one in the chamber. I know and understand its very different to carry in public and the like, but When I first started carrying around property I was allowed to carry, having one chambered did feel a little "weird" for lack of a better word, but after a few days, it wasn't anything. I feel quite comfortable with today's modern striker fired handguns with one chambered.
 
Carry a Glock 21. Always one in the pipe. I didn't used to but only because I was afraid of the gun. Once I learned exactly how all the safties work I had no problem carrying chambered.

Most modern firearms are safe to carry chambered. It's the safety between the ears that is prone to failure.
 
My XD SubCompact in .40 is always ready to go. I will carry any weapon with one in the chanber or i won't carry it. I would carry with zero safety's and not worry about it. I have trained to handle a weapon, any weapon, safely. It is not the weapon that makes carring a particular gun unsafe, it is the carrier that makes the weapon unsafe. I can't even reach into my pocket to get my keys without getting hung up because my finger is sticking out!, let alone my holster!

Carry the XD with one in the pipe or carry a wrench :wacko:
 
I really like my Glock23 glad I had it when I got arrested a year ago, better they had a $500 handgun then my $900 HK. Long story made short this dude accused me of pointing my Glock at him, he saw it while I changed clothing at the Gym had me arrested. A year later a jury found me not guilty Attorney cost me $1,500 11 trips to the Court House. Getting my Glock back from the Police property room took five trips and many many phone calls.
Then I had to have a background check and wait two weeks. Now I was informed I could not have the gun and Ammo. at the same time. Had to make another trip the next day for my Hornady TAP Ammo. Fool in property room asked if I just wanted them to trash it. Oh yeah I bet they would trash it.
 

New Threads

Members online

No members online now.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
49,533
Messages
610,704
Members
75,032
Latest member
BLACKROCK6
Back
Top