You can't beat the super tuck for comfort. I have been carrying a kimber ultra carry II in one for two years. The only proplem is the kydex has been ruff on the finish. I carry every day and i know all holsters will wear the finish. Representatives from Kimber recommended using leather instead of Kydex, so i ordered a Milt Sparks VM II holster for my kimber. It took 21 weeks to get this holster. Looks great and is as comfortable as the super tuck. I had my kimber refinished so I will see how the finish wears with the all leather holster. You cant go wrong with either one.