Hi James..I've never shot either of those..but I'd like to suggest a 9 if interested..the great thing about firearms is there are so many to choose from, and and every firearm fits each of us differently, the 9 I chose I am extremely satisfied with, for many reason, and I think that is key, the firearm that you choose should be the one you find the most reasons (both quality and quantity of reasons) for liking it..I went with the Springfield XD9 Subsompact..I didnt want a carry gun with a manual safety, just one extra step to try to remember in a high stressed moment, that could affect the outcome of life or death, the safety feature of this gun is the combination of grip safety levers on the back of the grip and small one on the trigger(will not fire unless they are both compressed). It also has a chamber indicator on top of slide and firing pin indicator on back of slide, where as in the dark you can feel the gun is loaded and ready to fire. So from a safety standpoint it's top notch for carry. Of course you have to love the physical attributes (how it looks) which I absolutely love, all black, great sights, (3-dot) which are interchangeable with tritium or fiber optic if ya choose, has melonite finish very durable compared to bluing (or you can choose stainless, which looks awesome). The barrel reminds me of a little cannon, the thickness is almost 1/8 of an inch thick, very stout. Now for the best part, this gun is so well balanced while shooting, can get back on target very quickly..I've shot many different brands and models and calibers and fell in love with this one..immediately.. Btw, out of the box with 2high capacity magazines, a 13 and a 16, which was just an added bonus.. As far as then2 you are trying to choose from, try finding or asking shooting ranges if they have either or both you can try..try to find the one with the most reasons you like and appreciate... I'm sorry if I turned this into a novel but I hope I was helpful