Problems With My Smith & Wesson Bodyguard 380

White1

New member
BACKGROUND

I bought the weapon last spring and have since put, maybe, 1,200 rounds through it. I have had to send it back to S & W twice because the laser screw periodically came loose and jammed the slide. That problem was never really fixed, but I learned to work around it by tightening the screw every 100 rounds or so. Not an ideal solution, but I can live with it.

After the second trip to S & W, the weapon usually did not lock back after I'd fired the last round. Again, not an ideal situation, but one with which I can live.

Today, after putting 150 or so rounds through the weapn, the take-down lever broke in half. It did not come out of the weapon, but the part of the lever on the outside of the gun broke in half. The 380 is headed back to S & W.

I'm getting to the point at which I don't have much confidence in the weapon, but I'm not quite ready to get rid of it. The Bodyguard 380 is my only experience with a mouse gun, and I very much like the fact that it has an external safety (I'm not looking to start a debate about safeties on carry weapons; I've read those threads), I like its weight, and I like its concealability. Plus, the person at the gun store who handles returning the weapon suggested to me that I'm firing it too much.

QUESTIONS

First, am I firing it too much? I hope not because, frankly, I need the practice. Yes I could practice with another weapon, but I want to trust the gun I carry, not the gun in my safe.

Second, are problems of this type and frequency just to be expected with a mouse gun?

Third, has anyone ever heard of a take-down lever simply shearing in half? This seems bizarre to me, and I wonder if it's not indicative of a larger problem.

Finally, might stepping up to an LC9 solve my problems? I might accept the slight loss of concealability and increase in weight that such a move would require, but not if I'm going to have to keep sending the weapon back for repairs.

Sorry for such a long post, but that little gun is putting me through my paces.
 
S&W have always been very good guns, and they usually stand behind them. It seems like you may have got a bad one. I don't believe shooting it a lot should be a problem. I am not fond of .380's . I would go to a 9mm if you decide to change guns. I am considering getting a small 9mm to replace my Mod. 60. I have narrowed my list to the S&W M&P Shield, Walther PPS, and the Kahr CM9. I like what I've read about the Shield but haven't found one at any of the Gun Shops around here to feel how the grip feels in my hand.











































rev
olver
 
I sold my S&W Bodyguard because the laser was next to impossible to turn on. Both on switches had to be pushed very hard at the same time. The person I sold it to also sold it less than 2 months later for the same reason. If you want a 380 with a external safety take a look at a Sig P238 or a Colt Mustang. I have the Sig with factory a wraparound rubber grip and 7 shot magazine. I don't have a laser on it, but it can be fitted with one specifically made for it.

I don't have any experience with the LC9, but I do have a Walter PPK 9mm and I love it.
 
My brothers wife has a S&W Bodyguard .380 and hasn't seen an issue with the items you described. But I agree with John and you may have gotten a bad one. So, I carried a Ruger P95 9mm for the first 4 years as a Conceal Carry (CC) and it was a great gun. It never jammed or has any issues what so ever and since then I've moved over to a Sig Sauer P250 Sub Compact (SC). It's much smaller and you can change the caliber from the 9mm to .40 S&W, .45ACP, .357 and they finally came out with a .380 change kit. So, that's always an option at that point.

But you have to look at a different prospective...

What happens if you're in a situation where you have more then 1 attacker? You can't defend 7 rounds of .45 ACP against 3 to 4 attackers. My recommendation is stick with a 9mm and you can carry extra couple of mags with you. It's all to what your comfortable with and what you can afford.

What Gun To Purchase: Consider the 9mm Pistol for Self-Defense?

Above is a really good informational on why a 9mm is a good carry and it has some valid points..just my .02 cents
 
Using Ruger LC9 and LCP here. Have had them for a few years and no problems with either one.
I also use the Taurus PT145 Pro, slightly wider than the LC9/mag extension, has the same length and width. 10 +1 rnds of 45.
 
Here's my suggestion: Bersa Thunder .380. Easy to conceal. Absolutely reliable. The barrel is fixed, which has proven to be an asset to accuracy. And the price is right... about $325 or so.
I suggest checking one out before you opt for anything else... that is, if you're going to stay with the .380.
If you're going to look at a 9mm, check out the Bersa Thunder 9 Ultra Compact. Still easily concealed and absolutely reliable. Also, for about $150 bucks or so, you can convert it to .40 S&W Cal by purchasing a barrel, magazine, and slide from Eagle Imports.
Just a suggestion... :o)
 
BACKGROUND

the person at the gun store who handles returning the weapon suggested to me that I'm firing it too much.

Sorry, I don't have any experience with this gun, but the comment that you are shooting it too much just does not make sense, especially when shooting a gun from a quality gun maker. Now if S&W sends you a letter stating that you are shooting the gun too much, then time to dump it.
 
My dad sold his. He had several ftf and fte. He did not use the laser much when practicing. I have a 238 and my opinion is that it is a much better gun. Try the LCP TCP and the Bersa if you just have to have a 380. My dad bought a shield after he sold his BG. Try several of the 380's and 9's if possible.

Sent from my DROID RAZR using Tapatalk 2
 

New Threads

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
49,523
Messages
610,661
Members
74,992
Latest member
RedDotArmsTraining
Back
Top