Good Planning or Good Luck?

Eidolon

Alter Kocker
Got an email today W/ a story about a guy that survived a home invasion because he and the wife had a plan.

I have to give the guy props on two points 1.) He had a plan and 2.) He and his wife drilled it and used it when needed.

But I also have a critique, and I'd like to get some feed back. Here's the story

Toney neighborhood, early evening, man & his wife just finished dinner. Man's in the living room in a recliner, wife is in the bathroom.

Man's sitting in the LR with a small dog the dog gets up and walks into the kitchen. About that time the man here's a loud crash assumes the dog knocked something over and gets up to investigate, as he approaches the kitchen he comes face to face with a crackhead armed an aluminum baseball bat. This is where the emergency action drill commences.

Man turns and runs, yelling the emergency codeword (special word that would never come up in normal conversation such as "gorilla butt". At the sound of the word wife comes out of the bathroom and runs to the bedroom husband right behind her. BR has been made into a safe room. Plan was they both hole up in the safe room, wife grabs XD45 off the nightstand, and husband grabs the 870 and gets ready to defend the door while wife is calling 911.

The plan worked ok except for wife almost shut husband out of the room.

Bad guy is locked out in hallway starts kicking door. Husband takes up shot gun and after a few minutes pounding on the door the crack head runs away. The police arrive and said crackhead is found down the block wandering in a daze and arrested.

Like I said, they had a plan, they practiced it and, ultimately, it worked.

My critique

when husband moved toward the kitchen he moved away from his defensive weapon and his safe room. This was an older couple what if the BG beat him to the room? What if Wife locked the door W/ husband on the wrong side? (As almost happened) What if God forbid the husband sat in the chair a few seconds longer because he assumed the noise was generated by the dog?
 
I'm not going to fault the guy when it all turned out alright in the end. Though I wouldn't have waited a few minutes while someone pounded on my bedroom door before firing...

I will say this - for you personally - if you feel that moving toward a noise to investigate is the wrong move because you are further away from a weapon, you may need to rethink that part of your plan. My family's plan is quite a bit different because there are kids in the equation, so everyone's got to figure out a few specifics on their own.

Personally I always carry. Even sitting on the couch vegging out or rough housing with my kids on the floor. Some people make a point to stash weapons in various places in their house so that don't get separated from a weapon. Do what works for you.
 
A critique is an opinion, not a series of what-if questions. In your own words, "The plan worked." Forget except. Dynamic, unexpected situation, and their plan kept them alive.
 

New Threads

Members online

No members online now.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
49,525
Messages
610,668
Members
74,995
Latest member
tripguru365
Back
Top