I had pretty much the same problem--could not choose between G30 & G36. My solution? I en ded up getting both. Both are plenty accurate and flawlessly reliable. They take turns as my EDC weapons. I have +1 extensions on most of my G36 mags, so I usually use them when carrying the 36, but if wardrobe dictates (because of longer grip with the +1s), I can use the stock mag. When carrying the G30, I use the stock mag and have a G21 mag available as well. I use a Shielded Holster Phalanx, but most of the time I use a MIC that I've modified by adding a J-hook to make it tuckable. Hope this info helps.