Choosing my CCW - Need suggestions/opinions

Hey guys, First time poster, long time lurker. I'm 23 years young, been into shooting but not heavily, I have some rifles I like to plink with but now that I'm coming back to America and that I'm of legal age in my home state of PA I want to get a pistol, I've been doing my homework for about 5 months now, when I was back home 3 months ago I held and fired a few pistols. Right now these are my options I've come up with:

Glock 26 - my only gripe is the fatness and I'm an extremely slender person, short and skinny.

Shield 9mm - Nothing but good things

Walther PPS (M1) - I like the paddle release on it, I know that's a reason people don't like it, but not I)

Glock 43

Kahr Cw9


I know it's not really narrowed down haha but I really like all these guns, I would like some people with more experience than I to give me some pros and cons. My biggest concern is concealment and reliability. This may seem really stupid, but I look as if i'm 16, if someone happens to see my printing, they may think I'm a nut case or something... but that's beside the point. What do you think is the best choice? If there is a gun you think belongs on that list please tell me about it!
 
Ruger LC9s Pro.

When you get back to PA find a gun shop/range that has the guns you like and shoot each of them again. I don't own a 9mm but am fond of fondling the Ruger SR9c. If I were of a smaller stature I'd go for the LC9s Pro. I'm not a fan of S&W and Glocks require me to adjust my grip to get a good sight picture. My guns fit me so that when they come up it the sights are aligned. When you find one that does that you'll understand. I CC a Kahr but it's not 9mm.

You never stated outright, though I believe it was implied, that your gun would be for concealed carry. There are few dual purpose handguns so a target gun might have different characteristics than what you would want to carry. My first handgun was a large caliber mid sized and is concealable but my carry handgun is a micro large caliber. I still practice with both to stay proficient.
 
All of the weapons you listed have pretty good reputations for reliability. There are probably 50 or more other makes/models that the same could be said of though. The equation is not just about the manufacturer or dimensions of the weapon you end up buying and/or carrying. There are intangibles and raw data to consider, which opens up your evaluations to an extended and in-depth study before you can really articulate in a few short sentences what it is you're in the market for. Or not. When I was your age I got my first permission slip after buying a High Standard Mark IV in .22 mag from a friend/co-worker for real cheap. It was a revolver that held 9 rounds. Great little gun. Nothing special, but it served my purposes at the time. A year or so later when I started making real money, I started buying guns two and three at a time, rifles, shotguns, handguns, large caliber, small caliber and everything in between. At one time in my early to mid 20s I had over 100 handguns. My "research" back then consisted of buying something, shooting it, practicing drawing from concealment, and then selling it if that "research" didn't produce my desired results. I am a big guy, but back in those days I was so skinny that I had to run around in the shower to get wet, but concealment has never been that big of a challenge for me, including back then.

I'm down to a little more than a handful of guns these days. I open carry almost all the time, but I still have the gun that I trained with and carried the most when I was still concealing. My daily carry (open) is a S&W 4563TSW. You'd be hard-pressed to find that weapon on anyone's "greatest carry .45 of all-time" list, nor would I put it on such a list of my own. It's just the .45 that I ended up keeping, and like that old High Standard, it suits my purposes just fine.

My conceal carry gun is also one which doesn't appear on many lists, an alloy frame CZ 2075 RAMI in 9mm that I've had for around 10 years I guess. Both it and my .45 are DA/SA mechanisms. Both have an external safety. The .45 has a hammer-drop manual safety, and the 9mm's safety can only be actuated with the hammer cocked, so someone coming from being used to a 1911-style action (carried "cocked 'n locked") could carry the RAMI the same way without having to transition from that to using the double-action pull as their first shot, and single-action every round thereafter.

I'm not a brand, caliber, or type-of-trigger-mechanism "shamer," nor am I a fanboi of any of the same things. I've got Craftsman, Milwaukee and Snap-On tools in my toolbox, and Stihl, Husqvarna, Troy-Bilt and Poulon gas-powered lawn and garden tools and chainsaws hanging all over the garage walls. I use 'em all. None are my "favorites" overall, just one might serve one purpose better than another, so that's what I use when working on that purpose. My guns are the same way now that I don't really collect anymore. My .45 was too big and heavy to carry comfortably and concealed, but generally-speaking, I prefer the bigger caliber, longer sight-radius and the way it fits my hand over the RAMI, so for purposes of concealed carry it didn't suit my purposes and the RAMI did/does, and vice-versa for open carry.

I said all that to say this; You're probably going to spend a lot of money because of going through a lot of guns, holsters and accessories, before you can really say what works best for you. Nobody here can give you the answer to that question until you yourself can articulate all the varied reasons that you like or dislike a particular brand, size, caliber or the pretty important consideration, "feel" of weapons you've actually fired quite a bit. You will learn how to effectively conceal the Glock 26 if that's what you buy, but you may just find that effective concealment isn't the only data-point that you end up choosing a gun that you will stick with for a long time on. Or not. The 26 may be perfect for you. Only trial and error will answer that question though.

Oh, and welcome to the site and good luck.

Blues
 
Just for comparison, I am 5'7", 130 lbs, with a 32" waist. I regularly carry a Glock 19 concealed. A also carry a Glock 20 concealed when hiking. The width of the gun can be ignored when concealing it with proper clothes, such as a heavier shirt hanging over the gun. The length of the grip, i.e., height of the gun this the actual problem, as the end of the grip prints. A good holster and belt that keep the gun close to the body solve that problem to a certain degree.

A note on the Glock 26. The standard magazine capacity is 10 rounds, but you can get a 12-round magazine that has a pinky rest. Also, the 15-round Glock 19, 17-round Glock 17, and the 31- or 33-round Glock 18 magazines work. You can carry a Glock 26 with 12+1 rounds and a 17-round backup magazine, which gives you a total of 30 rounds.

Also, understand that the gun itself is not everything. This was my reply in another thread:

My recommended shopping list:



Another recommended option is the S&W Shield 9mm with XS Big Dot Sights.

In any case, go to a gun range that rents guns and try them out.
 
If I were in your shoes I'd pick up a Shield, a couple of magazines and an adequate holster. Shield is a good gun and it's worth the price and it solves the immediate problem, you now have a gun that you can make work for carry.

Now that you're not under any kind of "I need a gun now pressure" you can take time to do your research, try different guns, look around at holsters and find out what works best for you (It might be the Shield it might not) and get that.
 
Kahr CW9.
Slim, light with eight shots on tap.
Has a chamber loaded (tactile) indicator and is rated for plus p ammo.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 
Best thing to do is go to a range that rent different weapons. Try them out till you find one or two, or heck like me I found three. and purchased all three. But that was me. Anyway, take your time and do try many different brands and calipers. While I do like 9mm mine are 40 caliper except for the revolver that was given to me and it is a 357. But each brand has many things the same yet are so different. Depending on your hand size could make a difference on which one works for you. But if you find one that you really like but the grips are not quite right there may be after market grips or additions that can make all the difference in the world. Anyhow, Take you time and research, shoot and compare. Each of us have our preference but again it is what works for us. What we like may not be what you are looking for or would like. Happy shooting and welcome to our little world here :D
 
Bersa BP9cc ---- Ruger LC380 ------ Ruger LCR in .22 mag ------ Kel Tec P-32 for a pocket gun. :big_boss:
 
I don't think anyone is going to be able to tell you what handgun is going to work best for you.
Handguns are like boots. One size does not fit all, so I'm in agreement with steveksfc, Go to a range with a large selection of rentals and try as many as you can until you find the boots that fit you best.
 
Hi Jerry, have you picked anything yet? If not can you provide any further preferences you looking for in your CCW such as size, capacity etc? You mentioned the S&W shield which is an excellent gun. For me I was looking for that compromise in getting something smaller then a full sized gun but also not going down to low in capacity. I loved The Shield but the capacity was a bit lower then I wanted. S&W also has a model M&P9c which is just slightly bigger but holds 12+1 rounds. This is what I chose.
 
There is no magic gun or magic bullets. One person may feel confident carrying a .22lr handgun, another may want a .45 acp. Only you can determine what is right for you. Shoot as many different handguns as possible. But, be honest. If you do not handle recoil well, do not force yourself to use a .357 mag. The whole success comes from shot placement, putting rounds where you want. Take a good look at all these calibers. .22lr, .22 mag, .32 acp, .380 acp, 9mm, .38 these are all the calibers that many people use for carry/home defense. Now if you handle recoil well, you may want a larger caliber. But don't just try and be Dirty Harry or John Wayne, be smart and use a caliber you shoot well.
:dirol:
 

New Threads

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
49,530
Messages
610,685
Members
75,029
Latest member
fizzicist
Back
Top