The Cell Pal was the first holster I bought when I started carrying conceled. While it is a great idea I could never make it work right. I could never get any of my cell phone cases to fit it right so I could draw without just removing my cell phone case from it. They didn't have any cases for sale that would fit my phone so nothing seemed to work. I did try several things and even if I did get something to stay on it I could never seem to get it to go down over my belt unless I undid my pants. It never worked for me the way it shows on their website. From the choices you gave I would go with the Super Tuck. My finances were a little tight at that time (I wasted too much on the cell pal) so I went with the Kholster and have been very very happy with it for a lot less $$$$$.