B&t mp5 high speed magazine loader

[Ringo]

B&T MP5 HIGH SPEED MAGAZINE LOADER

(Scroll down for video)​

B&T MP5 HK94 HIGH SPEED MAGAZINE LOADER, BT-231230, Brugger and Thomet, RTG Parts​

 

[Fallschirmjäger]

"OOhhhh, I need that for my Glock."

No, you don't. It only works on alternate feed magazines, not single position feed.

 

[phillip69]

Sorry fallschirm, that is why there are engineers in this world, to make the impossible possible. It can be done, just no one has put the effort into making it so yet.

 

[Fallschirmjäger]

Sorry to rain on your 'if you can imagine it, you can do it' parade but.... it's physically impossible to load a standard (single position feed, e.g. Glock, S&W, H&K, Ruger, etc.) pistol magazine by pressing the cartridges against the feed lips.

The item works perfectly for what it was designed to do, load magazines with 'dual feed positions' as illustrated by the right side magazine below.

But no amount of wishing is going to allow a cartridge to be vertically pushed past the feed lips of a magazine such as the one on the left. Those lips are what is holding the cartridge in the magazine in the first place.






Engineers know you can't subvert the rules of physics... no matter how hard you wish upon a star.

 

[phillip69]

Sorry again, you are still wrong.

I own an Ar-15; I built my own speed loader for it. I understand the two types of feeds.

This type of comment/thinking is why a lot of people are not engineers; they just say 'it cannot be done.'

I never once said or even suggested that the speed loader would be a straight in shot like the AR-15 model. See? An engineer looks at the problem differently. Of course it will require a slide in from the side; maybe a 45 degree motion or or or. That does NOT mean it is not possible to design. If I felt I needed it more than my perfectly acceptable to me Uplula, I would design it.

 

[Fallschirmjäger]

If I'm wrong, then prove it. I'll wait.

But I ain't holdin' my breath.

 

[JimmyRocks]

I'm excited to see if this has an outcome or if this it where it ends......

 

[phillip69]

.22lr Magazine Speed Loader - YouTube

When an engineer decides he needs one for his glock, it will be designed. And it will be more fluid than the above example.

 

[SR9]

I have a speed loader that came with my Ruger SR9. The mags have such a strong spring, it's almost impossible to thumb load. Works great. Loads 17 rounds quickly.
I've never had a .22LR that needed a speed loader. Usually an easy load.

 

[Ben Glassco]

Engineer Response

@ Fall and Philip... it is possible to engineer a B&T style super speed magazine loader for a glock or Single load magazine, however it requires thinking outside of the box. Not only would you have to redesign the loader, but you would need to create a uniquely designed magazine modified specifically to work with the loader. This is easier then it sounds, I came up with the following designs on my Note 5 in 10 minutes and I'm not even an engineer (probably should have been). I'm new to this, so I don't know how to post pics, but you can check out my designs by downloading the pdf file I uploaded to my Dropbox from this link:
https://www.dropbox.com/s/9a7eygba45rr3r0/Note012816_2.pdf?dl=0

 

[Ben Glassco]

Please check out my reply to Fall & Philip in the thread.

 

[bofh]

@ Fall and Philip... it is possible to engineer a B&T style super speed magazine loader for a glock or Single load magazine, however it requires thinking outside of the box. Not only would you have to redesign the loader, but you would need to create a uniquely designed magazine modified specifically to work with the loader. This is easier then it sounds, I came up with the following designs on my Note 5 in 10 minutes and I'm not even an engineer (probably should have been). I'm new to this, so I don't know how to post pics, but you can check out my designs by downloading the pdf file I uploaded to my Dropbox from this link:
https://www.dropbox.com/s/9a7eygba45rr3r0/Note012816_2.pdf?dl=0

First bold part: No-one is going to buy a magazine loader that requires modified magazines. Magazines are the Achilles heel of a semi-automatic firearm. F...ing around with them is asking for trouble.

Second bold part: Use the "Insert Image" button. PDF files can contain malware.